2) should be done for the hilarity factor but i wouldn't participate as i refuse to break my record of never having listened to TD and i wouldn't like to sit thru like 21 Xtina tracks.
I'd basically only participate in 4).
Sis, Not Like the Movies klnda *****.
It's better than half of Bionic, that's for damn sure.
Latter for me, with some bias of the former. That's why i didn't give a single 0 and only one song lower than 3.
Interesting. I went the opposite way: mostly quality, with a little bit of personal preference thrown in. There were songs I love that I rated lower because they were too generic or artistically mediocre. And I gave just one 10—to the only song I am truly confident will be regarded as a future pop classic.
For the next album tournament, we have four options.
1) 2008 Old Ladies Jam (as inspired by Venus) - X vs. E-MC2 vs. Discipline vs. Hard Candy
2) 2010 Roundup Part 1 - Teenage Dream v. Animal v. Bionic (and maybe Body Talk)
3) 2010 Roundup Part 2 - Loud v. Cannibal v. Speak Now (and allow me Messy Little Raindrops?)
4) These three ladies, with their most critically acclaimed works - Blackout v. The Fame Monster v. B'Day.
The choice is yours.
Four is the best one from this list but two would be good if Body Talk was confirmed.
How about Teenage Dream vs. Animal vs. Loud? They're all cutesy, messy and all over the place, reaching high highs and low lows and don't sound like real albums. Those sound more comparable to me than putting the vastly superior body of work that is Body Talk in there.
