[ohplease]

@ Duca & @Last Boy On Earth, these are your opinions which I respect, but not mine. I'm not here to fight. I don't want to bring Crazy In Love History either. You should ask yourselves what exactly makes them iconic debuts, what were the circumstances when both came as solo & released the songs. I agreed with everyone, the most iconic debut is BOMT. But CIL, the most relevant to this date, has the most impact on music & its culture. & it stays like this.

[Jewfro]

BOMT is the pretty obvious choice.

Edit: Perhaps Holiday, but I'm not really sure.

[SIMon1120]

Although I prefer Just Dance & Genie In A Bottle, I agree that BABY ONE MORE TIME is the most iconic debut

[tcatron565]

"...Baby One More Time" is the definition of iconic. No, I'm not a Britney Spears stan. Hell, I'm not really even a big fan. But, the truth shines bright.

"Crazy In Love" easily would take second place, though.

"Genie in a Bottle" is third. (Out of this list.)

The rest are all kind of tied, except "Just Dance." I don't know whether it's iconic or not, simply because it's still a "new" song.

[AnotherGagaFan]

Madonna's debut single wasnt holiday.. Lol. But holidy is most iconic. Than one more time

[Vini]

Originally posted by ohplease

But CIL, the most relevant to this date, has the most impact on music & its culture. & it stays like this.

Anyway, Everybody know who my vote went to,

[Barbarella]

Brittney Spears

[.::Andreita::.]

Vocal phenomenon Mariah.
Woman on Pop...Madonna
Teen phenomenon Britney.

[Bdawg]

Originally posted by AnotherGagaFan

Madonna's debut single wasnt holiday.. Lol. But holidy is most iconic. Than one more time

Um definitely not. Like a virgin ***** all over holiday

[brIt-()nstar]

Originally posted by ohplease

BOMT has the most iconic debut yes, but CIL as a debut has the most relevance & impact on Pop culture, actually no, on music culture.

Just no...

[FAN]

Baby One More Time by a MILE.


"Just Dance" sucks compared to most of her iconic tracks.

"Crazy In Love" was alright but reminds me of "Pon De Replay". :-/

Haven't actaully heard Mariahs or Madonnas

and Genie was great but nothin groundbreaking.

[julesvel]

As much as I wanted to say Beyonce... I can't deny the big bang that was Baby One More Time... :]

[Duca]

Originally posted by Rihannafan

"Crazy In Love" was alright but reminds me of "Pon De Replay". :-/

[Chemist]

Originally posted by Duca

I honestly think "Crazy In Love" is a much better song and a video than "Single Ladies". It is more iconic than "Single Ladies" to me too.

Anyway, BOMT is BY FAR the most iconic debut.

[YoYo]

BOMT WITHOUT ANY CLOSE COMPETITION . You actually should have made a separate thread for BOMT and the rest in another thead

Originally posted by ohplease

the most iconic debut is BOMT. But CIL, the most relevant to this date, has the most impact on music & its culture. & it stays like this.

What? They're BOTH debuts, so how can BOMT be more iconic while the other one has bigger impact? Do you know what the world iconic means?

[Grim]

BOMT. I still remember when that song blew up.

[AyuM]

Obviously Britney.

BTW, Madonna's debut single is 1982's "Everybody", a true classic... not "Holiday"!

[AyuM]

Originally posted by ohplease

But CIL, the most relevant to this date, has the most impact on music & its culture. & it stays like this.

[Queen Bea.]

Originally posted by Bdawg

Um definitely not. Like a virgin ***** all over holiday

As does Vogue, Like a Prayer and some would say Material Girls.

[Nɑɑji.. ©]

Mariah >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>