[LoKoPaNdA]

She's on the same level as Pink & Christina Aguilera

[funnychick]

Maybe Celine. I don't think Bey has the influence on other pop girls that the others have.

[Bad Blood]

Madonna is a better/bigger touring force
Mariah can sing better
Janet can dance better/is the better performer
Whitney can sing better

No.

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by abrahamjmr

Beyoncé debuted as a solo artist when album sales where dying. She's currently outselling Madonna, Mariah and Janet. Whitney passed away, sadly, and she didn't release more albums after I Look To You, her last masterpiece.

Album sales aren't an indicator of who's popular, big or successful now since they're pretty much dead.

When Beyonce debuted, Avril & Norah Jones debuted with huge sales.
And nowadays look how much Adele and Taylor are selling

My point remains

NOT with those album sales missy

[SuperLolita]

Shes above all of them

[NEZ]

shes above janet tbh, maybe even madonna when it comes to singing and dancing.

[pieuxvu]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

Not with those albums sales, sorry.

What about with Tours and awards?

[NEZ]

im not even a bey fan but she might actually be above them. she can sing and dance circles around those girls in heels. peak whitney and maybe even peak mariah could sing better but not one girl is putting on a show like beyonce.

[NEZ]

Originally posted by MrDeeds

When Beyonce debuted, Avril & Norah Jones debuted with huge sales.
And nowadays look how much Adele and Taylor are selling

My point remains

NOT with those album sales missy

of course you compare her to white girls.

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by pieuxvu

What about with Tours and awards?

Tours werent that big back then and let's not even begin with prices.
Show me an 80s tour as long and expensive as nowadays.

Didnt Taylor outsold her last tour with less dates btw?

[MrDeeds]

Originally posted by NEZ

of course you compare her to white girls.

But I havent even mentioned P!nk! Which albums sales and singles were and still are bigger than Beyonce's.




PS: And she has decent tour numbers

[Marla Singer]

Same level as Madonna, Whitney and Celine.

She's above Mariah and Janet.

[swissman]

Of course she is.
The thing the other ladies have on her is time... she's still peaking.

[rihannabiggestfan]

lol no

[Haburo]

i love her a lot but IMO she's not quite 'there' yet, i feel like britneymania in the 00s kind of makes her closer to that status than bey but she will definitely end up there

[dabunique]

so Madonna was coming off her biggest number one record, Take A Bow and starting to get ready for Evita
Janet was gettin ready to unleash The Velvet Rope
Whitney had three consecutive top 5 hits from My Love is Your Love

14 years into their careers, the first two had multiple hits way after their first 14 years

She not there when she can't even get a pop hit, both Whitney & Janet were crossin over jus fine

I think we should introduce Rihanna into the equation

[A-P-P-L-A-U-S-E]

yes

[t.A.T.u.]

No, stop being delusional.

[Floyd Mayweather]

She's bigger than all of them

[Floyd Mayweather]

Originally posted by dabunique

so Madonna was coming off her biggest number one record, Take A Bow and starting to get ready for Evita
Janet was gettin ready to unleash The Velvet Rope
Whitney had three consecutive top 5 hits from My Love is Your Love

14 years into their careers, the first two had multiple hits way after their first 14 years

She not there when she can't even get a pop hit, both Whitney & Janet were crossin over jus fine

I think we should introduce Rihanna into the equation

But Beyonce is 19 years in her career