Discussion: ATRL | Top 100 Albums Of All Time (Canceled) - Page 29

Ventitonic

I needed to know if charmbracelet was gonna make it by some miracle

pls continue 4 the fans

MasterXPosed

Quote:

Originally posted by wehan6

ok i don't wanna be annoying OP because everyone is coming for you now but maybe just do this rate like all the other rates have been done. #1 gets 20 points and #20 gets 1 point.

i know that means you have to recount the votes and start the list over but i'll be happy to help you and we can ask someone else to help too. i know you have a personal life and can't be on the ATRL 24/7 but it doesn't have to be done in one day.

i know your not cheating and this is just a suggestion. if you still want to finish the rate using your formula it's totally fine and sorry for complaining

Thank you! I already stated i'd post the results at the end but the people complaining aren't making it fun anymore. I've already posted half the ranking so there's no reason to redo it.

MasterXPosed

Quote:

Originally posted by Wicked

Sweetie, we just needed to know what the formula used is. You can't tell us that much?

It would've cleared everything up pages ago. As the rate went on more things seemed wacky.

True, i stated that i did it by points, if an album is 2 and it's the only album in all 53 lists, it'll just have 19 points and it won't be far on this list or not at all. and then it goes to a spot compared to how many people submitted it in what ranking.

Brando

Tacky. Wasted everyone's time and effort. And now that you've been exposed you are running away pretending to be upset. Shouldn't have started this in the first place. Feel free to post the results and method though. Very curious how ended up with these bizarre placements.

MasterXPosed

Quote:

Originally posted by Brando

Tacky. Wasted everyone's time and effort. And now that you've been exposed you are running away pretending to be upset. Shouldn't have started this in the first place. Feel free to post the results and method though. Very curious how ended up with these bizarre results.

I'm not pretending to be upset? You're actually being really rude for no reason. This is a forum. I started this for fun, first time doing a rank so "sorry" if i didn't include the votes with the albums.

Changes

Brando

Quote:

Originally posted by MasterXPosed

True, i stated that i did it by points, if an album is 2 and it's the only album in all 53 lists, it'll just have 19 points and it won't be far on this list or not at all. and then it goes to a spot compared to how many people submitted it in what ranking.

Then tell us who voted for

Otis Blue
What's Going On
Homogenic

Their placements on people's lists, how many people included them on their lists and their overall points.

Ventitonic

Quote:

Originally posted by Wicked

Okay. But this doesn't make much sense still? The albums in the bubbling under section you said only got one point.

So if my #2 was only mentioned by me it would've still made it on. I think that's where the problem was.

Maybe MasterXPosed meant to say bubbling under albums were only mentioned on 1 list and in a high ranking on said list rather than only getting 1 point.

Tom Vercetti

dansuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Brando

Then tell us who voted for

Otis Blue
What's Going On
Homogenic

Their placements on people's lists, how many people included them on their lists and their overall points.

Why are you trying to antagonise him? I understand you've put your effort into it, yeah. But can't you be a bit more respectful?

Subomie

yall post ur lists tho, I need those listening ideas (I already got some Marvin albums since his appearance)

Brando

Quote:

Originally posted by dansuxx

Why are you trying to antagonise him? I understand you've put your effort into it, yeah. But can't you be a bit more respectful?

No, not really. He is trying to run away from this with the excuse that we upset him. I actually want to confirm that he is running away because this whole thing was BS as already evident from comments on last 3 pages.

MasterXPosed

I'm not running away, not even upset but no point to post the rest if comment after comment is gonna be rude from you. I said i'd post the results at the end.

Brando

Quote:

Originally posted by Subomie

yall post ur lists tho, I need those listening ideas (I already got some Marvin albums since his appearance)

For Marvin go for Let's Get it On & What's Going On first. Let's Get It On is the smoothest & sexiest album of all time.

---

My List:

1. The Smiths - The Queen is Dead
2. Radiohead - Kid A
3. Frank Ocean - Channel Orange
4. Kanye West - My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy
5. Joni Mitchell - Blue
6. Radiohead - OK Computer
7. Kendrick Lamar - Good Kid Maad City
8. Arcade Fire - The Suburbs
9. Marvin Gaye - What's Going On
10. Bjork - Homogenic
11. Madonna - Like A Prayer
12. Bon Iver - Bon Iver Bon Iver
13. Janelle Monae - The ArchAndroid
14. The Weeknd - House of Balloons
15. Fleetwood Mac - Rumours
16. Prince - Purple Rain
17. Michael Jackson - Off The Wall
18. Kate Bush - Hounds of Love
19. John Coltrane - A Love Supreme
20. Nas - Illmatic
21. Jay Z - The Blueprint
22. The Beach Boys - Pet Sounds
23. The Beatles - Revolver
24. David Bowie - Hunky Dory
25. Dr Dre - The Chronic

dansuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Brando

No, not really. He is trying to run away from this with the excuse that we upset him. I actually want to confirm that he is running away because this whole thing was BS as already evident from comments on last 3 pages.

If it was BS, don't participate

Don't try and make him look a d*** when it's an album rate. It may be his first time, and stressful - and that's not particularly helped when you're trying to 'expose' him for not continuing an album rate he clearly wasn't enjoying.

Playa Playa

Quote:

Originally posted by Brando

Then tell us who voted for

Otis Blue
What's Going On
Homogenic

Their placements on people's lists, how many people included them on their lists and their overall points.

OP should at least do this so we can understand what he was doing

Brando

Quote:

Originally posted by MasterXPosed

I'm not running away, not even upset but no point to post the rest if comment after comment is gonna be rude from you. I said i'd post the results at the end.

Well, why instead of being defensive and saying this is your first countdown, you just follow people's advice and start showing numbers and names with your results. You don't have to finish this countdown in 2 days. Take your time, post one album at a time, 5 albums a day. Take a few days break, post another 5. It only escalated to this because you've been ignoring people's advice and complaints.

Paul McCutie

i was trying to help op telling him he should count all the votes before starting the countdown, but he didn't listen, he "checked" all the lists and started bubbling under with albums that only got 1 point instead, whereas many albums that got more points were not even mentioned. that's why i'm not even commenting on anything here. i think it's great that he put the effort into it, but it just makes zero sense to wonder which albums won if you do it all wrong... people sent you their lists, this could be a great thread. but you counted it weird, put wrong albums into bubbling under and when i told you like 100 times that you can't do it like that, instead of starting over, you continued with this without even saying how many points each album got.

i'm sorry, but this is a mess. don't worry about it too much though. next time you'll know better.

M A R N ✮

Don't cancel though

I wanted you to count the rest! I can post them for you if you don't want too Hun

please don't cancel this! One of my fave rates and I really was trying to support you

by recapping and everything

AlexisNeiers