[Cherry]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

LOL! Let's not get carried away. There have been songs talked about just as much as "Poker Face" and "Bad Romance," or more.

In recent memory?

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by Last Boy on Earth

she writes her songs and plays the piano

She also plays the Keytar and "Emma."

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Jay

That's where Rihanna comes into play..

But not just Rihanna, Michael, Madonna, Whitney, Aretha, Beyonce, Britney, Marvin Gaye and the list goes on and on.

[MissTina]

Originally posted by Aliens & Rainbows

Mandela >>>>>>>>> Beyonce's relative, BY FAR.

[Bad Wolf]

Alicia & GaGa have the same vocal coach

[Chemist]

Originally posted by MonstahNL

They claim SIngle Ladies has had more impact than any video of the past 5 years when even Rude Boy has more views on youtube.

[MissTina]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

You must be mistaken.

[Cherry]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

But not just Rihanna, Michael, Madonna, Whitney, Aretha, Beyonce, Britney, Marvin Gaye and the list goes on and on.

In recent memory?
PF/BR had more of a cultural impact than any other song from the 90s-00s, except Vogue. MAYBE.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by HausofCherry

In recent memory?

All jokes aside, but "Single Ladies" was just as talked about as those GaGa songs. "Umbrella" was as well. Those are just two examples.

[MonstahNL]

Originally posted by chemist

They claim SIngle Ladies has had more impact than any video of the past 5 years when even Rude Boy has more views on youtube.

They have to say something.

[Alexz]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

LOL! Let's not get carried away. There have been songs talked about just as much as "Poker Face" and "Bad Romance," or more.

Tik Tok, California Girls and Teenage Dream were all bigger hits from her peers.

[fanoftalent]

Originally posted by chemist

I nevers doubted about her impact, but Gaga is already bigger than Alecia has ever been

you are basing your assumption ONLY on media buzz.

P!nk has reached the status of a cult icon she don't need no extra media attention to sell out the stadium. She's mainly a touring act.

[QueenBeyoncé]

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by HausofCherry

In recent memory?
PF/BR had more of a cultural impact than any other song from the 90s-00s, except Vogue. MAYBE.

Not quite... maybe you need to do research of Whitney's version of "I Will Always Love You."

[Cherry]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

All jokes aside, but "Single Ladies" was just as talked about as those GaGa songs. "Umbrella" was as well. Those are just two examples.

Single Ladies just happened to get 15 minutes in the limelight for its video. Aside from that, its cultural impact...
Umbrella was just a hit song. Sure it got a bit of publicity, but could it match PF/BR in terms of impact?

The only recent song that comes close to rivaling those two songs is Tik Tok.

[MissTina]

Originally posted by HausofCherry

In recent memory?

I'm not here for Alzheimer's disease patients.

[YoYo]

Originally posted by fanoftalent

Pink is just not getting the media buzz,

Exactly, she almost never get media buzz

P!nk is an important artist but not an important celebrity, that's why she can't achieve an enormous amount of impact

Gaga is both

Britney is both

Beyonce is both


Shakira is............I dont know

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Alexz

Tik Tok, California Girls and Teenage Dream were all bigger hits from her peers.

That's just chart success. I'm referring to songs that actually go outside of their successes on the Billboard Hot 100. There have been several, and none of those songs you mentioned fall into that "several."

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by Captain Planet

All jokes aside, but "Single Ladies" was just as talked about as those GaGa songs. "Umbrella" was as well.

But neither sold as well as GaGa's singles have

[J a y]

Originally posted by MissTina

I'm not here for Alzheimer's disease patients.