[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by Donquizote

60s range is still unfavorable for most people unless you're content with the album being in 60s range

I wouldn't be so sure about that.



http://www.metacritic.com/about-metascores

So, what gives?

Has she gained respect or did she never truly lose it in the first place?

I'm conflicted and this is keeping me up, worrying frantically!

[Sirnight]

Originally posted by Can't_M!ss_This

Ugh. You do realize the **** Gaga gets is mostly in retaliation of what you fans do right? Mow your damn lawn and sit the hell down.


She won a golden globe. Easily the most sketchy of the major awards. I'll reserve judgement until an Emmy comes

I didn't known people were dumb enough to judge an artist based on how their fanbase behave. That's a new low.

[Ethereaaal]

Originally posted by Donquizote

60s range is still unfavorable for most people unless you're content with the album being in 60s range

Poor the many others in pop with 60s as their highest I guess. For pop music, it's normal.

[that G.U.Y.]

Yes she is globally respected by all people

[Tymps.]

@ everyone who opens up another one of these threads: chill

[paulyyyozd]

When it comes to her haters, obviously not.

When it comes to her fans, she already has their respect.

The rest is just like "wtf, golden globe for gaga? k I guess"

So, um, no.

[AMENHOOKER]

Remember when Lady Gaga was vomited on and this happened?



March 2014: http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=537556

I guess we can all finally come to the conclusion that she has maintained a certain level of respect, even at the lowest moment in her career.

Thank you all for your participation.

[Donquizote]

Originally posted by Ethereaaal

Poor the many others in pop with 60s as their highest I guess. For pop music, it's normal.

Originally posted by AMENHOOKER

I wouldn't be so sure about that.



http://www.metacritic.com/about-metascores

So, what gives?

Has she gained respect or did she never truly lose it in the first place?

I'm conflicted and this is keeping me up, worrying frantically!

Slay I guess

[Nutitle]

Yes!
She's not like... SUPER respected but yes

[americanshameless]

No, judging by the reactions in the room last night.

But I'd say yes, slightly since she now has a GG. But as a celebrity, she's still that "Lady Gaga" who will just be remembered for wearing the meat dress as events of that nature were a lot bigger for her than a 5-minute GG win which isn't as highly regarded as the Oscars, Emmys etc anyway. She was never taken that seriously, honestly.

[vuelve88]

YE$

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by americanshameless

No, judging by the reactions in the room last night.

But I'd say yes, slightly since she now has a GG ... a 5-minute GG win which isn't as highly regarded as the Oscars, Emmys etc anyway. She was never taken that seriously, honestly.

So, according to your logic, if you haven't won an Oscar and/or an Emmy, you're NOT respected? Got it! Thanks.

P.S. I cut out the irrelevant information. Gaga won 3 Grammys about 6 months after she wore the meat dress (to an event from which she went home with 7 awards, including VOTY), so it's certainly nothing to be ashamed of.

[Nutitle]

Originally posted by MM3

I believe more people know of her talents now than in 2009. Hopefully her jazz album later this year will continue to make people realize how talented she is.

OMG MaRy teas

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by Nutitle

OMG MaRy teas

[manwhore]

all the above

[wesleywalrus]

How is someone with three album with 70+ MC scores and 6 GRAMMYs not respected? Chill out OP, we all know she is.

[Jan]

The poll though

[americanshameless]

Originally posted by AMENHOOKER

So, according to your logic, if you haven't won an Oscar and/or an Emmy, you're NOT respected? Got it! Thanks.

P.S. I cut out the irrelevant information. Gaga won 3 Grammys about 6 months after she wore the meat dress (to an event from which she went home with 7 awards, including VOTY), so it's certainly nothing to be ashamed of.

The GGs are what say EMAs are for the movie industry. It's not that serious Her Grammy wins are to be celebrated yes, they are great achievements but some musicians that are seen as "jokes" have multiple Grammys and some of the biggest musical legends of our time have similar to or less amounts of Grammys than Gaga does. It doesn't end there, love. She is favourable to the GP but hardly seen as somebody who is as greatly respected and as raved about as the Monsters here are making it out to be. And the OP is a perfect example of delusion, well done.

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by wesleywalrus

How is someone with three album with 70+ MC scores and 6 GRAMMYs not respected? Chill out OP, we all know she is.

I'm perfectly calm. Don't worry about it.

Originally posted by americanshameless

The GGs are what say EMAs are for the movie industry. It's not that serious Her Grammy wins are to be celebrated yes, they are great achievements but some musicians that are seen as "jokes" have multiple Grammys and some of the biggest musical legends of our time have similar to or less amounts of Grammys than Gaga does. It doesn't end there, love. She is favourable to the GP but hardly seen as somebody who is as greatly respected and as raved about as the Monsters here are making it out to be. And the OP is a perfect example of delusion, well done.

Awards aside, can you propose another more valuable, more valid, more reliable unit of measurement? How does one determine who the GP respects and who they don't? There's nothing inherently delusional about the OP. I'm merely asking if what ATRL users had told us in 2014 has changed. Has it?

[Jorq]

would Britney stan, americanshameless lie?