[Hyper_Intake]

Originally posted by Darren-5-08

It went #19 in the UK, but its sales were decent. It just missed Silver (200k), which is very rare for a song with such a low peak.

Where do you find out her uk sales ??

[Ginger.]

Originally posted by guga10

That would be Telephone...

LoveGame is actually top 5.

I agree with you there.

And I really love the video.

[Foot]

Originally posted by mons†er

No. 'Judas' was a 'Bad Romance' rip off. She tried to duplicate it and failed.

She tried to duplicate it and was successful in doing so.

[mons†er]

Originally posted by Foot

She tried to duplicate it and was successful in doing so.

Sis we are just gonna have to agree to disagree.

[Foot]

Originally posted by guga10

That would be Telephone...

LoveGame is actually top 5.

I agree with both points.

[guga10]

Originally posted by mons†er

No. 'Judas' was a 'Bad Romance' rip off. She tried to duplicate it and failed.

Bad Romance is overrated.
Of course it ***** on discographie$, but is not as good as her best singles.
Judas ia Bad Romance rip off, but is 1000x better.

[slimane12]

Telephone and Lovegame are her worst singles. They are just garbage lyrically. I applauded her when she admitted she hated Telephone and Money Honey (both wack) it made me realise she is more self aware than people give her credit for.

Her best songwriting is by farrrr Paparazzi and The edge of glory. Just dance and Pokerface are great melodically...so catchy.

[Nicole]

Originally posted by mons†er

No. 'Judas' was a 'Bad Romance' rip off. She tried to duplicate it and failed.

Exactly. Must have been scary for her to watch it flop. She probably thought she could rely on the RedOne, PF/BR 7.0 formula forever and crank out easy hits.

[Hyper_Intake]

Telephone was definitely her worst single IMO. I actually love love game, its catchy, sexy and she looks hot in the video.

[slimane12]

Not really I don't think she dwells on things at all. She never addresses negativity bar the Madonna thing in that NME interview. She's all about moving forward constantly....she reminds me of B in that sense. They both have that bulletproof quality.

If she relied on Redone she would have had him produce the whole album. Flops are no big deal in an artists career they all have them eventually....COMING BACK from them is the most important thing (which she did)....and sorts out the men from the boys.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Exactly. Must have been scary for her to watch it flop. She probably thought she could rely on the RedOne, PF/BR 7.0 formula forever and crank out easy hits.

I always got the sense that she didn't really care about it as single. The way she always talked about it was so nonchalant/whatever compared to all the others (with maybe the exception of Telephone).

I love it, though.

[Alberto]

guys, check this thread

Why they always do this kind of threads? last time was Loud vs. BTW, then TD vs. BTW.
They like to make bad jokes.

[Whorehaus of Gaga]

Originally posted by slimane12

Not really I don't think she dwells on things at all. She never addresses negativity bar the Madonna thing in that NME interview. She's all about moving forward constantly....she reminds me of B in that sense. They both have that bulletproof quality.

Who are you talkin' to?

[mons†er]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Exactly. Must have been scary for her to watch it flop. She probably thought she could rely on the RedOne, PF/BR 7.0 formula forever and crank out easy hits.

It must have really sucked after all the hype and it sooooo underperformed. you think it was gonna pull a PF x2.

[guga10]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Exactly. Must have been scary for her to watch it flop. She probably thought she could rely on the RedOne, PF/BR 7.0 formula forever and crank out easy hits.

Originally posted by MrPeanut

I always got the sense that she didn't really care about it as single. The way she always talked about it was so nonchalant/whatever compared to all the others (with maybe the exception of Telephone).

I love it, though.

She tought it would be the safest hit on the album. Of course, after, she realised she couldn`t release the album with a flop so she rush released TEOG.

I do believe she cares about the singles or she wouldn`t promote everywhere, but i guess she cares less than Katy Perry, for example.

Judas is actually quite amazing.

[jungle juice]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

Exactly. Must have been scary for her to watch it flop. She probably thought she could rely on the RedOne, PF/BR 7.0 formula forever and crank out easy hits.

Can you blame her? Nearly all of her hits are RedOne productions. 'Judas' was too carbon-copy, though.

[Nicole]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

I always got the sense that she didn't really care about it as single. The way she always talked about it was so nonchalant/whatever compared to all the others (with maybe the exception of Telephone).

I love it, though.

She talked about it plenty. Remember the Google interview? Also her explanation of the song's meaning + video?

She talked about how she knew her fans wanted another PF + BR (I believe she referred to it as PF 3.0). It felt like she thought she was dropping a surefire hit onto the charts.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Nicole

She talked about it plenty. Remember the Google interview? Also her explanation of the song's meaning + video?

She talked about how she knew her fans wanted another PF + BR (I believe she referred to it as PF 3.0). It felt like she thought she was dropping a surefire hit onto the charts.

I don't mean that she didn't talk about it or promote it/want it to do well, it just seemed like her heart wasn't really in it, as compared to how she's talked about the other three singles so far.

[guga10]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

I don't mean that she didn't talk about it or promote it/want it to do well, it just seemed like her heart wasn't really in it, as compared to how she's talked about the other three singles so far.

Or how she talked about Hair.

[slimane12]

Well that's understandable as it wasn't as personal to her as Born this way, TEOG or You and I.