Poll: Greatest Hits Battle: Britney Spears vs P!nk - Page 3

Duca

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Pink>>>>>>>>>>>>>the industry.

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

yes Xtina currently plays in another league than Pink, a much lower one.

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Vocally Pink is not that far below Xtina either, but more importantly she's miles ahead when it comes to live performances.

Pedro

Britney's obviously!

XChrisX

P!nk >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Britney.

Duca

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

boy your delusions are getting out of hand. I didn't know being a one trick pony was same as making some influence on music.

The nerve. Wasn't P!nk initially positioned as a white-girl R&B singer and admitted she was a puppet in the beginning?

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Pink's hits have aged MUCH better than Britney's. And radio knows the true tea. Pink has one of the highest recurrent radio plays, while Britney's old hits barely ever get any recurrent play.

Britney was blacklisted on the radio in her early days.

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Plus Pink has the diversity and vocals on her side.

Diversity? She's constantly singing about being an underdog. It's as if she sees her fans as miserable losers.

Britney revived teen pop with "...Baby One More Time," she did pure pop on "Oops!...I Did It Again," she did pop/rock on "Britney," she did electro-pop, R&B, hip-pop on "In The Zone" on which she upped her artistic skills and co-wrote ten of the album's tracks. She made dance music mainstream with "Blackout" which Rolling Stone named the most influential album of the second part of the last decade, and did synth-pop on "Circus."

P!nk's voice is always cracking, and while Britney doesn't have the pipes of Christina, she is a pretty good singer. Just because she doesn't sing live doesn't mean she can't.

Duca

Quote:

Originally posted by xChunk

But you are aware of that Britney ***** on P!nk in general?

More like in every way possible.

1Republic

P!nk obviously.

Katy V.!

P!nk

By far!!!

Shy Boy

Anything Pink does >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Anything Britney does

Robert

Greatest hits so far.. but my perogative is awesome

Chunk

Quote:

Originally posted by Duca

The nerve. Wasn't P!nk initially positioned as a white-girl R&B singer and admitted she was a puppet in the beginning?

Britney was blacklisted on the radio in her early days.

Diversity? She's constantly singing about being an underdog. It's as if she sees her fans as miserable losers.

Britney revived teen pop with "...Baby One More Time," she did pure pop on "Oops!...I Did It Again," she did pop/rock on "Britney," she did electro-pop, R&B, hip-pop on "In The Zone" on which she upped her artistic skills and co-wrote ten of the album's tracks. She made dance music mainstream with "Blackout" which Rolling Stone named the most influential album of the second part of the last decade, and did synth-pop on "Circus."

P!nk's voice is always cracking, and while Britney doesn't have the pipes of Christina, she is a pretty good singer. Just because she doesn't sing live doesn't mean she can't.

fpppy

tcatron565

Both are good, but P!nk's is better for me.

tcatron565

Quote:

Originally posted by Duca

Diversity? She's constantly singing about being an underdog. It's as if she sees her fans as miserable losers.

Britney revived teen pop with "...Baby One More Time," she did pure pop on "Oops!...I Did It Again," she did pop/rock on "Britney," she did electro-pop, R&B, hip-pop on "In The Zone" on which she upped her artistic skills and co-wrote ten of the album's tracks. She made dance music mainstream with "Blackout" which Rolling Stone named the most influential album of the second part of the last decade, and did synth-pop on "Circus."

P!nk's voice is always cracking, and while Britney doesn't have the pipes of Christina, she is a pretty good singer. Just because she doesn't sing live doesn't mean she can't.

I'm sorry, but I just can't at the last paragraph. When the hell does P!nk's voice crack? Try never. That's how her voice is! That's like saying Miley sings out of her nose constantly. She doesn't do that, it's just how her voice is! P!nk's voice is VERY good. One of the best in the business. It's so raspy and soulful. It's not what you'd expect from a girl like her.

