[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

TO sum up tonight's events:


Marry The Night
Born This Way
Government Hooker
Judas
Americano
Hair
Scheiße
Bloody Mary
Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Bad Kids
Fashion of His Love
Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)
Heavy Metal Lover
Electric Chapel
The Queen
Yoü and I
Edge Of Glory

10 out of 17 left


Till The World Ends
Hold It Against Me
Inside Out
I Wanna Go
How I Roll
(Drop Dead) Beautiful (ft. Sabi)
Seal It With A Kiss
Big Fat Bass (ft. Will I Am)
Trouble For Me
Trip To Your Heart
Gasoline
Criminal
Up N Down
He About To Lose Me
Selfish
Don't Keep Me Waiting
Scary

13 out of 17 left

1+1
I Care
I Miss You
Best Thing I Never Ha
Party (ft. Andre 3000, Kanye West)
Rather Die Young
Start Over
Love On Top
Countdown
End Of Time
I Was Here
Run The World (Girls)
Lay Up Under Me
Schoolin Life
Dance For You
Dreaming

12 out of 16 left

AND NOW:


Marry The Night
Born This Way
Government Hooker
Judas
Americano
Hair
Scheiße
Bloody Mary
[strike]Black Jesus † Amen Fashion
Bad Kids
Fashion of His Love
Highway Unicorn (Road To Love)[/strke]
Heavy Metal Lover
Electric Chapel
The Queen
Yoü and I
Edge Of Glory

7 out of 17 left


Till The World Ends
Hold It Against Me
Inside Out
I Wanna Go
How I Roll
(Drop Dead) Beautiful (ft. Sabi)
Seal It With A Kiss
Big Fat Bass (ft. Will I Am)
Trouble For Me
Trip To Your Heart
Gasoline
Criminal
Up N Down
He About To Lose Me
Selfish
Don't Keep Me Waiting
Scary

8 out of 17 left

1+1
I Care
I Miss You
Best Thing I Never Had
Party (ft. Andre 3000, Kanye West)
Rather Die Young
Start Over
Love On Top
Countdown
End Of Time
I Was Here
Run The World (Girls)
Lay Up Under Me
Schoolin Life
Dance For You
Dreaming

5 out of 16 left

[Pedro]

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

After looking at What Songs are being eliminated from each artist its obviously Britney Stans run this motha.

I actually disagree. Big time. I think it'll be very close between them all

[Ra2]

Originally posted by A Bomb

Thank teh lawd I'm not the only one that thinks its terrible.
I gave it a 0.

I'm not sure what I gave that particular song, and I'm trying my best to remember.


I don't think I gave any song below a 4 that I can remember.

I know I gave 3 10s to FF/4 and 4 10's to BTW.


But other than that, it's a bit fuzzy.

[Venus]

I still cannot DEAL with Partyin' With Jesus being so low.

[GaGaFan]

*discovers You and I was already eliminated*



Going to bed before I bust a blood vessel.

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

AND NOW:

Government Hooker
Judas
Scheiße
Bloody Mary
Heavy Metal Lover
Yoü and I
Edge Of Glory

Till The World Ends
Hold It Against Me
Inside Out
I Wanna Go
How I Roll
Trip To Your Heart
Criminal
He About To Lose Me

Love On Top
Countdown
End Of Time
I Was Here
Schoolin Life

Voters have done wrong by 4 and Born This Way, but I'm good with most of what's left from Femme Fatale.

[A Bomb]

Originally posted by Ra2

I'm not sure what I gave that particular song, and I'm trying my best to remember.


I don't think I gave any song below a 4 that I can remember.

I know I gave 3 10s to FF/4 and 4 10's to BTW.


But other than that, it's a bit fuzzy.

Really? No zeros
I gave BTW like 2 0's
FF like 4 or 5
But I also Gave FF 2 10's
& BTW 3 10's

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by supaspaz

Voters have done wrong by 4 and Born This Way, but I'm good with most of what's left from Femme Fatale.

!!!!
All that's left from FF are the better songs from the album.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

AND NOW:

7 out of 17 left


8 out of 17 left


5 out of 16 left

So ATRL feels that BTW was most polarizing, with its "worst" songs ranked as some of the lowest and it's "best" songs still in the running.

"4" is middle of the road, most of the songs eliminated in the 30-20 range.

& FF has better variety of high quality tracks.

tbh, this matches up well with ATRL's general taste but doesn't match at all with the comments at the beginning of this thread where it was pretty unanimous that FF was the lesser of the albums.

idgi. but Someday I Will Understand.

[MP2K]

I should have known and voted.

