[Clump]

100% factual order = Asylum > MH > Coven > Hotel > FS

Roanoke is looking like it will slip between Asylum and MH or if it nosedives, MH and Coven.

[maurixrosup]

Originally posted by Tylerbv

The only pros of Hotel are:
- The soundtrack
- The hotel is kinda pretty
- It's over

this

[Tylerbv]

I stand by
Asylum > Murder House >>> Freak Show >> Coven >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Hotel

[Yves]

The only correct order:

1. Asylum
2. Murder House
3. Coven
4. Hotel
5. Freak Show

[ahauntingnearu]

Originally posted by Clump

100% factual order = Asylum > MH > Coven > Hotel > FS

Roanoke is looking like it will slip between Asylum and MH or if it nosedives, MH and Coven.

I almost entirely agree with you. I have rewatch Hotel first, but I do think FS is better than Hotel, only slightly, or maybe they're about equal.

And completely agree with your potential placements for Roanoke

[Dylangaga]

Another day of the same users posting about Hotel

Poor you OHH

Asylum=Coven=Hotel>>>>>the rest

[CroNich]

The correct order is basically what everyone else has already said

Asylum > Murder House > Coven > Freakshow > Hotel

However if the ending to Roanoke is as amazing as the rest of the season that could put it in front of Asylum or at least have it tie with it.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Asylum > Coven > Murder House > Freak Show > Hotel

Roanoke thus far is just ahead of Murder House

[britkneepopboi]

Bye at all this Hotel hate.
Why ya'll insist on dragging and picking apart each season is beyond me
Either way, we still watched every episode and were entertained at one point or another.

[HandsOn]

Originally posted by Lucky****

'Hotel' wasn't the pits...I enjoyed it more than Freak Show...and dare I say...Asylum

OMG! I'm glad I'm not the only one.

[ceremonials]

Mesa how do we always end up rating the season s every 5 pages

We need a new rate! Before the AHS6 rate.

Soundtrack rate?
Episode rate?

[ceremonials]

Or we could have one mega AHS rate where we vote for different categories.

Season Categories:

Best Writing
Best Plot
Best Acting
Best Set
Best Characters
Best Preseason
Best Special Effects
Best Makeup
Best Editing
Best Score
Best Soundtrack

Episode Categories:

Best Premiere
Best Finale
Best Plot Twist
Best Writing
Best Plot

Acting Categories:

Best Villain
Best Protagonist
Best Actor
Best Supporting Actor
Best Actress
Best Supporting Actress
Best Character Development
Best Death Scene

And maybe more if y'all can think of any!

[Tylerbv]

Best Plot Twist: Violet season 1 is the only right answer.

[ceremonials]

Or Ben dying. Those + it's mine are the only ones that really shocked me

[CroNich]

Bye at all the Gaga stans trying to say Hotel was anything more than a hot mess.

[chiliam]

Coven is much more entertaining than Murder house.

[Tylerbv]

Originally posted by ceremonials

Or Ben dying. Those + it's mine are the only ones that really shocked me

I called It's Mine in the first part of the episode. One of the only times I've been right about something on AHS

There were no big twists in Coven, Freak Show, or Hotel so there's not much competition

[Pop]

1. Asylum
2. Hotel
3. Murder House
4. Coven
5. Freak Show

[itsnickcray]

1. Asylum
2. Hotel
2. Coven
4. Murder House
5. Freak Show

Roanoke will be between Coven and Murder House I think.

TBH I don't hate any season. I like them all in their own way. I even love Freak Show just because of the amazing visuals.

[Brunette Ambition]

i love loving every season of my fav show