[Love]

Originally posted by Satellites

Girl Bye... the sales and the success do not lie! Even the critics liked this album better

Metacritic Scores:
B'Day :70
DIL: 64
IA...SF: 62

http://www.metacritic.com/search/pro...s=beyonce&ty=2

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Love is Love

Metacritic Scores:
B'Day :70
DIL: 64
IA...SF: 62

http://www.metacritic.com/search/pro...s=beyonce&ty=2

i am 6 grammys the critiques likes i am better

[Love]

Originally posted by kisuke

i am 6 grammys the critiques likes i am better

The Grammys has nothing to do with quality or the critics. Everyone knows the Grammy voting committee is biased.

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Satellites

Girl Bye... the sales and the success do not lie! Even the critics liked this album better as did most of the fans... Im not here for that novel you wrote because B'Day compared to IASF is just not happening... there were many random moments on B'Day like Resentment and Listen after songs like Freakum Dress and Get Me Bodied! She took her time and let IASF flow and it did perfectly.

Metacritic has B'Day as Beyonce's most critically acclaimed album. The only reason B'Day gets ******* on by the general public is because the singles underperformed except for Irreplaceable & Beautiful Liar. And I'm referring to the original tracklisting- the deluxe edition tracklisting is bad.

Also, success =/= better quality.

LOL @ IASF flowing better. No it did not, not the Sasha side. The I Am side might've flowed better but it was almost to the point of being too samey. It might be two CDs but you have to treat it as one album and it just doesn't work.

[beyoncefan1]

IMO I Am...Sasha Fierce>>>>Dangerously In Love>>>>B'Day.

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by Love is Love

The Grammys has nothing to do with quality or the critics. Everyone knows the Grammy voting committee is biased.

yeah no

they liked i am bette r

[Kisuke]

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by Linnen Armani

That also explained why the **** IASF losing album of the year to a cheesy yawning ''cohesive'' teenage theme. Fack.

Basically. People think Taylor was given the Grammy because of the Kanye incident, but her album was actually very well-received before then. Even some Beyonce stans started listening to it after the Grammys and said it was a very well made album.

IASF won in the general category for it's individual songs, its strong point.

[***Chu]

No need to compare those three, the 4th one must top over them.

[GeezusHaberdash]

IV will definitely **** on everyone's existence.


And Beyonce's music ***** on her peers' so it's not like we're saying IASF is a deplorable album. Just not her best...

[BeamMeUp]

She's coming!!!!!!

[***Chu]

co-sign.

[BeamMeUp]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

IV|VI

Virtuoso Intellect

[Kisuke]

Originally posted by BeamMeUp

Virtuoso Intellect

[GeezusHaberdash]

Originally posted by BeamMeUp

Virtuoso Intellect

I hope she does go with IV. It's so simple, elegant, and perfect.

[***Chu]

Originally posted by BeamMeUp

Virtuoso Intellect

Man I did believe that rumours.

[Love]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

IV will definitely **** on everyone's existence.


And Beyonce's music ***** on her peers' so it's not like we're saying IASF is a deplorable album. Just not her best...

Exactly.

I wonder which route Beyonce will go this era. I hope she has some old school soul funk songs but current a la Sol Angel.

[***Chu]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

I hope she does go with IV. It's so simple, elegant, and perfect.

I wish she won't have her fourth as a self-entitled album.

[Kisuke]

this thread already having over 500 views

[BeamMeUp]

Originally posted by GeezusHaberdash

I hope she does go with IV. It's so simple, elegant, and perfect.

Nice & simple. I hope she uses some color this era

Oh and in terms of strong individual songs, it goes:
IASF > DIL > B'Day