[asanders10795544]

Whitney? No

Mariah? Maybe in certain categories.

[ThirdWardBey]

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

[robotdanger]

Beyonce is the most successful and honored Black female artist of all time.

[slaveney]

ROTF

[mdnazn]

Originally posted by ThirdWardBey

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

Originally posted by robotdanger

Beyonce is the most successful and honored black female artist of all time.

whew

[madonnas]

Originally posted by ABeyBraith

So what's your question? Has Beyoncé surpassed Whitney and Mariah's legacy or if she's the #1 female of her generation? Please be consistent..

Seeing as how she's still this huge after so long, my question in the OP is really not that unreasonable of a question. That's what I was trying to say.

[Hazard]

Originally posted by ThirdWardBey

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

Now sis...

[RajibDavid]

What a troll thread. Obviously not.

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by ThirdWardBey

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

Beyoncé has stated that "Vision of Love" is what made her want to become a singer though so let's calm down a bit

[DirtyPony87]

No, but she's getting there.
This thread is going to get messy: one side is going to use it as an opportunity to ruthlessly and gratuituously drag Beyonce; the other is going to just become incredibly defensive and hysterical.

[TeemoR]

Madonna > Whitney >> Beyonce > Lady Gaga > Mariah > rest

[Brando]

Originally posted by ABeyBraith

*Translating*



"I wanna get Beyoncé dragged, let me ask something that will surely cause her to be dragged. Drag ATRL!"


Y'all get more transparent every single day and as usual, people will bite the bait.

madonnas is actually very serious and loves Beyonce. This is not a shade fest, not need to get preemptively hyper-defensive.

---

I think Whitney and Mariah are still Titans. Beyonce is up there, but she will need another album or two to surpass them.

[ABeyBraith]

Originally posted by ThirdWardBey

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

You're not helping.

Originally posted by madonnas

Seeing as how she's still this huge after so long, my question in the OP is really not that unreasonable of a question. That's what I was trying to say.

It is unreasonable. Beyoncé is a huge superstar, she has had incredible impact and is still relevant thanks to her consistency/work ethic, she is undoubtedly the #1 female of her generation. Whitney and Mariah are hailed as untouchable legends, which I agree with so comparing them to Beyoncé (on ATRL of all places) is only asking for her to be dragged.

[TipToe]

Originally posted by Hazard

Now sis...

Do you think people are going to remember more of self-titled or Daydream/Bodyguard soundtrack when it's all said and done? Puh-lease.

[PrettyHurts]

Originally posted by TeemoR

Madonna > Whitney >> Beyonce > Lady Gaga > Mariah > rest

[Anticipating]

Originally posted by ThirdWardBey

Self-titled alone has made more of an impact in the music industry than Mariah and Whitney ever have.

[g.m.]

Originally posted by TeemoR

Lady Gaga > Mariah

What!?!

[Hi_im_new]

No. Their success and impact is unparalleled by any of the female acts that debuted after them.

[slw84]

So you either knew this was a disrespectful topic or you didn't and I'm not sure which one concerns me more....
No one is surpassing Whitney and Mariah...

[ABeyBraith]

Originally posted by Brando

madonnas is actually very serious and loves Beyonce. This is not a shade fest, not need to get preemptively hyper-defensive.

You and I both know that that is exactly what it will turn into, don't be so obtuse.