[Glamthony]

Originally posted by G&G

In your Warning Point.

[thehealing]

Christina > Kelly > Beyonce'

[RajibDavid]

Originally posted by caerbayn

But you wasted no time in finding that ludicrous video trying to claim Christina has "power" and Beyonce doesn't? I watched that video and nothing in it made sense. Especially referring to Christina's vibrato-less howls as "powerful".

And no Christina can't sing better. Actually READ what those videos are criticising her about. Poor breath support, straining on notes that are alleged to be in her "comfort zone". No vibrato, poor enunciation. This is not people being "pressed", these are VALID criticisms. Christina does the opposite of what you are meant to do and her voice suffers.

Whether or not you think she's "soulful" or her tone conveys emotion is entirely subjective and has nothing to do with being a good vocalist.

If you decide to browse all over YouTube, you'll see that they are much more anti-Xtina vids. Those Beyonce fans still go to the latest Xtina performance or song to trash her. They are hating even in "La Casa" video, that shows they are 100% pressed. Xtina fans don't need to do that, we know Xtina's voice is superior and more famous.

[LaVitaFenty]

Xtina>Kelly>Bey (listening to 4 & her recent performances, she grew as an vocalist since DIL era)

[Jeze]

King B>>>>

[TheRealBabyDre]

44.72%

Beyonce all the way !
Xtina is good but her screamin and movin the mic from her mouth annoys me !
And I don't really know this Kelly girl ..... ~_~

[Drais.]

Dead at the poll backfiring.

[duybeeGAshantiGA]

Kelly really can belt an high note with an ease. Xtina is not good at this. But overall, Beyonce should win, she uses her voice in crazy ways.

[Music 2005]

@ Beyonce winning a vocal contest

[UnusualBoy]

I'll go with Christina her performances of Beautiful slay me so hard

[ShineOverShadow]

In all seriousness, Kelly really is the best vocalist of this generation, and is only getting better.

[sef_aguilera]

Originally posted by DiamondDust

Kelly Clarkson could sing Christina into the ground. She literally wouldn't survive standing next to Kelly Clarkson. Kelly can just do so much more with her voice than Christina ever could. Christina owes all her recognition to a great public relations team because she is not that good, and she's nowhere near the level of premier vocalists like Whitney, Mariah, or Celine.

"Christina Aguilera" and "voice of a generation" in the same sentence is the best joke I've read all morning. I'm pretty sure the voice of a generation would be able to sustain a chest belt with full vibrato. Dream on.

are you in drugs? even Celine confessed that Xtina is better than her. SIT!

[sef_aguilera]

Let's see if the lesser gurls like Beyonce can sing like this.

[t.A.T.u.]

Originally posted by sef_aguilera

Let's see if the lesser gurls like Beyonce can sing like this.

never!!!

[Shay_Dee]

I'm sorry..I love bey but even Legends like Patti, Aretha and Etta are speaking the truth.. Do I even need to post the videos? LOL

[b3dro]

christina > bey > kelly

[loco]

Honest opinion:

Love them all, they are great singers so I had to cut it out to live performances

Kelly: always been a CONSISTENTLY strong live performer. incredible range and never dodges notes.
Beyonce: same
Christina: in her earlier years she was pretty good, she hit amazing notes live. ever since stripped she started to dodge high notes which annoys the HELL out of me. Stuff like beautiful and hurt(dont get mes tarted on the voice within live performances)

[fabbriche]

Originally posted by sef_aguilera

are you in drugs? even Celine confessed that Xtina is better than her. SIT!

Ikr? Celine said Christina is "probably the best vocalist in the world."

[Quiqui4eva]

Originally posted by t.A.T.u.

gerls u can't do this to me of course beyonce has no chance with kelly & Xtina but i can't choose between my 2 queens

Gorl you know you're using your stan card


Anyway, Christina WAS an amazing vocalist, with definetly the most strength. Although, she tends to oversing and is losing the spark she had. Kelly has consistently had great vocals, but her voice is not as strong as the other two. Bey is also an awesome consistent singer and has more strenth in her voice than Kelly, but Kelly has a little more control than Bey.

Control - Kelly > Bey >>>> Christina
Consistency - Bey > Kelly >>>>> Christina
Strenth - Christina > Bey >>>>> Kelly

First: 3 points
Second: 2 points
Last: 1 points

Kelly = 6 points
Christina = 5 points
Bey = 7 points

Based on score, I think Bey is definetly the best

[BPD]

Can somebody please please post Christina's CNN Heroes Performance of Beautiful!

That performance was ****en EXQUISITE and Christina has complete control of her voice. Just post it somebody