[Gui Blackout]

Will Lady Gaga's brand new single "You and I" be a bigger flop than "Judas"?

Discuss.

[Remixed]

Nope

[Grim]

I think it'll be a hit with the way she's been promoting it. Plus, she gets HAC support so the AI will be there.

[Auburn]

No. I just have this feeling about this song not flopping, but you never know

[Wonda]

No. But it won't be a number 1 either.
It'll continue on her little Top 10 streak, in a nicer fashion than Judas.

[iLays]

Yes

[KevinKDC]

No.

[Government Hooker]

Hopefully NO

[MrPeanut]

I doubt it'll have as high a peak on the Hot 100 or perform as well as Judas did in other countries, but I think it'll have a much better run on radio.

[Regina George]

No, I love it

[Duca]

Hopefully. "Judas" is a much better track. Far, far better than "The Edge Of Glory" as well.

[JonnyϟLightning]

Yes.

[judaslover]

No, because I think it will go inside the Top 10. But it depends on the competition on the charts during later this month, and in September.

[MrPeanut]

Originally posted by Duca

Hopefully. "Judas" is a much better track. Far, far better than "The Edge Of Glory" as well.

I still weep over the injustice of it flopping.

[ddeizaguirre]

People are seriously underestimating this song.. I dont think it will have the success of her previous singles but its definitely has a chance of being a multiformat smash

[S&M]

Yes.

[Inverted]

No, people like the song. Judas is just a sloppy demo-sounding mess.

[Forevermore]

Worldwide it will do worse but in the U.S. it will perform better then Judas did.

[Rated R]

Originally posted by Duca

Hopefully. "Judas" is a much better track. Far, far better than "The Edge Of Glory" as well.

+1. Judas is the best song on the album in my opinion

[B94]

Yes. Judas is a great song and You & I. Good luck to her though. I would have much rather see her use Bloody Mary as a single choice.