I thought it was an interesting enough question to thread
I think I prefer Garibay. Heavy Metal Lover, Marry the Night, and The Edge of Glory **** on the rest of the album (aside from Scheiße, no pun intended).
I think scheibe is amazing the instrumental is perfection but the message is weak IMO I think it'll still smash hard though! Judas has grown on me amazing track somewhat comical to me or maybe the video gives me that feel... Hair is ****ing epic best redone track on the album hands down! Great message great instrumental a mixture of 80s rock ballad with metal in the structure of a pop song which is awesome and the bridge slays! I would like for the, to continue working together at least 2 songs per album.. Hes the piece of the puzzle that made her who she is and losing him so soon might not be a good idea.. I must agree his recent non gaga tracks are absolutely horrible! So disappointed in him recycled trash after recycled trash..
I ****ing knew I liked you for some reason!
Quote:
Originally posted by Ouz
I can't listen to Hair till the end, I cut it at half. It's oh so long how can you handle it?
That's why I love it. It just keeps going and going and going.
I certainly don't think RedOne's work stands out from the rest of the work on this album. I think the best 3 songs on the album are GH, HML and BTW, none of which have his name attached.
- 
