[rihannafan]

Example of songs tht have limited commercial appeal: FourFiveSeconds and Russian Roulette
Example of songs that have commercial appeal: Applause, Perfect Illusion, Born This Way, Bad Romance and Just Dance

[Perririsus]

Originally posted by Darren

Well? It doesn't sound like a song that would go #1 on pop radio, does it?

It's a fact that between Just Dance, Applause, Born This Way, and Bad Romance, this is EASILY her least commercial lead single.

Just because it bombed does not mean it was not meant to smash. It was in everyone's interest. Accept it already.

[Schhh]

Gaga rush releasing second single

[chris1991]

When is Kim's new sex tape going to leak?

[Darren]

Originally posted by RoarRiteNow1

PI is a 3 minute song with a catchy danceable beat + the 2 biggest hit producers of 2015 behind it, liddos need to stop trying to spread the myth it's not commercial

Mark Ronson and BloodPop produced PI, yes, but so did the people responsible for Tame Impala's discography and Dope

[DoubleDutchess]

We all knew PI wasn't hit material after the first listen. Still a great song. It'll be a classic in 10 years.

[Darren]

Originally posted by Perririsus

Just because it bombed does not mean it was not meant to smash. It was in everyone's interest. Accept it already.

I could have told you from the night the song was released that it wasn't going to be a hit. In fact, you can probably find that in my posting history if you care to search.

[jose168]

Perfect illusion is a catchy 3 minute pop song with standard structure and basic relateable lyrics. Its more commercial than any of her lead singles.

[Badger]

Kum looking like a skull draped with plastic

[Nialler]

This Love is kinda underrated hymn. Loose her tween diary'd sings

[Duca]

Originally posted by Darren

Well? It doesn't sound like a song that would go #1 on pop radio, does it?

It's a fact that between Just Dance, Applause, Born This Way, and Bad Romance, this is EASILY her least commercial lead single.

of course it does

the song is essentially just one long hook

[Darren]

Originally posted by Nialler

This Love is kinda underrated hymn. Loose her tween diary'd sings

Best song on 1989.

[Willy.]

Perfect Illusion is a commercial song. If she would've just sang it in the tone that she sings the bridge, none of this would've occurred, lol.

[Jaspurr]

The fact that Fad probably thinks PI is commercial-sounding is the real problem here. So out of touch with reality.

[Delilah.]

Originally posted by jose168

Perfect illusion is a catchy 3 minute pop song with standard structure and basic relateable lyrics. Its more commercial than any of her lead singles.

But it has a guitar

[Pink Matter]

Chart Listings: H100: Starboy #3

I love it when talent wins

[Dämon]

Originally posted by jose168

Perfect illusion is a catchy 3 minute pop song with standard structure and basic relateable lyrics. Its more commercial than any of her lead singles.

Just Dance (her most basic, generic + trashiest lead single) says hi though.

[RoarRiteNow1]

Originally posted by Darren

Mark Ronson and BloodPop produced PI, yes, but so did the people responsible for Tame Impala's discography and Dope

Exactly, it had all the ingredients of a hit song but Gaga is simply extremely talentless as a songwriter (this was clear the minute she stopped getting RedOne + Rob Fusari to write all her songs for her)

[RichGirlPlanet]

To be fair, any music GaGa would put out nowadays would have 'limited commercial appeal' just for simply having her name attached.

[Nialler]

Perfect Delusion was definitely produced to be a big radio hit. But Faga is just the worst mainstream songwriter.