[Brunette Ambition]

Originally posted by Nutitle

Uhmm... I just finished Freakshow and...



WTF? I loved it, I was expecting a MESS but NO

Freakshow >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> TRASH >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> COVEN



Also, Emma's acting wasn't that bad
And Dandy had so much potential

+ Kii @ Elsa crying for Ethel
"WHY WHY WHY?!" nnnnn

preach the tea

anywho, them acknowledging that characters from different seasons look the same would be the final nail in the coffin after the messy connections.
if sally and billie acknowledge each other for looking the same it would make no sense that queenie didn't think iris was delphine with a new job or that marie now suffers from acne.

[Lord Gaga]

Sorry but for me it's

Asylum > Murder House > Hotel > Coven > Freak Show

People do too much on Coven and it's slayful characters. Too bad the story was messy. Freak show started off strongly but was never all that interesting. Interested to see what's going to happen in season 6.

[conseeded]

Coven was so good until the last 2 episodes. It really needed an episode or two more

I need to watch Freak Show after Hotel ends. The only scene I've watched is Maggie's death scene (hihihihihi)

[Dylangaga]

Am I the only one who wanted Cordelia and Fiona to duke it out in the last episode? I liked that scene but I expected someone to attack the other if that makes sense

[Nutitle]

Maggie's death was so pathetic and pointless

[conseeded]

Originally posted by Nutitle

Maggie's death was so pathetic and pointless

it was Emma's fault for snatching up Taissa's role

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

It's one thing to play one character that appears in different seasons

And it's one thing to have one actor play two characters

But to have one actress play two characters that INTERACT TOGETHER and aren't canonically twins...

Ryan is just taking the piss out of us. I swear.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Originally posted by Nutitle

Freakshow >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> TRASH >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> COVEN

False

Also, Emma's acting wasn't that bad

False

Asylum >>> Murder House >> Hotel > Freakshow >>>>>>>> Coven

False

[Gee]

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

It's one thing to play one character that appears in different seasons

And it's one thing to have one actor play two characters

But to have one actress play two characters that INTERACT TOGETHER and aren't canonically twins...

Ryan is just taking the piss out of us. I swear.

I agree to an extent.

I'm all for suspension of disbelief but if he makes them interact I don't know how i'm going to feel.

Especially if they don't acknowledge that they look identical. Watch him try to connect all the seasons tonight.

Woo lord.

[ahauntingnearu]

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

It's one thing to play one character that appears in different seasons

And it's one thing to have one actor play two characters

But to have one actress play two characters that INTERACT TOGETHER and aren't canonically twins...

Ryan is just taking the piss out of us. I swear.

agreed. but ya know, whatever

i think Coven and FS are very underrated. yes, MH and A are obvs better than them and FS is the worst of the four, but i really don't think they're bad--especially Coven. if coven hadn't made a couple slip ups, imo, it could've been the most thought-provoking and interesting/entertaining season. asylum really set the bar so high
also, i genuinely don't believe Hotel is significantly better than FS. i want to see the finale and then rewatch hotel a second time before i give my definitive ranking though

[Brunette Ambition]

i liked maggies death in freak show. i love gruesome deaths.
but i would have prefered it if he saw the twins in half.

and i would have prefered it if fiona killed all the witches in the finale.

[Gee]

Originally posted by Nutitle

Uhmm... I just finished Freakshow and...



WTF? I loved it, I was expecting a MESS but NO

Freakshow >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> TRASH >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> COVEN



Also, Emma's acting wasn't that bad
And Dandy had so much potential

+ Kii @ Elsa crying for Ethel
"WHY WHY WHY?!" nnnnn

__________________

Asylum >>> Murder House >> Hotel > Freakshow >>>>>>>> Coven

And y'all will have to deal with the true tea

Seek medical attention.

[Brunette Ambition]

Originally posted by Gee

I agree to an extent.

I'm all for suspension of disbelief but if he makes them interact I don't know how i'm going to feel.

Especially if they don't acknowledge that they look identical. Watch him try to connect all the seasons tonight.

Woo lord.

why?
i'd rather have them interact and not acknowledge that they look identical than them interacting and them acknowleding that they look the same because then it wouldn't make sense that queenie didn't react proper when she saw iris who looks like delphine or ramona who looks like marie.

[Vertigo Stick]

Asylum would have been even more chilling if Lana died in the end. I was on the edge of my seat and would have been pissed if that were the outcome, but it would have been the good kind of reaction. The thought of talent not winning is very scary! I am more than okay with the outcome we got, just saying this would have broken my heart!

[Haus]

I was against the idea of connecting each season at first, but considering Sally's character and how Sarah is generally amazing, I'm HOPING that Sally and Billie Dean interact

[Brunette Ambition]

Originally posted by Vertigo Stick

Asylum would have been even more chilling if Lana died in the end. I was on the edge of my seat and would have been pissed if that were the outcome, but it would have been the good kind of reaction. The thought of talent not winning is very scary! I am more than okay with the outcome we got, just saying this would have broken my heart!

i think the finale is perfect the way it is.
especially the flashback to her and sister jude on the first day of meeting.
it makes you question if lana was really the nice lady in the end.

[Teneo]

Originally posted by Vertigo Stick

Asylum would have been even more chilling if Lana died in the end. I was on the edge of my seat and would have been pissed if that were the outcome, but it would have been the good kind of reaction. The thought of talent not winning is very scary! I am more than okay with the outcome we got, just saying this would have broken my heart!

Why did I think this was some type of shade, I had to re-read the post two times

[Gee]

Originally posted by Brunette Ambition

why?
i'd rather have them interact and not acknowledge that they look identical than them interacting and them acknowleding that they look the same because then it wouldn't make sense that queenie didn't react proper when she saw iris who looks like delphine or ramona who looks like marie.

It comes back to Ryan saying all the seasons are connected.

I feel like Billie being a psychic/medium would play a huge role in actually linking everything together. It would be a nice tip of the hat to have her acknowledge how weird it is(but probably come off completely comedic).

I still have no idea what the actual purpose of bring her back... so my opinion could completely change if the writers pull something good out of their ass.

[Dylangaga]

This is QUEEN SARAH PAULSON we're talking about sistren, she will NAIL IT! And we all have doppelgangers

[Opacho]

Originally posted by Teneo

GABOUREY