Not sure if you guys have heard of these, but these are good.
 
 
Their both on the smaller budget, but are both pretty good at giving you the creeps.  I just saw Goodnight Mommy.  It's a German film with English subtitles.  If you like It Follows, it's similar to that in style of how the filming/directing works.  I wish I could understand what the significance of this film's ending was.
Last Shift has a similar feel to the Silent Hill games.  It's otherwise a pretty good scare. 
Both these films made me go on message boards and try to wrap my head around the film.  Highly recommend watching both.