[Mariano]

À plot twist doesn't have to be a complete surprise, let alone that people that are not on the forums have no idea that it's gonna be him for the most part

And what is the best plot twist then ? Because AHS don't even have a lot of plot twists in the first place

If they are smart it better not be him So you'd rather it be someone who makes NO SENSE just for the surprise ;rip:

And how is it not going to change everything ? 10CK is not even the main plotline, so yeah it's not going to change anything for the Countess for example, but it changes everything for John, this is not a MOVIE it's a TV series with an ensamble cast.

It's a PLOT twist and it's a good one /end.

[RyanYuno]

my episode rank so far would be 2>1>5>3>4

they need to start calling Gaga, The Countess/Elizabeth more often. its ridiculous that they havent, it makes it look like Gaga is playing a vampire version of herself

[A Little Unruly]

Since you're one of those members it's pointless to have a discussion with I'm gonna leave it at that.

[Pure Adrenaline]

Originally posted by Mariano

John being the 10CK is a PLOT twist by definition.

Anyway, they are revealing he is the 10CK in ep. 8 cuz we'll have to see how he deals with it....... and possibly others etc.

Nnnnnn idk where you get your definitions from but you clearly need a new source of information

So far there haven't been anybody else to be pointed at being the 10ck killer. If it was going to be plot twist the writers would have been giving us other suspects. The only person right now involved in this story line is John and no body else + since he started working on the case he's been going nuts and now that he is fired from his job we can't even look at the police department to look for any suspects or motive .... like srsly every normal person that watches this show would have figured it out that John is the killer by now, like that doesn't even require to use your brain that much 1+1

[Pure Adrenaline]

Originally posted by Mariano

À plot twist doesn't have to be a complete surprise, let alone that people that are not on the forums have no idea that it's gonna be him for the most part

And what is the best plot twist then ? Because AHS don't even have a lot of plot twists in the first place

If they are smart it better not be him So you'd rather it be someone who makes NO SENSE just for the surprise ;rip:

And how is it not going to change everything ? 10CK is not even the main plotline, so yeah it's not going to change anything for the Countess for example, but it changes everything for John, this is not a MOVIE it's a TV series with an ensamble cast.

It's a PLOT twist and it's a good one /end.

Just because YOU think it a plot twist and YOU think it's a good plot twist doesn't make it neither of those..

Actually the first 2 seasons of AHS brought one of the best plot twists TV series has ever had and that's what made the story so good in first place. No one would have expected Violet to be death or Dr. Thredson to be the Bloody face becasse they were done right and were actual plot twists. (if you had already knew about those 2 before watching MH and Asylum that's is your fault for spoiling yourself and not be surprised or amazed by them)

[Brunette Ambition]

taissa already being dead didn't interest me at all. i was surprised when everybody here loved it.

[Brunette Ambition]

also someone needs to explain to me the ownership of the hotel.
gaga owned it, then lost it to madoff, thus why she's also poor. but how can she sell it to will drake then?

[Mariano]

Not even going to read your comments guys.

I have actually studied the subjects I am talking about, so yeah one thing you are right - pointless to have a discussion with me with your lack of knowledge.

John is the detective who is trying to find the person behind several murders. If it ends up being himself, it's a PLOT twist by definition. As simple as that.

Now whether your fan theories match that or not - insignifficant to what I am saying.

[HausOfCarlos]

Originally posted by Pure Adrenaline

Just because YOU think it a plot twist and YOU think it's a good plot twist doesn't make it neither of those..

Actually the first 2 seasons of AHS brought one of the best plot twists TV series has ever had and that's what made the story so good in first place. No one would have expected Violet to be death or Dr. Thredson to be the Bloody face becasse they were done right and were actual plot twists. (if you had already knew about those 2 before watching MH and Asylum that's is your fault for spoiling yourself and not be surprised or amazed by them)

Those two definitely were AMAZING plot twists but if John ends up being the killer it still is a plot twist no matter how unsurprising it is since it 'twists' the whole plot, it goes against the protagonist point of view we have of him.

[Mariano]

And I agree about the Velvet and Dr. Thredson plot twists being good, never said they weren't

I said that if John ends up being the 10CK it'd be one of the best plot twists of the show. And again if you weren't on ATRL, u wouldn't catch most of those "clues" that he is the 10CK

[P!nk Forever]

I have a feeling that John Lowe is already dead and a ghost. Just can't explain how it could have happened.

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

John being the killer would def be a plot twist. You guys have already overanalyzed and looked too far into things which is why you think it'd be boring.

I can definitely see John being the killer, so it wouldn't be a SURPRISE to me, but that is definitely a plot twist. Look at the movie Se7en, which definitely inspired the 10CK plotline-- if Brad Pitt's character turned out to be the killer, it'd definitely be a surprise & a good twist.

[Daddy]

Originally posted by Brunette Ambition

the way it was shot (to the right there was so much room) it was so obvious that was gon happen.

Right? Usually we have seen It all nowadays so I don't get how people could be really surprised by such basic things

[C/H/A/N/E/L]

Literally WHAT else would be more of a twist for you people than the MAIN INVESTIGATOR of a murder spree being the killer? And it's not even that he knows and he's trying to keep it a secret. The main theory people have is that he has split personalities & one is killing and the other is investigating. That is an AMAZING idea, and if y'all don't think so, then you're hopeless & are asking too much of this show.

[joe71941]

Casual viewers dont expect John to be the killer its just that we are obsessed with the show.

[Mariano]

Originally posted by C/H/A/N/E/L

Literally WHAT else would be more of a twist for you people than the MAIN INVESTIGATOR of a murder spree being the killer? And it's not even that he knows and he's trying to keep it a secret. The main theory people have is that he has split personalities & one is killing and the other is investigating. That is an AMAZING idea, and if y'all don't think so, then you're hopeless & are asking too much of this show.

mte

[Giorgoc]

Chanel better spill it. Y'all are too much.

[KylieistBoi]

People are expecting soap opera twists from AHS like Empire does

[Brunette Ambition]

Room 33 promos with Gaga in the room
http://41.media.tumblr.com/f5e5498cc...py75o1_500.jpg
http://41.media.tumblr.com/328ef086e...py75o1_500.jpg

[Rusty]

Originally posted by Brunette Ambition

Room 33 promos with Gaga in the room
http://41.media.tumblr.com/f5e5498cc...py75o1_500.jpg
http://41.media.tumblr.com/328ef086e...py75o1_500.jpg

Disney Princess teas