[Blue Jeans]

Please post a video clip
I'm not trying to be shady, this is for research

[americanshameless]

Go ask in ha base.

Answer:

[Bey_Rihstan]

George bush was president if I recall

[cOe]

Inb4 Mickey Mouse Club

[Itskorbitch]

prob legit circus tour. you ought to know. had to be live.

[Marvin]

1995

[cancer]

In a concert? IDK.
But she sang happy birthday on the X Factor once which was the closest we've been to hearing her sing live this decade

[Itskorbitch]

[Beyoncé-Knowles]

Not in this lifetime anyway.

[Domination]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TwWDlz7O8s

[cancer]

Originally posted by Itskorbitch

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DdRKmTb82nQ

Embedded it for you

[Repo]

Having been to Vegas, she performs a handful of songs live. I think the last live one is Lucky, but I know Work Bitch was too. And Everytime (which is always live)

[cancer]

Originally posted by Domination

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-TwWDlz7O8s

You're not funny.

[Eternium]

You Oughtta Know in 2009. Mess at someone thinking Bush was President in late 2009

[ZeroSuitBritney]

You Oughta Know

[heartbeats]

this was definitely live she just sang with a different vocal

[qurl]

Originally posted by Repo

Having been to Vegas, she performs a handful of songs live. I think the last live one is Lucky, but I know Work Bitch was too. And Everytime (which is always live)

lipping to a prerecorded track =/= singing live

as a Beyoncé stan, i would know

[Aqua]

Originally posted by cancer

In a concert? IDK.
But she sang happy birthday on the X Factor once which was the closest we've been to hearing her sing live this decade

She sang "It's My Party" on Radio One in 2013 too @ 17:40

[AMENHOOKER]

2012. She sang 'Happy Birthday' live on X Factor.

[Badger]

Didn't she sing happy birthday on the US XFactor?