[If U Seek Amy]

All I'm saying is nobody I know understands the BTW video. E.T. has a point to it. BTW is just Gaga dancing around and no sense is really made at all. E.T. shows Katy bringing a foreigner to life and falling in love with him. Simple.

[Bibliotheque]

Originally posted by Razr

This is for sure Katy's best video. California Gurls I would say is her second. But I believe this is far better than BTW because most people I know do not understand the BTW video. E.T. gets to the point with no confusion and most people are not going to put forth the effort to figure out what Gaga is talking about in the video. People like what they can understand easily and like it when its something nice to look at. E.T. has both and so it will come out on top.

[Monster]

Originally posted by Bibliotheque

I'm still undecided about this video. It's just... blah

Agreed. It's beautiful, but all it essentially is is floating, and then the kiss and the ass shot.

[If U Seek Amy]

I guess I can't really argue a point with gaga stans... whoever can. Thats just my view on the topic of why E.T. is better. I know Gaga is your favorite but some people need to look at obvious facts.

[supaspaz]

Best video ever? Not quite. But definitely interesting and visually quite stunning. The concept fits perfectly, as the slow motion and music meld together to create something incredibly hypnotizing (though nothing much at all happens). It's nice to see that there are still artists out there making great videos without resorting to over-the-top shenanigans that actually diminish the overall product.

[Navin]

Originally posted by Razr

All I'm saying is nobody I know understands the BTW video. E.T. has a point to it. BTW is just Gaga dancing around and no sense is really made at all. E.T. shows Katy bringing a foreigner to life and falling in love with him. Simple.

Thats not what I saw.
I saw A black man rapping in a spaceship and then an alien floating in the sky.
And then the alien turns into a woman and All I see is animals making babies.
And then the alien loses control and falls to Earth I think.
And then she sees a robot, makes out with it and then theres a human inside.
And then she has animal legs....
And then they leave.

ET is arguable just as confusing as Born This Way

[BnPac]

Originally posted by Rainbows

This quote right here explains exactly why I enjoy this song and video!!

I feel the same!!!


And I think you all should stop with the BTW comparisons, it was the tittle of the 1st review, it doesn't mean the whole thread should take that direction. Smart up people or this will be closed.

[satellites.™]

The alien visuals and the beginning with the fantasy scene are for now my favorite shots in any video EVER.

[If U Seek Amy]

Originally posted by satellites™

The alien visuals and the beginning with the fantasy scene are for now my favorite shots in any video EVER.

Visuals in E.T. are the best I've ever seen. + 1.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by BnPac

And I think you all should stop with the BTW comparisons, it was the tittle of the 1st review, it doesn't mean the whole thread should take that direction. Smart up people or this will be closed.

+1

This is an "E.T." music video review thread, not a comparison thread for "E.T." and "Born This Way."

[Sammi]

Originally posted by satellites™

The alien visuals and the beginning with the fantasy scene are for now my favorite shots in any video EVER.

[Navin]

Originally posted by Rainbows

+1

This is an "E.T." music video review thread, not a comparison thread for "E.T." and "Born This Way."

You know thats what the OP Wanted.
The first article he posted was one that compared them both

[Green]

E.T's video is visually fantastic. I think she's going to get multiples VMA's nominations thanks to this video.

[If U Seek Amy]

I feel like Katy is just going to end up like last year and not get any awards because of fan base sizes...

[KarlosVzla]

It's miles better than Born This Way in my opinion.

[Nɑɑji.. ©]

The video is gorgeous I liked it she looks pretty.

[Reed]

Kudos to Katy for actually making the concept of her music video compliment the theme of the song. It was really good!!

[Remixed]

Katy brings an other-worldly dimension to the 5-minute long masterpiece for her latest single off Teenage Dream, “E.T.” Gaga is usually the queen of special effects and over-the-top short-films, but Katy may take the cake with her latest clip.

Oh my god

[Navin]

The end cinematography was EPIC.
The whole Video should have been in that environment.

[Lithium9]

This video Sucks how can anyone call it a Masterpiece LOL
It's just her floating in the space and then falling down to earth and yeah random images of animal ****ing
nothing more