[Rylary]

Originally posted by Sasha.

SH is not worse than PO

PO is pretty tragic!

[Tylerbv]

ff jeremy can't play anymore with that tragic blown away ranking

[Rylary]

her backup singer is absolutely horrible

[Tylerbv]

I don't know why she even needs a backup singer anyways. I'd prefer just her.

[Rylary]

some songs yes, such as heartbeat. It sounds bad when she sings it alone like the target version, it just needs a backup.

but most of the time she sings on her own like Something In The Water.

[Rylary]

what happened to the stans?

[Mezik]

I'm in Ottawa on trip.

Next time I come here it'll be to see Carrie.

[gagacasanova]

Originally posted by Rylary

what happened to the stans?

In hell for not letting Smoke Break and Heartbeat hit the top 40.

[Tylerbv]

Chaser is still so good.

BB made a list of the top 100 AI performances of all time.
24. Independence Day
6. Alone (should be higher )

#1 is Fantasia.

[Pirate Aaron]

Originally posted by Tylerbv

Chaser is still so good.

BB made a list of the top 100 AI performances of all time.
24. Independence Day
6. Alone (should be higher )

#1 is Fantasia.

Carrie's AI run wasn't that good

I'd probably bump Alone down since I can think of better performances; every performance above it was actually better.

If you want to know what the overall consensus was from the GP of her performances, you can check this link out.
http://whatnottosing.com/contestants...4#.Vu-Wy5KixX8

[Tylerbv]

She was still better than some of the garbage above her. Summertime is horrible. So many great performances were in the bottom half of the list

I would've probably put Alone #2 or #3 and Independence Day top 20 at least.

[Rylary]

The mess at fantasia being #1. I need to see this list.

[Pirate Aaron]

Originally posted by Tylerbv

She was still better than some of the garbage above her. Summertime is horrible. So many great performances were in the bottom half of the list

I would've probably put Alone #2 or #3 and Independence Day top 20 at least.

You just hate Fantasia, so

All of the performances in the top 10 were really good, but then they put Phillip Phillip's Home performance at #11, wtf.

I would honestly put Bo Bice's In A Dream above Alone. That performance still remains the only full on a capella performance on idol.

[Tylerbv]

Originally posted by Pirate Aaron

You just hate Fantasia, so

All of the performances in the top 10 were really good, but then they put Phillip Phillip's Home performance at #11, wtf.

I would honestly put Bo Bice's In A Dream above Alone. That performance still remains the only full on a capella performance on idol.

True. She's whiny and has a horrible tone. I still would've put the performance on the top 100 list, but probably in the 50s or 60s.

In a Dream is top 10 material. For top 10, I'd have something like (no order)
Alone
Bo Bice - In a Dream
Kelly Clarkson - Stuff Like That There
Jennifer Hudson - Circle of Life
Diana DeGarmo - Don't Cry Out Loud
Allison Iraheta - Someone to Watch Over Me
David Archuleta - Imagine
Chris Daughtry - Hemorrhage (or however it's spelled)
Clay Aiken - Bridge Over Troubled Water
David Cook - Billie Jean

I think I'm missing some good ones, but these are all >>> most of the top 10 they had.

[Mezik]

fantasia burrito was awful, i cried when diana lost to her

[gagacasanova]

[Mezik]

Originally posted by gagacasanova

Omg, Isaiah is so precious.

[Rylary]

real tears. Dianna was amazing and she was robbed

[Nightingale]

I didn't realize Isaiah was so big already!

[Sasha.]

Originally posted by gagacasanova

what a beautiful family