[omgitsralph]

Originally posted by Symphonic

If you search 'scary mermaid' on Google images the first picture is a horrible mermaid (with teal hair).

Something Laurieann would want. I just want Gaga to send her somewhere in an island to avoid her "creative" directions on this next video.

Originally posted by Evilkitt3n

Hair would fit perfectly with the mermaid theme, i can imagine Gaga combing her hair with a fork like Ariel.

Yes, perfectly. She didn't say YUYI would have a partner in the video, am I right? I can imagine her teal hair flowing underwater in the "I just wanna be free, I just wanna be me" part of the song.

[Hello]

Originally posted by omgitsralph

I hope her vision of mermaid is the good, happy mermaid (Topless or shell bra) not the ugly, scary mermaid.

A fusion of the two. Like the ones from the latest Pirates movie.

[omgitsralph]

Originally posted by Allstar

How does she perform You and I as a mermaid though?

Chill, we're not yet sure about that. She should definitely slow down a bit at the moment and come back with a huge smash hit - HAIR.

[Allstar]

I think her definiton of mermaid is the more beautiful one, since she loves Arielle and looking at her lately....

[omgitsralph]

Originally posted by Allstar

Idea:

A big pool with great underwater details and some fishes swimming in it. A glass box with air in the middle.

The box is actually not a box, but a shell where a piano was built in and she sits inside of it.

She wears a tail and long hair that hides her naked breasts and performs You and I.

I like this idea. Not so sure if she knows how to swim.

[omgitsralph]

Originally posted by Hello

A fusion of the two. Like the ones from the latest Pirates movie.

She doesn't need another dark video this era. Move on to the brighter side, Ms. Stefani.

[dream8ker]

I left a few hours, just came back and I discover that she gives hints about Y&I being the very probable next singe

1. WTF, when you have MTN or Scheisse on your album...

2. She promised fans would decide the 3rd single, I understand TEOG was rush released but this was the perfect occasion to let us choose and we chose Scheisse or MTN mostly

3.On youtube Yoü & I has 2 times fewer viewers than MTN, Scheisse or Bloody Marry

4. I understand she might want to show she has a broad register, but I think she already showed it with TEOG and all the Y&I performances

I don't understand this choice if it were confirmed. I'm not mad, cauz' she's a great artist, and will always stan for her.

But I want her to show the calibre of the songs on BTW, and clearly Y&I is not a demontration of that on the contrary of above mentioned songs...

[omgitsralph]

Originally posted by Allstar

I think her definiton of mermaid is the more beautiful one, since she loves Arielle and looking at her lately....

Ariel is so magical. One of my favorite Disney princesses.

[Boop]

Originally posted by Riverwide

I wish people would realise that she can't keep releasing dance pop songs forever. She has to mix it up now and again, to expose people to the other side of her music. Madonna often took risky choices with her single releases and while in the short-term it may have resulted in "flop" singles(Oh Father, Bedtime Story, Human Nature etc), in the longterm, it made her singles catalogue look so diverse and interesting. I think it's time GaGa did this.

So many of you are WAY too hung up on chart positions and radio updates that you've lost sight of the wonderful music GaGa has delivered. It's such a shame. Music is not all about charts and hits.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by dream8ker

2. She promised fans would decide the 3rd single, I understand TEOG was rush released but this was the perfect occasion to let us choose and we chose Scheisse or MTN mostly

I'm still asking myself when she ever promised that.

[Allstar]

No responses to my idea, other than the one from Ralph?
Everyone here for a boring VMA performance?

[dream8ker]

Originally posted by Allstar

I'm still asking myself when she ever promised that.

4:35 to 4:55

[Darren-5-08]

Originally posted by Allstar

I'm still asking myself when she ever promised that.

I remember she said she *wanted* that to happen, but I doubt Interscope would take that too seriously after Judas. Y&I is not *my* choice, but I can see it doing really well on radio. It does show a different side to her music and could be an album seller, if nothing else. Also, a VMA performance of it would be epic. The majority of people prefer Gaga's performances when it is just her and a piano. It could be a great opportunity.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by dream8ker

4:35 to 4:55

Well, alright.
I didn't believe her back then and I still don't.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Darren-5-08

Also, a VMA performance of it would be epic. The majority of people prefer Gaga's performances when it is just her and a piano. It could be a great opportunity.

It would only be epic, if she performed it in a way I described.
Other than that, I don't see a piano perfomance being epic.

[Darren-5-08]

Originally posted by Allstar

It would only be epic, if she performed it in a way I described.
Other than that, I don't see a piano perfomance being epic.

It wouldn't be epic to us only. The general public prefer Gaga and piano rather than a big spectacle.

[MusicTalker]

Someone who hasn't voted this round in my Vs Game yet in the lounge needs to break the tie between Judas & Heavy Metal Lover.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Darren-5-08

It wouldn't be epic to us only. The general public prefer Gaga and piano rather than a big spectacle.

That doesn't make it epic.

When it comes to performances, the eye judges too. And I am confident that that refers to nearly everyone out there.
So a piano performance, with a big underwater set, would still be a piano performance. Just that it is a big spectacle at the same time.

[Darren-5-08]

Originally posted by Allstar

That doesn't make it epic.

When it comes to performances, the eye judges too. And I am confident that that refers to nearly everyone out there.
So a piano performance, with a big underwater set, would still be a piano performance. Just that it is a big spectacle at the same time.

She needs a performance in the US that will sell albums though. That does not necessarily have the same meaning as an epic performance...

[dream8ker]

Originally posted by Allstar

That doesn't make it epic.

When it comes to performances, the eye judges too. And I am confident that that refers to nearly everyone out there.
So a piano performance, with a big underwater set, would still be a piano performance. Just that it is a big spectacle at the same time.

In any case, Y&I does not scream epicness @ all... I hear a nice balade really worth listening... but not something striking as Paparazzi for instance...

When Scheisse or MTN on the other hand...