[duybeeGAshantiGA]

GaGa can totally do that last note on Bey's version. It's just that she doesn't want to repeat. It's not even that hard tbh

[Temporal]

Bey, though both were great. I liked Bey's arrangement more (as well as her vocal placement).

[Nemo]

I love both so much GaGa's by a small margin

[BTrisc]

Gaga, though Bey's arrangement is amazing. She's not really expressing much emotion, but the result of using a pre-recorded track.

[SHICD]

Gaga is the clear winner here.

[Ascension]

Bey's sounded miles better; I didn't care for the awkward arrangement of Gaga's at the end.

[ToxDuris]

Gaga by far.

[BTrisc]

Originally posted by Jet

Bey's was a lot more impressive considering it was sung in a much higher key with runs, vibrato and and power. Gaga's was low and very generic.



Not in this universe.

The argument that a higher voice equates to better quality is so so wrong.

And generic? Not when the "stand there and melisma your heart out
against a pre-recorded instrumental" schtick has been done umpteen times.

[Ravindra]

Gaga, the classical-esque placement worked well for this type of event.

[Phil]

Gaga's voice is a lot stronger
Beyoncé sounds so weak like her voice is about to fail at any moment

[Mattyboy]

Gaga

[Bey_Rihstan]

Beyonce easily

Gaga sounded a mess.

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

Beyonce easily

Gaga sounded a mess.

America + ATRL disagree.

[SpinThatShhh]

Gaga easily wins.

Beyoncé's was good, but not note-worthy.

[Mezter]

Beyonce

Originally posted by Chivas

No, sweetheart. Gaga is more talented than Bey in every possible way.

Bye

[Baby Boy]

Bey.

[Hurem]

Gaga.

[idkher]

Beyonce's was better. Lady gaga sung in like 3 different voices it was kind of bizarre

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by Mariano

America + ATRL disagree.

Bey_Rihstan doesn't give 2 ****s what America or ATRL disagrees on, as this is her own, personal opinion. Thanks.

[Bmezy]

Originally posted by duybeeGAshantiGA

GaGa can totally do that last note on Bey's version. It's just that she doesn't want to repeat. It's not even that hard tbh

Lies. Have you even heard Gaga belt a D5 before..she's never hit a note this resonant in her entire career ..This is a fact and isn't subjected to your bias for Gaga.. You probably cannot even fathom what Beyoncé did there,can you .. She sustained a 12 second word over the course of 4 notes up the staff with perfect intonation and support withou taking a SINGLE breath.. This is the vocal capacity that Gaga will never reach..

"Gags can totally do that.." -not even in in her dreams.. And you fronting saying this like you actually know what you're talking about..The transparency is real.