[PrinceGaga]

Why should this even be questioned? Ofcourse Gaga has input I mean dd

[Buyonce1814]

The Hive stays saying that but y'all keep dragging them for it but now it's Gaga.... But yes - I agree.

[retromaury]

Sure jan

[inspiration4]

Originally posted by Buyonce1814

The Hive stays saying that but y'all keep dragging them for it but now it's Gaga.... But yes - I agree.

Hasn't Beyonce has had demo's leak in which nothing was changed from the final version? I'm pretty sure I recall that happening during the I AM era...

Was it Smash Into You?

[Titan]

Even if she did only re-write one line it's still a songwriting contribution by definition

[BabyCantYouSee]

Originally posted by Buyonce1814

The Hive stays saying that but y'all keep dragging them for it but now it's Gaga.... But yes - I agree.

That's because songwriters who are involved in making Beyonce's songs claim she steals credits.



This is off-topic, though.

[dirrtydiana]

Originally posted by BabyCantYouSee

Coming up with the melody of a song isn't a minor contribution.

Gaga is notorious for taking something that has already been created and promote it as her own, e.i. BTW (song) and Artpop (taken from Andy Warhol's "PopArt.")

Originally posted by wesleywalrus

not when the main songwriter herself has admitted Gaga's help in interviews

Helping. She changed the melody so what she did falls under composing more so than writing which is why Linda is right.

[Titan]

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

Gaga is notorious for taking something that has already been created and promote it as her own, BTW and AP.



Helping. She changed the melody so what she did falls under composing more so than writing which is why Linda is right.

I can't at you all taking this as 100% fact with no proof or evidence what so ever

[inspiration4]

Originally posted by BabyCantYouSee

That's because songwriters who are involved in making Beyonce's songs claim she steals credits.



This is off-topic, though.

Burn

[CakeLike]

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

Helping. She changed the melody so what she did falls under composing more so than writing which is why Linda is right.

Generally speaking, any significant contribution to melody, lyrics, or structure typically counts as songwriting


You might wanna check your facts because it look like the lawyers dont agree with you

[dirrtydiana]

Originally posted by Titan

I can't at you all taking this as 100% fact with no proof or evidence what so ever

Same can be said for people supporting Gaga.

Originally posted by CakeLike

Generally speaking, any significant contribution to melody, lyrics, or structure typically counts as songwriting


You might wanna check your facts because it look like the lawyers dont agree with you

Or you might wanna revaluate your ethics and draw a line on where you think "contributing" becomes flat out stealing.
The song was already there, written. Gaga just came in and decided to sing it another way cos she couldnt sing it or she felt inspired by something that was already there, like her last two eras.

[careerfatality]

Originally posted by BabyCantYouSee

That's because songwriters who are involved in making Beyonce's songs claim she steals credits.



This is off-topic, though.

oh lord

[CakeLike]

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

Or you might wanna revaluate your ethics and draw a line on where you think "contributing" becomes flat out stealing.

Who did she steal the melodies/structure and production from? Her own brain?

[Titan]

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

Same can be said for people supporting Gaga.



Or you might wanna revaluate your ethics and draw a line on where you think "contributing" becomes flat out stealing.

The person as a witness to the studio time spent together writing this song says Gaga did co write? Who is more reliable? Someone that was with her writing or someone that wasn'T?

[Mariano]

Originally posted by Buyonce1814

The Hive stays saying that but y'all keep dragging them for it but now it's Gaga.... But yes - I agree.

1. Monsters never really drag Bey for writing credits

2. Lady Gaga is KNOWN for writing all her songs, melodies and lyrics.

3. Gaga already SAID several times in interviews that Diane went to her with THE SONG (which in itself means that Diane had written something before even contacting Gaga).

[Yanko]

Originally posted by BabyCantYouSee

That's because songwriters who are involved in making Beyonce's songs claim she steals credits.



This is off-topic, though.

[careerfatality]

i wonder why she said stuff like that. hmm

3. The good news: Lady Gaga earned her first Oscar nomination for "Til It Happens To You." The less-ideal news: Fellow pop-star-with-pipes Miley Cyrus failed to garner a nomination for her tune-with-a-message, "Hands of Love" from Freeheld.

oh thats probably why. now shes under the sheets crying and eating nutella while going on a rant on twitter. how transparent

[Romantica]

Originally posted by Yanko

linda is just bitter her song didnt get nominated
that is all

.

[♚ PRiNCE HiGH ♚]

Originally posted by dirrtydiana

Same can be said for people supporting Gaga.



Or you might wanna revaluate your ethics and draw a line on where you think "contributing" becomes flat out stealing.
The song was already there, written. Gaga just came in and decided to sing it another way cos she couldnt sing it or she felt inspired by something that was already there, like her last two eras.

Stealing? Oh for ****s sake

Gaga composed the song. She produced the song and had (a minor) hand in writing the song.
She DESERVES the nomination

[Green]

Originally posted by Buyonce1814

The Hive stays saying that but y'all keep dragging them for it but now it's Gaga.... But yes - I agree.

!!!

Beyoncé is dragged for the same and she didn't get a nomination for Listen even when she was listed as one of the songwriters. The bias