[Britney Jean]

This episode is such a hot mess, but i still like it

Poor Diana tho, she's pretty, level-headed and didn't deserve to get killed horribly like that

Finally real acting from Lily Rabe, she's awesome as always

Evan's given such a little screen time in this season, him being dead for real this time

Sidney's so stupid by not hiring Kathy as the Butcher again, you know what kind of things an insane person like her will do if she's being treated badly like in that interview. She's gonna kill everyone and probably she's the only one that'll survive in the end

Cheyenne always plays the most stupid person since Hotel btw. Never liked any of his role, he's an eye-candy tho

[Danial]

The car tape scene

I'm ready for the mess in the house

[A Little Unruly]

Bout to watch.

[Aviana]

Cheyenne is so annoying, Agnes please smite ha!!

Could Taissa be playing Zoe? Since Gaga is the original Supreme, they might bring back a Coven character for a guest role?
The current Supreme can not be there for an obviously reason and all the other witches are dead except Zoe..

[Shendelzare]

this season

[Silence.]

This episode was good except there was one thing I really ****ing wish they left out

'All but one died over the next three days'

WHY would you say that?

[Aviana]

How many episodes left before the mid-season break?

[Silence.]

So from the looks of it one of the OG people probably made a deal with the butcher for everyone to die but them. It seems like that person is Matt

[Navyofbadgals]

this episode
I can't

lots of scares though, I definitely liked it

[Navyofbadgals]

Originally posted by Silence.

So from the looks of it one of the OG people probably made a deal with the butcher for everyone to die but them. It seems like that person is Matt

where did you get this theory?

[CroNich]

Originally posted by Gagamon

I have a feeling we will see the real scathach/Gaga's character again this season since her story was never finished

But no more Gaga

I have a feeling that Gaga's character met Sydney before the filming commenced and is part of the reason he has brought the cast back as a 'sacrifice'.

[OreGuy]

Originally posted by Aviana

How many episodes left before the mid-season break?

I think there's no mid season happening. This season will be concluded on Nov. 16(my bday btw hihi) if there's no stuff that will happen soon to postpone the episodes.

[Navyofbadgals]

I wonder what the 10th episode could be though

[Navyofbadgals]

btw won't the ratings be an absolute mess because of the debate? or did they air at different times?

[HEARTCORE]

Originally posted by Silence.

This episode was good except there was one thing I really ****ing wish they left out

'All but one died over the next three days'

WHY would you say that?

A lot of people complained about how watching the 'real' people tell their story in 'My Roanoke Nightmare' made it clear that they would survive. By including the fact that everyone except one person dies makes it clear that the confessionals in 'Return to Roanoke' do not necessarily equate to safety.

[A Little Unruly]

I was so confused when Shelby got busted for her affair with Dominic Banks. Took me a minute to adjust to the fact that he isn't Matt.

Overall, this episode and the Big Brother concept gave me Halloween Resurrection and Blair Witch 2: Book of Shadows teas.

I hope Matt is going to be that one person to live.

I think it would have been a very interesting spin if it had turned out that Matt, Shelby and Lee made up the entire thing for the cash (Lee did kill Mason) and the actual horror would have come in form of the cast members and real life versions going crazy on each other during the shoot of the second season, entirely leaving out supernatural elements. But yeah, what they went with will do, too.

[Silence.]

Originally posted by HEARTCORE

A lot of people complained about how watching the 'real' people tell their story in 'My Roanoke Nightmare' made it clear that they would survive. By including the fact that everyone except one person dies makes it clear that the confessionals in 'Return to Roanoke' do not necessarily equate to safety.

I'd prefer they just left that out. Let me watch them die and see one survivor make it to the end. ATM with each actor I'm watching I feel like.. okay odds are you're going to die.

[Silence.]

Originally posted by Navyofbadgals

where did you get this theory?

I just think there's something off with Matt. I think he's still witched up.

[A Little Unruly]

Originally posted by Silence.

So from the looks of it one of the OG people probably made a deal with the butcher for everyone to die but them. It seems like that person is Matt

That deal doesn't make any sense, though, cuz once that person got away they were safe. So why would the butcher offer such a deal when she knows she has no power outside of the woods to get back to them or that person actually comply to that deal after they're back in civilization and could just mind their own business?

[Innocencelost]

All this meta-reality is giving me thrills never felt before. Ryan managed to truly reinvent AHS and make it fresh again! Chapeau