| |
Tournament: (Resolution) How To Get Away With Murder: Case One
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 12,615
|
Wow XL, that looks really good! The accusations have my pulse racing. I wonder how Sexy will respond,
puhuhu
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
thanks for the clap guys
don't blame me if I picked the wrong culprit tho
if you like more evidence,
Dibbles asked
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
Sexy, were you with another player during the night and in what room?
|
Sexy replied
Quote:
Originally posted by Sexy
No, i just followed everyone to the study 
|
tymps says
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
Well idk what's going on I don't really understand. But my action last time was that I was in the library talking to Prismy. I didn't find out anything though.
Does anyone know who's mafia?
|
maybe after talking to prismy, he went back to his cabin while prismy left in the library.
jpow claims
Quote:
Originally posted by jpow
I sent a request to Satan to talk to ha in the library. She accepted, but then I forgot send a message  So I left through the lit library to the dim atrium and went to bed without anything happening.
|
so Sexy was actually with another player during the night phase but she denied it.
Sexy reacted to jpow
Quote:
Originally posted by Sexy
|
it means she's doomed. jpow spilled the tea
maybe after talking to Sexy, jpow went back to his cabin, leaving both Sexy and Prismy in the library. So it only means one thing....................
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
Quote:
Originally posted by 8thPrince
Wow XL, that looks really good! The accusations have my pulse racing. I wonder how Sexy will respond,
puhuhu
|
did I picked the right culprit?

|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 12,615
|
Clarifying: Remember that everyone is reset to their cabins at the end of the Night Phase, and remains where they were in the switch from Day to Night phase.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/15/2012
Posts: 22,487
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Xedretinz Lododnz
^In other words, self-inflicted?
here's my theory....
During the night phase, Tymps decided to have a short talk with Prismy in the library. After the short conversation, Tymps decided to went back on his cabin, leaving Prismy alone in the library. Maybe because of boredom, Primsy decided to read one of the books in the library. While Prismy was busy reading, jpow and Sexy went inside the library to have a short talk. Then, jpow decided to went back on his cabin to take some rest, leaving both Sexy and Prismy in the library.
In the other hand, Xedretinz Lododnz decided to go to the Infirmary. He checked things out there, the fridge specifically. He noticed that some things are not on its proper place the last time he went there during the day phase. Maybe someone took off something or moved something. It turns out that theycallmemaraj went there earlier and was the one who moved things in the fridge. There is no evidence that he went to the library after that.
Then, the crime takes place. Sexy, while Prismy without being conscious, decided to detach the extension cord of the lamp in the table which makes the place a bit dark. She decided to attack Prismy from behind while he was not aware and could not see anything in the dark. With Prismy being surprised, he accidentally dropped the book and tried to let go of the extension cord on his neck. Unfortunately, he failed and was killed. Sexy brought with her the extension cord then decided to put back the book in the shelf. She decided to put the body in the Study
During that time, swiftie13 decided to go to the Parlor to play the piano. After getting bored, he decided to go back to his room. While going back, he heard some noise in the atrium but didn’t check it. Dibbles went to the Parlor too maybe after swiftie13 leaves. She spends some time there. While roaming around the Parlor, she heard some dragging in the atrium, maybe some dragging going to the study. She decided not to check it due to fear for her life.
Sexy finally made it in the study along with her victim, Prismy. She decided to put Prismy’s body at the back of the chair so it will not be noticed easily. To make it more sure that no one will notice it easily, she decided to unlit the candle in the table which leads for the study to get darker.
From the Kitchen, Jackson decided to go to the library to check things. He noticed that the place is a bit dark. He noticed a lamp in the table but has no extension cords. Maybe he didn’t know that is has an extension cord since it’s his first time going there. The lamp produced no light which leads to the place being dark. After that, he went back in his cabin.