But Schoolin' Life

[Ra2]

Originally posted by A Bomb

Really? No zeros
I gave BTW like 2 0's
FF like 4 or 5
But I also Gave FF 2 10's
& BTW 3 10's

I don't think so.

As of right now, I don't think any of them deserve a 0.

High points of FF:
HIAM
Trip to your Heart
Low points of FF:
Big Fat Bass (too repetitive...I love the part towards the end though)
How I roll. (It's cute, bubble gum pop perfection, but I'm not here for it).

High points of 4:
I was Here
Love on Top
Low Points of 4:
Party (Just not into the genre)
Rather Die Young (just never clicked)

High Points of BTW: (as a gaga stan more so than a brit or bey stan this is harder).
The Edge of Glory
Judas (even if it's a BR clone/wanna-be).
Low Points of BTW (so easy):
Americano
Black Jesus + Amen Fashion.

[Pedro]

Originally posted by Ra2

I'm not sure what I gave that particular song, and I'm trying my best to remember.


I don't think I gave any song below a 4 that I can remember.

I know I gave 3 10s to FF/4 and 4 10's to BTW.


But other than that, it's a bit fuzzy.

I said before my lowest scores went to the Unicorn song and to Beyoncé's Party and it was a 5. I think it's just going over the top giving lower than that they are not that bad so I love that u didnt give 0 to any song as well

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

tbh, this matches up well with ATRL's general taste but doesn't match at all with the comments at the beginning of this thread where it was pretty unanimous that FF was the lesser of the albums.

I think it's the nature of the game. We're rating the songs individually, so I'm not surprised that the high energy, single-ready tracks of Femme Fatale would jump out more at the average voter. 4 is definitely an album experience, and Born This Way's filler is too polarizing.

[A Bomb]

Originally posted by Ra2

I don't think so.

As of right now, I don't think any of them deserve a 0.

High points of FF:
HIAM
Trip to your Heart
Low points of FF:
Big Fat Bass (too repetitive...I love the part towards the end though)
How I roll. (It's cute, bubble gum pop perfection, but I'm not here for it).

High points of 4:
I was Here
Love on Top
Low Points of 4:
Party (Just not into the genre)
Rather Die Young (just never clicked)

High Points of BTW: (as a gaga stan more so than a brit or bey stan this is harder).
The Edge of Glory
Judas (even if it's a BR clone/wanna-be).
Low Points of BTW (so easy):
Americano
Black Jesus + Amen Fashion.

Oh you're one of the Black Jesus haters.
The songs I gave 0's to, are the songs I deleted from my itunes.
Song with high points were
Inside Out
He About To Lose Me

Heavy Metal Lover
Scheisse
Bloody Mary

Countdown
Love On Top

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by supaspaz

I think it's the nature of the game. We're rating the songs individually, so I'm not surprised that the high energy, single-ready tracks of Femme Fatale would jump out more at the average voter. 4 is definitely an album experience, and Born This Way is too polarizing.

Yea, that makes sense. It would explain while LOT is in the running over "I Miss You" & "I Care."

[Green]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

I'm going to need all the comfort I can get for this next one.

21. Beyoncé - I Miss You



Overall Score - 7.259 Highest Score - 10 (10x)/Lowest Score - (1x)

You will all burn in hell. I know you know this, but I have to say that.

Except for the nine others who gave this song a ten.

A masterpiece. I gave it a perfect 10.

[Ra2]

Originally posted by A Bomb

Oh you're one of the Black Jesus haters.
The songs I gave 0's to, are the songs I deleted from my itunes.
Song with high points were
Inside Out
He About To Lose Me

Heavy Metal Lover
Scheisse
Bloody Mary

Countdown
Love On Top

I enjoy all of those songs minus countdown. It's actually really good but I don't like the "countdown" part.

I love the chorus to BJAM, and I LOVE the intro, but the verses just don't cut it for me.

[EarlyMorning]

Yasss for Hold It Against #1 snatching Re-do This Track.

[Ra2]

Originally posted by supaspaz

I think it's the nature of the game. We're rating the songs individually, so I'm not surprised that the high energy, single-ready tracks of Femme Fatale would jump out more at the average voter. 4 is definitely an album experience, and Born This Way's filler is too polarizing.

The thing about BTW is that it is in fact polarizing. There aren't many songs that everybody likes.

There's at least 1 song on the album for everybody, but no 1 song is for everybody. I'm actually surprised so many BTW songs are still in it. I was going to assume it was going to be a BTW sweep and maybe 4 of them making top 20.

[EarlyMorning]

Wait Mary N' Joseph, I Miss God and Christ + Christ got eliminated? This list is garbage.