[Reb'l Rêveur]

BIRTHDAY was released as the 4th single from PRISM. It peaked at #17 on Hot 100. It is a RIAA platinum certified.

OUT OF THE WOODS was released as a promo single first then eventually as a 6th single off 1989. It peaked at #18 on Hot 100. Currently, it is a certified Gold by RIAA.

[OpenBacardi]

Idk but Birthday is the superior song

[G.U.Y.]

Birthday.

It wasn't more successful because of Dark Horse's shadow; OOTW doesn't have an excuse.

[SadGirl]

OOTW is much better but Birthday felt bigger

[Sazare]

The critically hailed Top 17 smash

[halcyonday]

OOTW is better, but Birthday was bigger.

[WalkingOnCharts]

Birthday

[Delilah.]

Birthday

If she made a decent video it would have smashed.

[liberalmusiclover]

Birthday. Better song, better video. Out of the Woods is horrible.

[WeFoundTrouble]

Birthday bigger.

OOTW better,

[Reb'l Rêveur]

Originally posted by liberalmusiclover

Birthday. Better song, better video. Out of the Woods is horrible.

Are you talking about the lyrics video or the official one? But still,

[WEEKND]

Originally posted by G.U.Y.

Birthday.

It wasn't more successful because of Dark Horse's shadow; OOTW doesn't have an excuse.

OOTW is from an album that is already 5X platinum though.

Not everybody has that

[NEUTRON]

Birthday

[MexicanLiLMonster]

Birthday only because it was a solid Top 20 hit, where it spent some weeks within the Top 20.

OOTW only got Top 20 in its debut.

[Rei]

Birthday is RIAA platinum certified though.

[Kayzan]

Originally posted by WeFoundTrouble

Birthday bigger.

OOTW better,

.

[2014]

OOTW.

it hasn't yet finished it's run and it could still outsell Birthday when it's all said and done.

[Music=Epicness]

OOTW may have peaked at 18 when it was initially released, but it is currently struggling at No. 51 rn during its single run (down from last week) and has peaked at 44 since its release. OOTW is a flop not a moderate hit

EDIT: my point is birthday because it actually performed decently for a single.

[liberalmusiclover]

Originally posted by Reb'l Rêveur

Are you talking about the lyrics video or the official one? But still,

Both are better than Out of the Woods' video.

[Reb'l Rêveur]

Originally posted by 2014

OOTW.

it hasn't yet finished it's run and it could still outsell Birthday when it's all said and done.

Is it not done yet?