[Tutankhamun]

Originally posted by Аshanti

Because it was 1,5 years ago?

And Joanne is released in Q4? Were sales in 2015 much bigger?

According to the monsters' logic:

Someone 33 years into her career, debuts with 120K in sales in 2015 = Big flop! Has-been!
Someone 8 years into her career, biggest pop star a few years ago, debuts with similar figures = Talent Won! OGH Lost!

The monsters are the most hypocritical fanbase ever. Always playing the victim and then suddenly acting all cocky and braggy when she's not doing terrible.

[Ethereaaal]

Originally posted by Tutankhamun

And Joanne is released in Q4? Were sales in 2015 much bigger?

According to the monsters' logic:

Someone 33 years into her career, debuts with 120K in sales in 2015 = Big flop!
Someone 8 years into her career, the biggest pop star in the world a few years ago, debuts with similar figures = Talent Won! OGH Lost!

The monsters are the most hypocritical fanbase ever. Always playing the victim and suddenly acting all cocky and braggy when she's not doing terrible.

Thanks for your input!

Meltdown a bit

[eli's_rhythm]

Originally posted by smoothkarmel

It's funny how back in 2009 the monsters were dragging bey saying she needed gaga for a hit and she's local now 7 years later Lemonade selling over 485k in pure sales first week at 17.99 . My oh my how the tables have turned.

If anything it was 3 Britney fans in SYG saying this, not munsters.

[Shaner69]

I inflated sales is Gaga's thing.

[Mark Rih]

Originally posted by istan4badgalriri

LM talking about sales climate and how we can't compare 1-2 year old album sales to Joanne sales, but.... They had no problem comparing ARTPOP's 2013 sales to ANTI's 2016 sales, just 2 months after ANTI's release.

And again....

kiii well at least now LM are finally aware that sales have been declining a lot over the past 3 years.

Well at least they know now Better late then never I guess.

Originally posted by Komet blu

Rihanna stans embarrassing themselves in here

Nah, they're just clocking some proud cocky LMs

Originally posted by G.U.Y

Both Thread Starters are not "LM" ; Beautiful Liar stans xtina ,Bey Admired stans bey & adele

"s" & "s " cancelled

Yeah because the monsters in those threads obviously said that the comparison was wrong and they didn't say 'ARTPOP was bigger cuz it sold more!!!11!'. Yeah right.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Tutankhamun

And Joanne is released in Q4? Were sales in 2015 much bigger?

According to the monsters' logic:

Someone 33 years into her career, debuts with 120K in sales in 2015 = Big flop! Has-been!
Someone 8 years into her career, biggest pop star a few years ago, debuts with similar figures = Talent Won! OGH Lost!

It's not our logic, it's everyone's logic.
Your explanation makes it even more obvious we're right!

[6_INCH_HEELS]

Ok, these numbers aren't bad for Gaga. Go girl!

[erianoillim]

Originally posted by I am your light

HDD initial predictions are always messy

Still great numbers for Gaga. No need to her fanbase to panic or some OGH's to drag her.

As a OGH I'mma keep quiet because these numbers are cute, you all should do as well.

Thank you

[MarinaKal]

Omg ATRL taught me that she would sell less than Britney

[Xavi]

Originally posted by hausofhofverbergs

I am pleasantly surprised with GaGa's opening week sales, good for the current climate.

100k+ is great for any artist nowadays, only a select few can sell over 200k+.

Why can't we celebrate success for ANY female artist instead of dragging them down

That's the true.

Pop are dying and the stupid fan bases only fight.

[Marioland]

Imagine how horribly low first week sales for Katy Perry will be with this climate. I predict lower than 90k. Gaga still has power while Katy Perry is totally forgotten!

[UnusualBoy]

Originally posted by Marioland

Imagine how horribly low first week sales for Katy Perry will be with this climate. I predict lower than 90k. Gaga still has power while Katy Perry is totally forgotten!

Prism opened with better numbers than AP and Rise had a better peak than PI, what's this non-sense?

[KCLA]

Originally posted by Marioland

Imagine how horribly low first week sales for Katy Perry will be with this climate. I predict lower than 90k. Gaga still has power while Katy Perry is totally forgotten!

But Rise sold more than PI in its 1st week.


OT: Gaga's numbers are aomething appreciated only by LM

[istan4badgalriri]

Originally posted by Marioland

Imagine how horribly low first week sales for Katy Perry will be with this climate. I predict lower than 90k. Gaga still has power while Katy Perry is totally forgotten!

Katy will do 200k+ first week. Maybe even more, depending on the lead single.

[Marioland]

Originally posted by istan4badgalriri

Katy will do 200k+ first week. Maybe even more, depending on the lead single.

You'd wish! She will be catastrophically flopping left and right!

[Artemisia]

Adjusted down 20k after SNL??

[eteru]

Will this even go gold

[AALIYAH DANA]

The fact she went from selling a million first week to less than 200k in 5 years

[Aden]

Woooo still going #1.

[Lyrical.]

Originally posted by Marioland

You'd wish! She will be catastrophically flopping left and right!

The fact that LMs can still be this cocky amazes me.