Now that I think about it I feel like there could be four killers. The reason why there are several scenes showing three might be because the fourth one doesn't work with anyone. This killer (who I think might be Pete) could perhaps be murdering people as an act of revenge because they know that their murders will simply be lumped in with the other ones. They could also simply be an independent killer to act as an alibi for the other three which is why some of the Red Devil scenes - like the one in the next episode where he chases potential murderers like Hester and #5 - is so confusing and doesn't seem to make sense with the other murders. Also, if Pete is the fourth killer (and therefore unrelated to Boone), this would eliminate the whole discrepancies with gender and incest (not to say that they aren't plausible, it would explain why Pete hasn't had sex with Grace and would be an interesting allusion to Sleepaway Camp.)
It's Chanel O. There's really only two choices after last episode: her or #5. And #5 seems drastically less likely.
For what it's worth, I DO NOT want O as the killer. It's just that everything points to it being her, but the show refuses to treat her as a suspect in the least. Exact same strategy employed by Harper's Island AND Scream MTV.
Is #5 really that less likely though? She's the only one who DIDN'T leave for Thanksgiving despite throwing a bitch fit last week and saying she was leaving and never returning
Also She was their when her annoying boyfriend got killed yet the Red Devil wasted the entire nail gun on him and not her, not even a warning shot? That seems fishy to me
Chanel is not the killer and Chanel has showed obvious signs she's actually a good person and has sympathy for others. For example, she obviously felt bad for Hester during the Thanksgiving dinner. Chanel is not a villain and she's not the killer.
Also, Chad can die. He's getting really annoying.
Don't forget the time she went back to help Zayday when she could've easily let her die, like these girls really think she's the killer
I screamed when gigi's head showed up on the platter
I Literally knew that was gonna happen before they showed it because of the change of music, and how Chanel was talking all slow, It was predictable, but good
Also I Live for their sisterhood moments like the Cafeteria fight, and Chanel sticking up for Hester against Chad's tragic family, Two of my fave scenes of the season.
Chad should've been the head on the platter. His coming back at the end was officially the straw of him being annoying and not funny anymore.
Agreed. I've been enjoying him all season but it's time to go.
When Chanel stood up for herself and Hester I was cheering. I love their bitchiness but I also love when the girls band together. When she took him back at the end I was like
I think there's a new red devil killer in the midst. The girl twin made a new alliance and that's the one that killed Gigi and Boone hence why they were so silent . So one of the people we saw walking about today was the other RD. My guess the new killer in the crew is Pete making Grace the OG baby girl.
I think there's a new red devil killer in the midst. The girl twin made a new alliance and that's the one that killed Gigi and Boone hence why they were so silent . So one of the people we saw walking about today was the other RD. My guess the new killer in the crew is Pete making Grace the OG baby girl.
I think Chanel (Abigail) is just a red herring.
That was the twin sister that killed Gigi, it was pretty obvious since she turned on the carving knife and held it up towards Gigi instead of cutting the chicken.
That was the twin sister that killed Gigi, it was pretty obvious since she turned on the carving knife and held it up towards Gigi instead of cutting the chicken.
Right my theory is that it wasn't. We're just meant to think it was. The twin sister just sent 'her' red devil in place to get rid of Boone and Gigi while she was away establishing another solid alibi
But wait, does everyone have keys to the house or the doors are unlocked?
Pete's ass just coming in uninvited. Chanel #5 popping out of nowhere all randomly. (She's a Chanel, but still)
A mess, the devil could easily walk up in there.
Denise ran around the house and randomly appeared here and there.
Dean and Gigi showed up at the house from time to time.
And a lot of other times.....
And it took you 10 episodes to question this. Where have you been, sis??
like the Cafeteria fight, and Chanel sticking up for Hester against Chad's tragic family, Two of my fave scenes of the season. 
