1. Tom - Katy
2. prezli - Kylie
3. rl231 - P!nk
4. Satan - Beyonce
5. URBAN - Rihanna
6. thecptz - Jessie
7. holyground - Taylor
Birthday was a tragedy. Kylie's music video looks like it was recorded with a razr phone. P!nk's is just a mess. Beyonce's is boring but nothing terrible. Same goes for Rihanna. Jessie's video isn't bad besides the corny scenes running on her body? Not sure who thought that would be artsy. As for Taylor, I just feel like a tour video was fine for New Romantics and it's not a terrible watch more so than it was disappointing we didn't get a "real video".
The videos are all tragic and should be erased from their vevo channels. All are terrible except from the two bottom boys.
Brian's Rank:
P7:
1. Tom Vercetti
2. thecptz
3. prezli
4. Satan
5. rl231
6. URBAN
7. holyground
The Birthday music video is so corny and try-hard I cannot bear it. I don’t think Taylor’s video was bad at all actually, sure it's a tour video but it’s still nicely done.
Element's Rank:
Part Seven: Worst Music Video
1. Katy Perry
2. P!nk
3. Kylie Minogue
4. Jessie J
5. Beyoncé
6. Taylor Swift
7. Rihanna
Birthday is tragic. P!nk offended my eyes. Kylie made me cringe. Jessie J/Bey were whatever. Taylor was fair, and Rih's was good tbh.
1. Satan - Beyonce
2. holyground - Taylor
3. prezli - Kylie
4. Tom - Katy
5. thecptz - Jessie
6. rl231 - P!nk
7. URBAN - Rihanna
Beyonce and Taylor's covers weren't anything special but they were at least passing as an actual cover. Kylie, Katy, and Jessie's covers looked extremely fanmade but at least they were done well. I appreciate the concept of P!nk's cover but it just looks cluttered. And Rihanna's cover is just a cartoon version of a picture that's already out there so I just didn't find it creative at all.
The Top 3 are all masterpieces. I love Kylie's bright colors blending with each other. Katy is also perfect, Jessie looked hot! The bottom 3 looked boring to me. Especially Taylor's cover. It looks the same with 1989's single covers.
Brian's Rank:
P8:
1. prezli
2. Tom Vercetti
3. holyground
4. Satan
5. URBAN
6. rl231
7. thecptz
I think the Kylie cover is really cool, and the Katy one looks very well done and legit. The Jessie J one looks kind of corny and cheap to me.
Element's Rank:
Part Eight: Best Fanmade Cover
1. Katy Perry
2. Beyoncé
3. Kylie Minogue
4. Jessie J
5. P!nk
6. Rihanna
7. Taylor Swift
As a Coverlandia user, submitter, and commenter, I have seen some of these covers before and some of them are by my favorite designers (specifically benikari who did Jessie's). Katy's and Beyonce's are my absolute favorites here because they combine original, professional designs with an appropriate theme that harkens back to the actual song/album. Kylie and Jessie are really great original designs, although the artist behind Jessie's has a lot better. P!nk falls flat for me and feels over-processed. Rihanna's is really cool from an artistic perspective, but it doesn't work as a cover imo. And Taylor's lacks energy and intrigue.
Despite a tie, rl231 is eliminated instead of URBAN due to having the lower average placement. URBAN's average placement in P1-P7 was about 5.0 while rl's was about 6.8.
Sorry, but you will be up for elimination at Tribal Council!
5. slimSHADY - Avril Lavigne - Things I'll Never Say
6. holyground - Taylor Swift - Wonderland
*Not Taylor singing but y'all should know the song anyway*
7. Satan - Beyoncé - End of Time
8. wesleywalrus - Britney Spears - Breathe On Me
9. Xed Lodz - Kelly Clarkson - If I Can't Have You
10. rl231 - P!nk - Heartbreaker
11. Vulnicura - Björk - One Day
12. thecptz - Jessie J - Seal Me With A Kiss
13. Speezy - Jordin Sparks - No Parade
Dylan's Rank:
P9:
1. thecptz - Jessie
2. Tom - Katy
3. Satan - Beyonce
4. prezli - Kylie
5. holyground - Taylor Swift
6. URBAN - Rihanna
7. rl231 - P!nk
I've been telling everyone for a year Seal Me With A Kiss should have been a single. It's a great track. Tom and Satan both picked choices that were obviously snubbed. I don't know how I Was Gonna Cancel was picked over Les Sex. I've always thought Wonderland could have been a cool single though it maybe wasn't a Top 10 smash at the same time. Loud was an album full of singles so Fading just doesn't stick out as something that was snubbed. The P!nk song doesn't sound commercial at all to me.
SMWAK and LL are smashes that got away. I consider the other 5 lacklusters especially TayTay and Pink. Sorry.
Brian's Rank:
P9:
1. holyground
2. Satan
3. Tom Vercetti
4. thecptz
5. rl231
6. URBAN
7. prezli
Wonderland is a great song! I don’t know how it wasn’t a single. End of Time too, I would have figured it was. As for Les Sex, I’m not really a fan of it and I think Kiss Me Once had better songs that should’ve been singles.
Element's Rank:
Part 9: Most Snubbed Single
1. Katy Perry
2. Kylie Minogue
3. Taylor Swift
4. Rihanna
5. P!nk
6. Jessie J
7. Beyoncé
Legendary Lovers has to be one of the greatest snubs of all time. Kylie/Taylor were really great songs. Rihanna was okay. As for P!nk/Jessie/Bey, I couldn't really see those three as singles. (Side note: Avril and Jordin -- great choices! I love those songs)
i cant even follow anymore.
P7: Worst Music Video
You still made it this round though.
