[Mermaid]

whats so great about michaels performance..i mean its good but seriously the judges praised it like its out of this ****ing world or something..and simon said 'best performance throughout the competition so far'.. really..?

everytime aaron open his mouth i just want to shut my tv his voice is so annoying it never stop..! todrick will go as well..tim performance wasnt that good either he ruined that classic..i dont know what the judges hearing..

[igor]

My favorite girls this week are Crystal, Lilly and Didi. I think Paige and Katie should go home, they weren't good, especially Paige, her performance was BORING.

About the boys, my favorites are Alex (I'm completely in love with him, he gets better every week), Tim (I didn't see this coming, his performance was really great) and Michael (but I don't see him having a successful career and I think the judges overpraise him). Todrick and Andrew should go home, they were terrible. If Andrew doesn't go, I hope Aaron goes instead.

[Evan]

Why is everyone hating on Todrick? I thought he had the best performance among the guys.

[tcatron565]

Yes Todrick is gone! Tim still in. How did that make it into the top 12?

Although, I will have to admit Todrick gave his best performance of the season so far last night.

[ForrestFuller]

Originally posted by tcatron565

Yes Todrick is gone! Tim still in. How did that make it into the top 12?

He actually had a good week.

[Carrie-is-no-1]

KATELYN is gone i knew that the audience cannot connect with her

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Aaron is in who's out??

[tcatron565]

Katie's going. Lilly has too strong of a fanbase to be voted off this early.

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Alex Lambert is eliminated!

[dussymob]

Alex, Todrick, and Katelyn are gone. Aww I liked Alex.

[Evan]

Andrew should've gone.

[dussymob]

Well either Paige has a stronger fanbase than we think or VFTW saved her ass last night.

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Originally posted by tcatron565

Katie's going. Lilly has too strong of a fanbase to be voted off this early.

I hope they don't save the shocking elimination for last

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Originally posted by dussymob

Well either Paige has a stronger fanbase than we think or VFTW saved her ass last night. :shock:

It's demo splitting. I don't think VFTW is that of a big deal.

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Originally posted by dussymob

Alex, Todrick, and Katelyn are gone. Aww I liked Alex.

me too Ales sound is so unique

[dussymob]

Originally posted by Carrie-is-no-1

It's demo splitting. I don't think VFTW is that of a big deal.

Good I hope she improves on the big stage and don't get eliminated early on.

[dussymob]

Lilli's gone

[tcatron565]

WHAT?! I did NOT see that one coming! I like Katie more than Lilly, but I thought Lilly was a shoe in for top 12!

[ForrestFuller]

Both Katie and Lily deserve the Top 12.Not Lacey and Paige.

[tcatron565]

Ew. I didn't see the girls perform. If this was the way she was that night, I see why she was eliminated. Patsy Cline? You don't touch her songs. Especially with the voice Lilly's got. She's got a very unique and cool voice, but wow. BAD song choice.