Sexy, realizing that the extension cord is still in her, decided to rush back in the library to put it back in the lamp. However, due to darkness, she accidentally bumped one of the bookshelves which lead to a book to fall down. She successfully put back the cord but failed to notice the book. Then she went back on her cabin.
While going back to his cabin from the infirmary, Xedretinz Lododnz hears some slight shuffling noise in the library. But he thinks it could be possibly nothing. It could be the book on the floor shuffling its pages due to air maybe.
It concludes that:
Victim: Prismatic
Cause of Death: Strangulation via Roped-like object
Murder Scenario: The Library
Victim’s Body found in: The Study
Method of Killing: Attack from Behind
Murder Weapon: Extension Cord of the Lamp
Killer: Sexy
but it could also be possible that Sexy went first in the infirmary to get some chloroform to use it in the crime...
watcha think? 
|
This doesn't add up
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/6/2015
Posts: 3,009
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
This doesn't add up
|
What doesn't add up, can you explain, so we don't point out the wrong culprit 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 22,126
|
......as if i'm smart enough to do all that
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 35,912
|
Satan wouldn't. She's a lazy ass bitch.
Now, what I wonder if why XL was the only person who heard shuffling. Did anyone else hear shuffling or did the rest of us either hear dragging or nothing at all like
I'm only bringing this up because I'm emphasising on what Monokuma said;
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Monokuma
And secondly: here's your last clue, before we start the trial: Your end of the Night Results are the biggest clue for this case. Wouldn't one person's be different from all the others....? You have to find out what was in everyone's night results to crack this.
|
No one else has heard shuffling from what we can tell. (I haven't really looked at what you guys have posted ayylmao)
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Wonderlust
Satan wouldn't. She's a lazy ass bitch.
Now, what I wonder if why XL was the only person who heard shuffling. Did anyone else hear shuffling or did the rest of us either hear dragging or nothing at all like
I'm only bringing this up because I'm emphasising on what Monokuma said;
No one else has heard shuffling from what we can tell. (I haven't really looked at what you guys have posted ayylmao)
|
cause the infirmary is near the library. So it's really possible that I will get pass through front of it when going back to my cabin. I can possibly hear something
Now, I'm a bit hesitating about the culprit tho 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/6/2011
Posts: 6,127
|
i like how this is titled How to get Away with Murder, but it's actually Dung Ropa or w/e that game is called.
8th prince is a deceitful ***. 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
hmmm. It think there's something really wrong about this
there are two statements that contradicts one another
and I'm not sure if it was Sexy's 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/7/2015
Posts: 6,930
|
I don't think it was Sexy.
According to Xed's theory there was someone in the library with Prismatic before Sexy...
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 15,127
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
hmmm. that was something!!! 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 12,615
|
24 hours remain of the trial. You may now begin voting here. Your last vote upon the conclusion of the period will be the one taken into account.
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
just check out the bold ones in the quotes.... the blue thingy are my comments about it.
Quote:
Originally posted by Wonderlust
He can't have been in the Lounge though because I was in the Lounge all night. I also heard noises coming from the Atrium then in the Study before I dismissed it and went back to sleep.
Which is why I believe Prismy was murdered in the Atrium and dragged into the Study.
|
it is indeed true
Quote:
Originally posted by 8thPrince
Puhuhu, the game's getting exciting now
I think I'm caught up on everyone's movements? Lemme know if I missed you.
Also, here's a clarification I'd like to make: unless you meet with someone during the night phase, you won't see anyone in the rooms during the Night phase. Imagine as if you're going to the same places, but hours apart.
|
a hint
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
During the day phase, I went to The Kitchen first and just looked around, asked about the menu and that's it, so -1AP. Then I went to The Infirmary where Satan/Sexy already was and I just looked around again, also -1AP. Then I went to The Library where Speezy, theycallmemaraj and Hugamari were looking at books and I just looked around, again -1AP. Finally I went to The Lounge where Wonderlust was and I passed Prismatic, who went to the Library, hung out and that was my last action point.
