[WeFoundTrouble]

Because Carly actually makes GOOD pop music.

[Schhh]

Atrl drags Katy cuz she's at the top of her game. Carly has little success and no "stans" so dragging her would be wasting time.

[MadelineXPepito]

Carly had some haters (me) when CMM smashed. I feel like it's driven by her lack of success (compared to Katy), but also Emotion truly is better than anything Katy ever released.

[Natawie]

Originally posted by KillingYourCareer

Because Katy has a lot of bitter haters from certain fanbases who will use any excuse to drag her down, while Carly isn't commercially successful so she has no haters really.

[Andres]

Because Carly actually makes GOOD pop music.

[Bencharmer]

Cause Katy is more successful than others.

[vuelve88]

Katy is misunderstood. It took people a while to appreciate Bjork. This is the same.

[ImmaSlave4u]

Because Carly isn't competition, meanwhile Katy is more successful than most.

[LAHouK]

Carly's songwriting is better than Katy's. Katy songwriting can be cringey sometimes.

[alfonso12]

Originally posted by wehan6

katy perry makes great quality pop music and ATRL just doesn't seem to get that!!!

Weird, seems like professional critics and the Grammys committee doesn't seem to get that either.

[wesleywalrus]

Because Katy doesn't make good music

[UnusualBoy]

It has more to with the fact that Katy is a main girl and a threat in certain way towards their faves unlike Carly.

[RickyH.]

Originally posted by LovingYourCareer

Because Carly actually makes GOOD pop music.

.

[B'Day]

G.O.O.D Music

[PieceByPiece_KC]

Pure Pop is dead right now. Katy is in trouble

[lightstheyblindme]

Carly's music seems elevated compared to katy's also she writes it herself

[Reinvention]

Because Carly actually makes GOOD pop music.

[PrismaticFluff]

Originally posted by Reinvention

Because Carly actually makes GOOD pop music.

reinvention wyd

[Kunst]

Carly makes GOOD pop music, no misses. Katy only hit it right with Teenage Dream (the song).

[Samuel]

Katy is a major threat, Carly is not. Also because Carly is commercially unsuccessful and Katy isn't, ATRLers think they have some air of superiority by liking her and not Katy because she's totes indie or something. idk why they act like they don't bop their bussies whenever they hear California Gurls on the radio but w/e!