[Rihorse#1fan]

So there can only be 5 main pop girs just because you say it? Gurl what?

If you say that neither Rihanna or Gaga are main pop girls you're being delusional as f*ck

[DevonDreams]

Rihanna, but Gaga and Ariana are top 10 main pop girls

[M A R C]

Originally posted by robotdanger

If Rihanna is a main pop girl, how is Gaga not?

The ARTPOP era was more successful than ANTi by miles.

Metacritic score
ANTI - 73, ARTPOP - 61

Top 10s
ANTI - 3 (so far), ARTPOP - 1

#1s
ANTI - 1, ARTPOP - 0

Sales
ANTI - 2x plat (4 months) , ARTPOP - 2x plat

BB200
ANTI - Still in the top10 after 4 months, ARTPOP - in the top10 for a little amount of time

And ANTI tour is shaping up to do better than the ARTRAVE.

[Humunukuapua]

What next Timber, are you going to say that Selena Gomez is bigger than Rih?

[Sazare]

It's Rihanna, Adele, Beyoncé, Katy, and Gaga.

[robotdanger]

Screaming at the Navy trying to make it seem as though ANTi was some huge success.

She had one hit single, a Samsung check, and a couple good reviews. Chill.

[Baby Boy]

Right now it's Adele, Taylor, Beyonce, Katy & Rihanna.

[Rihorse#1fan]

Originally posted by Timber

All of these can go platinum in sales, but one can't even go gold in sales.

So you made this thread with the hope that everyone would say that ariana is a main pop girl and Rihanna and Gaga aren't

[Tom Vercetti]

Originally posted by robotdanger

Screaming at the Navy trying to make it seem as though ANTi was some huge success.

She had one hit single, a Samsung check, and a couple good reviews. Chill.

It wasn't a "Huge Flop" either like some try to convince themselves.

[Anticipating]

Originally posted by robotdanger

If Rihanna is a main pop girl, how is Gaga not?

The ARTPOP era was more successful than ANTi by miles.

Gaga hasn't had a successful album or a top 3 single in half a decade. No shade, but that doesn't scream main pop girl to me.

Rihanna just got a #1 single with ANTI

[Humunukuapua]

Originally posted by robotdanger

Screaming at the Navy trying to make it seem as though ANTi was some huge success.

She had one hit single, a Samsung check, and a couple good reviews. Chill.

What's Gaga got then? She only has one album with a better MC score.

[M A R C]

Originally posted by robotdanger

Screaming at the Navy trying to make it seem as though ANTi was some huge success.

She had one hit single, a Samsung check, and a couple good reviews. Chill.

Work? Needed Me? That's not only 1 hit.
And ANTI was reviewed by 31 critics, not a "couple".

[robotdanger]

Originally posted by Darren

ARTPOP was literally a victim of timing. It has actually sold better than Anti. It only was viewed as a failure because of comparison to other high profile Q4 releases. It's the same reason Rihanna was going to release Anti this past fall before she realized Adele would make her look like a failure.

Educate.

ARTPOP was only seen as a failure because it didn't slay like her other albums. And let's be honest, everyone wants to see Gaga fail. But that doesn't take away from the fact that it sold more than ANTi. Actual sales don't lie. 250k - 450.

[Mister Gaga]

Rihanna, Katy Perry, Lady Gaga, Beyonce and Taylor.

Adele is not a pop girl.

[Humunukuapua]

Originally posted by robotdanger

Educate.

ARTPOP was only seen as a failure because it didn't slay like her other albums. And let's be honest, everyone wants to see Gaga fail. But that doesn't take away from the fact that it sold more than ANTi. Actual sales don't lie. 250k - 450.

No, everybody does not want to see her fail. But it's her many delusional fans like yourself that make liking her music very difficult

[MakeMeOoh215]

Originally posted by Timber

I think there are 4 that are for sure: Beyoncé, Taylor, Adele, Katy. But the 5th is arguable.

Would it be Rihanna, Lady Gaga, or Ariana?

Beyonce is a legend and shouldn't be grouped with those girls TBH.

[MakeMeOoh215]

Originally posted by Rei

Adele is above that as well as Britney Spears. Beyoncé is also above that and is more r&b than pop.

Katy Perry
Taylor Swift
Rihanna
Selena Gomez
Ariana Grande

Pretty much!

[Serpentine]

Beyonce, 34 yo, mother of one, a pop girl

[HalcyonParadise]

Currently

Beyonce
Rihanna
Taylor
Gaga

and Katy.

I don't see Adele as a "pop girl".

[Darren]

Originally posted by M A R C

Metacritic score
ANTI - 73, ARTPOP - 61

Top 10s
ANTI - 3 (so far), ARTPOP - 1

#1s
ANTI - 1, ARTPOP - 0

Sales
ANTI - 2x plat (4 months) , ARTPOP - 2x plat

BB200
ANTI - Still in the top10 after 4 months, ARTPOP - in the top10 for a little amount of time

And ANTI tour is shaping up to do better than the ARTRAVE.

There are 2 top ten hits from the album Anti, same as ARTPOP.