Night Phase, like I said, I went to The Parlor and just hung out, -1AP and still 3 left at the end of the night.
See I have nothing to hide  and if Prismatic never moved in the night, it also fits, because he was in the library the last time I saw him 
|
how did she know where will Prismy go after leaving the lounge? Prismy didn't mention he's going to the library at all.
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
I was in the parlor until I went to bed, that's how I could hear the dragging, I still had 3 action points in the end.
How about the rest, where were you all during the night?
|
she says she went to bed after wandering around the parlor
but....
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
This is a short summery of what we got when it comes to night results, just stating what people have said, not if it's the truth. Anyone noticing something or knows something more
Tymps. - Yes
jpow - Yes
Dibbles - Yes : The Parlor and stayed all night, heard dragging
theycallmemaraj - Yes: the infirmary, got chloroform; checks out with XL story
Sexy - Yes
Jackson - Yes: Kitchen and Library, pm correction checks out
Xedretinz Lododnz - Yes: the infirmary, checked fridge, heard shuffeling
swiftie13 - Yes: In the parlor, didn't hear anything until in the room
I don't think we'll get answers in time from the other three, so that won't help 
|
she claims that she STAYED ALL NIGHT in the parlor but it's impossible because....
Quote:
Originally posted by 8thPrince
Wait, even that might not have been clear. How can I say this in a non-spoilerific way?
Okay then:
Details in your night results depend on the area you were in when Night ended. THEN you return to your room automatically. Everyone's night results conclude with them returning to their room, that's not significant.
If you have any questions about that, feel free to ask.
|
and this
Quote:
Originally posted by 8thPrince
Clarifying: Remember that everyone is reset to their cabins at the end of the Night Phase, and remains where they were in the switch from Day to Night phase.
|
right?
and 8th gives us a clue like this
Quote:
Originally posted by 8thPrince
I hate to butt in, buuuuuut
Your narrowing of suspects is flawed: Never was it said that the culprits themselves can't investigate.
And secondly: here's your last clue, before we start the trial: Your end of the Night Results are the biggest clue for this case. Wouldn't one person's be different from all the others....? You have to find out what was in everyone's night results to crack this.
See ya in a few! puhuhu

|
she is clearly the one investigating so much other than me and you and wonderlust
here's another evidence
Quote:
Originally posted by swiftie13
I've been laying low in fear of my life. Here's my story:
I was in the parlor before the murder took place and noticed the piano. I played a little melody from The Legend of Zelda before calling it a night. I headed to my room and while in there, I heard dragging but I have a busy mind so I made nothing of it. I proceeded to sleep and stayed in my room throughout the night phase.
|
swiftie13 actually is telling the truth. he's the one in the parlor until the crime happens and dibbles was not in the parlor. It was just her alibi
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
Wait, why did you fear for your life after the crime, you couldn't get killed during that time and why did you tell me that you didn't hear anything, but you said in the thread you heard dragging.
|
how sure she is that swiftie13 will not get killed?
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
^this is exactly what I was thinking  The evidence adds up, especially if you look at everybody's night results. I think we maybe have our killer
Wait a minute 
|
she's so sure about my theory. It's like she wants us to believe that's actually what happened just to make her safe and not being targeted
here's our pm convo
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Xedretinz Lododnz
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Dibbles
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Xedretinz Lododnz
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Dibbles
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Xedretinz Lododnz
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Dibbles
Quote:
|
Originally posted by Xedretinz Lododnz
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
Sexy, were you with another player during the night and in what room?
|
Sexy replied
Quote:
Originally posted by Sexy
No, i just followed everyone to the study 
|
tymps says
Quote:
Originally posted by Tymps.
Well idk what's going on I don't really understand. But my action last time was that I was in the library talking to Prismy. I didn't find out anything though.
