[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by Lukitoo

Yeah they really destroyed our faves with their #4, #19 and #30 peaking singles If it wasn't for their fanbase that buys albums they would've dropped from their top-tier spot in 2015.

oooooh the 2Min song is so cute, I loved it

Except they were the bestselling in digitals, physicals AND touring of 2015.
Get better receipts next time.

[Xalric]

Happyface ent. (Dal Shabet company)



A Tragedy

[Lukitoo]

Originally posted by Comedor

http://www.soompi.com/2015/12/22/gir...p-girl-groups/

For a veteran you should be more informed.

GaOn counted solos/sub-units towards the group. They had 4 singles, Taeyeon's solo (THAT one was the real smash), Taetiseo's Christmas album and Tiffany's OST.

SNSD are definitely getting weaker. Taeyeon's solo was far bigger than any of the 4 songs they released MVs last year. Taeyeon's album sold about 2.3 million downloads with only 1 single released. SNSD had 4 promotional songs, 2 eras and were outsold by her.

But if you think the group is still "Unbreakable Wall" with the best selling non-title from Party selling 84k and from Lion Heart selling 28k while Taeyeon's U R did 450K, who am I to judge.

[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by BlackAura

It's not worth it, sis.

If the posters/photobook music is good, it's definitely worth it.

[sunny phoenix]

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

Except they were the bestselling in digitals, physicals AND touringof 2015.
Get better receipts next time.

u know they released 4 singles right?

[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by Lukitoo

GaOn counted solos/sub-units towards the group. They had 4 singles, Taeyeon's solo (THAT one was the real smash), Taetiseo's Christmas album and Tiffany's OST.

SNSD are definitely getting weaker. Taeyeon's solo was far bigger than any of the 4 songs they released MVs last year. Taeyeon's album sold about 2.3 million downloads with only 1 single released. SNSD had 4 promotional songs, 2 eras and were outsold by her.

But if you think the group is still "Unbreakable Wall" with the best selling non-title from Party selling 84k and from Lion Heart selling 28k while Taeyeon's U R did 450K, who am I to judge.

Not you using the first week sales for Longevity Heart to justify your inaccuracies

[Exzime.]

Originally posted by Sorbet

EXO-L have to do better than this

xiumin fans in exo-l only accounts for 1.25% of the whole fanbase.

[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by sunny phoenix

u know they released 4 singles right?

CMIYC/You Think were outsold by album tracks/not promoted, so they'd still be #1 even if they only released 2 singles.

[sunny phoenix]

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

CMIYC/You Think were outsold by album tracks/not promoted, so they'd still be #1 even if they only released 2 singles.

still 2 singles is double than what the other GG release...

[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by sunny phoenix

still 2 singles is double than what the other GG release...

Or quadrupled, if you're using Miss A

[Xalric]

Check and TTS' Bump It (ft. SNSD) should have been the songs promoted (singles).

But that tragic ass choreo for Bump It tho

[Lukitoo]

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

Not you using the first week sales for Longevity Heart to justify your inaccuracies

28k are the sales for "Green Light" while it charted in the top 100 because it was the best selling album track.

I compared the total sales. Taeyeon's mini outsold everything SNSD released last year COMBINED. You should train your text interpretation.

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

CMIYC/You Think were outsold by album tracks/not promoted, so they'd still be #1 even if they only released 2 singles.

They didn't. The best-selling track from them was Check (during the PARTY release) with 84k. Both CMIYC and You Think sold a little over 100k

[Hitori]

Sohye shut down Pinky and that DIA girl in Full Moon! She used her actress-side well!

[sunny phoenix]

Originally posted by BlazingLovatic

Or quadrupled, if you're using Miss A

but i thought u said that CMIYC and YT dont really count

and i am using the GG releases of 2015... Miss A, sistar, AOA, Mamamoo all the GG that topped the digital of 2015 released only 1 single... if these groups had a second single then ....

[Jack!]

The Jimin song wanted to make me rip off my ears.

[Lukitoo]

Originally posted by sunny phoenix

but i thought u said that CMIYC and YT dont really count

and i am using the gg releases of 2015... Miss A, sistar, AOA, Mamamoo all the GG that topped the digital of 2015 released only 1 single...

They are only #1 because of Taeyeon's solo. EXID would easily overtake them without I's sales, even if you count all of the 4 singles+album tracks sales

[BlackAura]

Pinky is not even the best Pledis girl, it's Im Nayoung. Pinky and Dani should leave the top 11.

[sunny phoenix]

Originally posted by Lukitoo

They are only #1 because of Taeyeon's solo. EXID would easily overtake them without I's sales, even if you count all of the 4 singles+album tracks sales

gdfgdf

Taeyeon's solo count as SNSD ??

****ing bye what are we even discussing here then...

[BlazingLovatic]

Originally posted by Lukitoo

28k are the sales for "Green Light" while it charted in the top 100 because it was the best selling album track.

I compared the total sales. Taeyeon's mini outsold everything SNSD released last year COMBINED. You should train your text interpretation.



They didn't. The best-selling track from them was Check (during the PARTY release) with 84k. Both CMIYC and You Think sold a little over 100k

I was talking about album tracks in general.
Not Lion Heart songs

[Xalric]

Originally posted by sunny phoenix

gdfgdf

Taeyeon's solo count as SNSD ??

****ing bye what are we even discussing here then...

A reverse Destiny's Child counted as Beyonce experience.