[Reeces]

What a disappointment. Why did she have to release such a basic video for one of her best songs?

[Katy V.!]

Originally posted by Aryl

Joseph Khan is laughing somewhere.

[inspiration4]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

They should have added some vid to the vid.

It's as if this video is a compilation of all of the footage from one particular scene that was meant to be a 20 second section of the actual video. It's like someone stole the rest of the scenes and they just had to release what they had to meet a deadline. Not bad, moreso weird. I can only assume some behind the scenes drama is what led to this "video".

[Auburn]

Originally posted by MrPeanut

If only there were other scenes to .gif...

but true

[Crank_It_Up]

It is very simple. But too simple for me. I mean, it's Lady Gaga we're talking about here.
I had a glimmer of hope that she would contain the rumored mermaid concept at a point of the video but, no.

It's not bad but it is boring. The thing is, it is a song written in honor of her grandfather so I probably would understand why she wanted to tone it down for him, and after the recent attack of Clarence Clemons.

[bobbymfw]

It's a decent video and it doesn't take away from the fact that it's a great song. She probably had to work with a small budget for this since "Judas" turned out to be an expensive misstep.

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by Rîh.røx.

I'm sick of this. Gaga cant get any negative feedback ever. If its over the top and long its amazing and unique and Lady Gaga did it once again! And if its simple and short and boring, its amazing and unique and Lady Gaga did it once again!


No.

Was this comment premade?

[VampireGrin]

Going to watch for a 2nd time. Got my coffee ready. Wish me luck

[Ahmed.]

Originally posted by LCTV

im on the edge.. of budget..

HAHAHAHAH XD

Originally posted by hairofglory

I was really hoping she would jump of the building to finally make it interesting

My first though

Originally posted by BornThisWay

All you monsters defending her need to just stop.
I wouldn't mind a more basic video, but maybe a basic video with more than ONE ****ing backdrop.
Eh, Eh, LoveGame, Poker Face, etc. all at least had mulitiple scenes and things going on.

This video was insufferably bland and uneventful.
And as a stan of Ms. Gaga I want something weird, new, different, strange, boundary breaking, attention grabbing, INTERESTING in a video. This gave me none of that.

Her worst video by far and none of you can deny it.


Lastly, the budget for this video appears to have been less than the budget for Rebecca Black's "Friday" video. Seriously, wtf is that **** coming from the biggest pop star in the world? I'm really mad.

[Hilary & Rock]

You guys are being too hard on this video, I mean, I kinda liked it...it's very simple but the camera work, the colors and the set are just beautiful

but the problem here is that the video is really uneventful, I mean, nothing happened! I will rate this video with a 7 | 10....


but yes I did expect something EPIC, I had this great video pictured in my mind, based on her performance on Idol, with an AWESOME duo dance sequence and them jumping off a building or something.... THAT would've been EPIC!

[Dark Matter]

The Saturdays and LMFAO called. They want their set back.

[inspiration4]

DEATH @ "I'm on the Edge of Budget"

[Hilary & Rock]

Originally posted by Good_Doc_Gone_Bad

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

This girl is CRAZYYY!!!
but she's funny

[Raguabros]

Her worst video ever.

[Lonƹ]

Originally posted by Raguabros

Her worst video ever.

+1

[B94]

http://www.breatheheavy.com/exhale/v...php?tid=382524 Gimme more is great song with a bad video. And the same can be said with TEOG.

[VampireGrin]

Alright, I appreciated it a little more on the second watch.

[J a y]

Originally posted by Raguabros

Her worst video ever.

Agreed.

[KRL]

Originally posted by Raguabros

Her worst video ever.

I like it more than BDR, born this way and alejandro

[hOAng]

I was expecting a video with a storyline. This song is so good and she can do much better.