I really hate AY-O . Thankful for the one-two punch of John Wayne and DIC to cleanse my memory of that song.
Here are my First Impressions
Diamond Heart- Alright. Average Gaga track that gets better towards the end
Ay-O

Chorus is the only good part.
Joanne: It's really pretty. Makes me want Joanne to come back

Would be better if it was a short interlude thoughl.
John Wayne -Intro is amazing. Love the cowboy talk juxtaposed with the valley girl "like"s. Verses are great. Breakdown in the chorus could have been a little better, but still good.
DIC: One of the best songs. Outro is soo good. WIsh it had a defined chorus but her mumblings still sound great. The bridge slightly reminds me to that of Sexxx Dream's. It fits well with the song.
PI: Is it me or is it mixed better than the single version? It's worse than the previous track, but its still good and high energy. Key change is as great as ever.
Million Reasons: The switch from PI to Million reasons is a bit abrupt

Typical ballad. Good, but not great. Nothing distinguishable about it.
Sinner's Prayer: I wish it was more like the Dive bar performance where the base comes after a while instead of the beginning because it makes it more dramatic. Other than that, I enjoy how smooth it is.
Come To Mama: One of the biggest surprises. I was not feeling the snippet at all but its soooo sweet w/o coming off as too corny. Really strong sing-a-long factor
Hey Girl: It's alright. Florence just sings circles around Gaga and I dont really like the format of the song. It needs a chorus that doesnt sound like it would fit right in with the verses. The outro is her best outro ever though. Best production along with Sinner's Prayer on the album.
Angel Down: It's good but forgettable. Edit: nvm best ballad on the album
I'd rate it 7.2/10 upon first listen . A little too ballad heavy to the point where it gets tiring. The middle is where the album really shines. I also like the key changes. Definitely a step up from ARTPOP