On a side note, I recently spoke with a Pitchfork reviewer, and he said he was unsure why P4K did not review BTW, but that they will likely refrain from doing so any time in the foreseeable future.
Maybe they'll wait until their readers select numerous tracks from it for their end-of-the-year pop lists and then do a last minute review because in their quest to stay relevant, they missed that people actually enjoy Lady Gaga still.