Does anyone know who's mafia?
|
maybe after talking to prismy, he went back to his cabin while prismy left in the library.
jpow claims
Quote:
Originally posted by jpow
I sent a request to Satan to talk to ha in the library. She accepted, but then I forgot send a message  So I left through the lit library to the dim atrium and went to bed without anything happening.
|
so Sexy was actually with another player during the night phase but she denied it.
Sexy reacted to jpow
Quote:
Originally posted by Sexy
|
it means she's doomed
maybe after talking to Sexy, jpow went back to his cabin, leaving both Sexy and Prismy in the library. So it only means one thing....................
watcha think? 
|
Can we communicate like this
But I think you're right. I asked that question, because I got a reply through pm from jpow, saying he talked to Sexy. So I was confused why Sexy answered this way. There were 4 people in the library, and jpow and Tymps. seem to be okay and Prismatic was killed, so it does seem like Sexy is the killer
But have we ruled out swiftie13 already, because he was also lying about why he didn't he return to the study after the crime and said different things about what he heard.
I think Sexy being the killer sounds like the best scenario 
|
yeah, sure
I think she really is the killer. I noticed Sexy's comments in the thread doesn't really make sense. Maybe she was afraid to speak cause she might reveal anything about the crime
In swiftie's case, maybe he just misinterpret the PM. Everyone went back on their cabins automatically and he claims he went back by himself.
|
Aha I see. So it was Sexy in the Library killed Prismatic after jpow and Tymps left. And dragged the body through the atrium and in the study. Was the murder weapon the extension chords from the lamps in the library, cause I got kinda confused at that point  If so we know how the murder went and most importantly we know the killer 
|
At this point, the extension cord is the only weapon we can think of. I checked the library after the crime and chekced the cord. It says that there is no way to know if it was taken out of the library.
I think it doesn't need to be taken out the library cause it can be used inside the library and can be easily put back its location after the crime.
btw, I'm starting to make my theory now. I'll show you later when I'm done. 
|
That's what I thought, but got confused by the "they haven't been removed" but apparently that means outside the room  So it works! Looking forward to your theory  I wish I could make one, but I'm babysitting and on mobile and since we have the same ideas kind of unnecessary 
|
lol, wait I actually think the cord was taken out the library after all but was put back after the crime 
|
Even better if she reacts, most of the time would the killer make mistakes at that point. And we need the majority for the votes, so everybody needs to see this theory and agree with it  I mean it's a solid theory, so I can't see anything going wrong with posting this as soon as possible. Hopefully it works to convince the others and we're good
first one in bold: she wants us to communicate via pm to avoid further accusations about her in the thread. If I post anything in the thread, someone might spill tea about her being the killer
2nd one in bold: she really wants me to get convinced that swiftie13 is lying about the parlor thingy cause her alibi is contradicting with swiftie13.
3rd: she has no idea if the cords were actually used. so it's actually not used at all.
4th: she claims that the cords we're not removed so maybe she was nervous for us to know that the murder weapon is not actually the cords.
5th: she really wants us to get convinced by the wrong theory
All those investigation of hers we're all lies. She tried to trick us, but in the end she actually did it.... Yeah I'm talking about a specific person
Conclusion:
Victim: Prismatic
Place Attacked: The Library
Place Killed: The Atrium
Place Body Found: The Study
Killer: Dibbles
Murder Weapon: Rope
While Prismy was being attacked in the library, maybe he tried to let go and accidentally bumped one of the bookshelves and lead to a book to fall to the ground
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 22,126
|
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/6/2015
Posts: 3,009
|
I wake up from a wedding and this is the betrayal I get 
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 1/4/2014
Posts: 24,453
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Dibbles
I wake up from a wedding and this is the betrayal I get 
|
Sorry bae but it's the only possible thing that could happen
I don't like to do this but this is how this game works 
|
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 1/1/2014
Posts: 30,842
|
Y'all hoes still talking about me even when I'm dead. The impact and legacy. 
|
|
|
|
|
|