I'm not putting down Britney at all, I'm just saying, don't be posting statements like that. It makes you seem like an idiot, and I know you're not.

MusicLoverDude

I think the CDs are equally great. Neither is better than the other.

They're just greatest hits albums guys...not that important.

SarahWalker

Britney for sure. All of the songs listed are a big part of my childhood. Whenever one of those songs randomly pops out on the radio, I sing along and laugh at myself for STILL memorizing the lyrics after all those years.

P!nk has good set as well, but I'm not familiar with 40% of those songs.

Strangergab

Britney Album its EPIC

Pink album is just good

Louie

How is that even a question? Britney's Greatest Hits albums are indestructible. They're on par with Madonna and Mariah Carey's, who are over 2 decades into their careers.

P!nk is one of my favourite artists in the industry. But I can't tolerate these songs:

6. Trouble - never liked it. Video is fun but other than that it doesn't do anything for me and sounds desperate.
7. Stupid Girls - it was fun in its early days, but then became repetitive and annoying
14.Funhouse - I choose to look at this as a big black dot in her amazing discography. It didn't deserve to be the title of the album/a track on the album/a single
15.I Don't Believe You - borrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrring.
19.Whataya Want From Me - I can't even listen to this anymore. It's better than Adam's but woah does it kill my ears
21.Heartbreak Down - I'm not even gonna...

They don't even deserve to be on her albums, let alone greatest hits collection.

Every single track on Britney's GHs is a 10/10 moment.

P.S. before any P!nk stan hops on my grill, this is MY opinion. Take it or leave it.

fanoftalent

I think the amount of votes Pink got in this poll against Britney, whose stans pretty much rule this forum is an indicator that her hits are just as memorable and iconic as anyone else's in the past decade. She's definitely the most consistent hit-maker out there and people love her hits. The fact that the album already sold very close to 2 million copies (1,9 million to be exact) in the current market is an indicator that general public loves her and loves her hits.

Also unlike some other acts her single and album sales come from a wide range of general public, as opposed to dedicated stans buying multiple copies of the same product

Louie

Quote:

Originally posted by fanoftalent

I think the amount of votes Pink got in this poll against Britney, whose stans pretty much rule this forum is an indicator that her hits are just as memorable and iconic as anyone else's in the past decade. She's definitely the most consistent hit-maker out there and people love her hits. The fact that the album already sold very close to 2 million copies (1,9 million to be exact) in the current market is an indicator that general public loves her and loves her hits.

Also unlike some other acts her single and album sales come from a wide range of general public, as opposed to dedicated stans buying multiple copies of the same product

The stans buying multiple copies could only help her sales with such little numbers. Its very hypocrite to say that though since P!nk's stans do the same thing as well, you can't be damn sure that only Britney's stans do it. That said, it still doesn't effect the sales that much.

P!nk's hits are just as memorable and iconic as Britney and Beyonce's. She is one of the most consistent hit-makers out there and yes people love her hits. Of course her Greatest Hits album is doing great, it's P!nk. All that doesn't discredit Britney's Greatest Hits, though. You could say the exact same things about Greatest Hits: My Prerogative. I don't understand your need to be cynical about this whole thing. Can't you just be happy with both of them having good greatest hits? Britney and P!nk are awkwardly put against each other sometimes and it just doesn't work out, They are very, very different artists. + they LOVE each other, so just cool off.

Chunk

Quote:

Originally posted by Louie

The stans buying multiple copies could only help her sales with such little numbers. Its very hypocrite to say that though since P!nk's stans do the same thing as well, you can't be damn sure that only Britney's stans do it. That said, it still doesn't effect the sales that much.

P!nk's hits are just as memorable and iconic as Britney and Beyonce's. She is one of the most consistent hit-makers out there and yes people love her hits. Of course her Greatest Hits album is doing great, it's P!nk. All that doesn't discredit Britney's Greatest Hits. You could say the exact same things about Greatest Hits: My Prerogative.

Spill the true tea.