[jEnJeN_aeL]

john got eliminated???? ugh.......ow...my fav is gone.....

i'll miss him...

[dussymob]

Originally posted by Evan

All my faves are being eliminated. If Paige goes, I'm done with Idol this season.

Didi should've gone, not Michelle. And Joe's elimination last week was just horrible. :-/

Andrew should've gone, not Jermaine. And how the **** is Lacey still there? Last week she was horrendous and this week her performance was just.....average.

[dussymob]

Originally posted by Pon.

1 Asian and 3 black contestants have gone LMFAO

I'll miss Michelle, miss her gorgeous outfits <3
I'll miss Haeley - the cute girl, miss her smile <3
I'll miss the incredible voice of John <3

Yeah this show lost credibility when they started only having a dominant amount of caucasians. Last season there was only 3 or 4 that wasn't caucasian. It sucks.

[Яeo.]

Noo I'm gonna miss Haeley she was cute.
But honestly, her performance of "The Climb" was horrible. It's just not a song for her.

[SwagLikeALegend]

Haeley

[fpppy]

Haeley has a good voice she just didnt pick the right songs. I agree with the other 3 that were voted off

[igor]

Haeley and Jermaine deserved to go home, they're terrible. I like Michelle and John, but they weren't good this week.

I hope Todrick, Lacey and Tim (or Andrew) go home next week.

[NE.]

Originally posted by Evan

All my faves are being eliminated. If Paige goes, I'm done with Idol this season.

Didi should've gone, not Michelle. And Joe's elimination last week was just horrible. :-/

Andrew should've gone, not Jermaine. And how the **** is Lacey still there? Last week she was horrendous and this week her performance was just.....average.

I agree, if they eliminate Paige and Michael, Im DONE.

This show is **** now. The season with Fantasia was it's last credible season and then it was all downhill from there.

Last season was some trash. The winner was the worst winner ever, and this season has already hit the fan.

[NE.]

Originally posted by dussymob

Yeah this show lost credibility when they started only having a dominant amount of caucasians. Last season there was only 3 or 4 that wasn't caucasian. It sucks.

DEATH at this, but SO true.

[MusicTalker]

So I compiled a point system based on the number of reviews each of the girl's got on iTunes for each of the their songs.

For example, Didi Benami's single last week got 387 reviews. Her current one has gotten 92 reviews.

So 387+92= 479

get it?

[MusicTalker]

Here's what i found...

1. Siohban Magnus 494
2. Didi Benami 479
3. Crystal Bowersox 448
4. Lilly Scott 371
5. Katie Stevens 343
6. Katelyn Epperly 319
7. Lacey Brown 258
8. Paige Miles 155

so it looks like Lacey & Paige are not gonna make top 12

[MusicTalker]

Here's for guys...

1. Andrew Garcia 701
2. Tim Urban 637
3. Alex Lambert 631
4. Lee Dwayze 626
5. Casey James 512
6. Aaron Kelly 393
7. Toddrick Hall 328
8. Michael Lynch 246

Toddrick & Michael are safe bets to go home

But why are guys getting so many more reviews than the girls?!

[MusicTalker]

Here's what your top 12 MAY look like... (this is a very loose prediction)

and don't ask me why guys numbers are so much higher than girls I don't know...

1. Andrew Garcia 701
2. Tim Urban 637
3. Alex Lambert 631
4. Lee Dwayze 626
5. Casey James 512
6. Siohban Magnus 494
7. Didi Benami 479
8. Crystal Bowersox 448
9. Aaron Kelly 393
10. Lilly Scott 371
11. Katie Stevens 343
12. Katelyn Epperly 319'

I'll be updating numbers daily now

[Mariah]

People age over 35 watch the show the most, and I don't think they go to iTunes very often.

[MusicTalker]

Originally posted by Mariah

People age over 35 watch the show the most, and I don't think they go to iTunes very often.

I know but the ratings basically show who's getting the most attention

except girls must be buying the majority of the songs! & they are buying all of the GUY's songs!

[dussymob]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Here's what your top 12 MAY look like... (this is a very loose prediction)

and don't ask me why guys numbers are so much higher than girls I don't know...

1. Andrew Garcia 701
2. Tim Urban 637
3. Alex Lambert 631
4. Lee Dwayze 626
5. Casey James 512
6. Siohban Magnus 494
7. Didi Benami 479
8. Crystal Bowersox 448
9. Aaron Kelly 393
10. Lilly Scott 371
11. Katie Stevens 343
12. Katelyn Epperly 319'

I'll be updating numbers daily now

This is as irrelevant as the crap show you can't go off no Itunes reviews. Micheal is one of the frontrunners and Tim Urban is horrible why would he make the final 2.

[MusicTalker]

But iTunes reviews might how how popular the contestant is in general .

[greenoz]

Originally posted by MusicTalker

Here's what your top 12 MAY look like... (this is a very loose prediction)

and don't ask me why guys numbers are so much higher than girls I don't know...

1. Andrew Garcia 701
2. Tim Urban 637
3. Alex Lambert 631
4. Lee Dwayze 626
5. Casey James 512
6. Siohban Magnus 494
7. Didi Benami 479
8. Crystal Bowersox 448
9. Aaron Kelly 393
10. Lilly Scott 371
11. Katie Stevens 343
12. Katelyn Epperly 319'

I'll be updating numbers daily now

wtf!

[MusicTalker]

Look the idea isn't as "lame" as you guys think it is. think about it, the more reviews a song gets, the more popular it is. & if you add their performances together, you get a generaliZation of how popular they might be.

But some things complicate it, so it is not as accurate as could be. Middle-aged people don't buy on iTunes nearly as much as teeangers & IMO the boys are selling more than the girls...

[JM4ever]

Paige will be eliminated or I'm done here.