Not to mention Tidal's fake data that continues to live on in these charts. Lemonade was a perfect illusion.
yeah
the way the news outlets tore TIDAL to pieces after they reported kanye's unbelievable #s for TLOP but started kissing Bey's ass a month later when her also ridiculous tidal #s came out
The propaganda is real
I still can't believe Bén got another 15 minutes @ the VMAs to perform the entirety of her new album Like at least the first time it made sense because she got the Vanguard award but there was no reason for her to do it this year
Well, that's also based on 4 quarterly CDs being released per year, yeah?
even if they released 10 times a year it would still be embarrassing that they're bigger than the woman who just a few years ago was the "biggest star on the planet"
Say what you want to say, but at the end of the day Joanne will be the 2nd or 3rd best selling female album of 2016. 375k+ in the US and 800k+ WW pure sales in only 10 weeks. The GP loves it and its sales will skyrocket when the Super Bowl comes
Say what you want to say, but at the end of the day Joanne will be the 2nd or 3rd best selling female album of 2016. 375k+ in the US and 800k+ WW pure sales in only 10 weeks. The GP loves it and its sales will skyrocket when the Super Bowl comes
I still can't believe Bén got another 15 minutes @ the VMAs to perform the entirety of her new album Like at least the first time it made sense because she got the Vanguard award but there was no reason for her to do it this year
MTV was just desperate for relevant performers. I mean Rihanna got FOUR performances
And the ratings bombed VMAs are irrelevant now, the only award show that holds any weight anymore are the Grammys.
Say what you want to say, but at the end of the day Joanne will be the 2nd or 3rd best selling female album of 2016. 375k+ in the US and 800k+ WW pure sales in only 10 weeks. The GP loves it and its sales will skyrocket when the Super Bowl comes
No
But it did prove she maintains a large and loyal fan base. It'll be a while before she completely flops. She kinda won but not in the way the monsters wanted her to (hits, cool, relevant).
even if they released 10 times a year it would still be embarrassing that they're bigger than the woman who just a few years ago was the "biggest star on the planet"
You do realize that by the end of the week Joanne is at 500k SPS in the U.S after 2 months? Had she released in January like Rihanna, she would have been at the very least Top 20 on the list. But no she released in damn near November so let's drag her on year end lists since it's an easy target.
But it did prove she maintains a large and loyal fan base. It'll be a while before she completely flops. She kinda won but not in the way the monsters wanted her to (hits, cool, relevant).
Yes the loyal monsters are buying the album 9 weeks late. The 58,000 that bought it in the past week WW are paw-lifting little monsters.
No. This is what it looks like when ONLY your loyal fanbase buys an album:
Say what you want to say, but at the end of the day Joanne will be the 2nd or 3rd best selling female album of 2016. 375k+ in the US and 800k+ WW pure sales in only 10 weeks. The GP loves it and its sales will skyrocket when the Super Bowl comes
beyonce
adele
taylor swift
rihanna
ariana grande
celine dion
either your concept of "2nd or 3rd" is skewed or you've forgotten a few
But it did prove she maintains a large and loyal fan base. It'll be a while before she completely flops. She kinda won but not in the way the monsters wanted her to (hits, cool, relevant).
Eh, in the Monsters' world, "Perfect Illusion" was a multi-week WW #1 hit that eclipsed "Uptown Funk!" so... I guess that's cool enough, right?
But it did prove she maintains a large and loyal fan base. It'll be a while before she completely flops. She kinda won but not in the way the monsters wanted her to (hits, cool, relevant).
All these sales are not coming from her fans Her pure sales are very consistent
170k-43k-18k-11k-21k-24k-19k-18k-28k
Just admit, I'm sure ya'll thought that it would never go Gold, but it already has after only 9 weeks. She won
beyonce
adele
taylor swift
rihanna
ariana grande
celine dion
either your concept of "2nd or 3rd" is skewed or you've forgotten a few
She just passed Taylor's 2016 figures this week. Ariana is at 1m and Celine at 860k She will surpass both with ease and will be competing with Rihanna but will most likely still end up behind. Hence, 3rd.
Like at least the first time it made sense because she got the Vanguard award but there was no reason for her to do it this year 
