You're right. It's a laughable comparison. The winner is obviously the one with a #1 hit and nominations in the Grammy general field (that don't come from featuring on someone else's album).
No she's megasuccessful and relevant. Poor Carly on Fox Broadway Jepsen!
Outsold by Meghan Trainor, Little Mix, Florence and The Machine despite being a replica of Britney, one of the most successful pop stars ever. Unable to get 10 people to review her trash. Yikes.