[swiftie13]

Originally posted by Sam 

I don't see anything wrong with the scoring system. I don't feel comfortable giving an above average song a below average score just because it happens to be in the lower ranks of the round. That's not a true rating of the song. Why score a song lower than it should be just for the purpose of having lower scores overall? If you do a great job you deserve a great score.

I second this although I'm not a judge hehe



Omg @ Clarkson getting 2 10's

[minho]

Originally posted by ClarksonSlays

I got two 10s but I was still No. 4

Sam was it Lovesong or Meowster that sabotaged me?

It was me!

I actually kind of tugged on your song a bit, but it was still received nicely.

[Dylobs]

Originally posted by Sam 

Funny, I never heard you complaining about the way the scoring was done in GotSkill's or Truth Teller's seasons (which is the same as this season, by giving a numerical score and averaging them).

But let me not take you so seriously and ignore your request to change the scoring system.

[Element]

I was just reading some of my PH7 songs and dear God were they awful

[Temporal]

I don't think the scoring is that big of a deal just because it's higher than normal, it just comes with a different judging panel.

[Temporal]

Originally posted by lovesong

It was me!

I actually kind of tugged on your song a bit, but it was still received nicely.

Snatching my PH7 crown wasn't enough for you?

[Moonchild]

I'm glad all of my critiques have been pretty consistent across judges so far.

[Hugamari]

Originally posted by Moonchild

I'm glad all of my critiques have been pretty consistent across judges so far.

Hold onto your weave for next round then!

(No, this isn't an ominous hint)

[Temporal]

My chart positions so far:

1, Ocean Lips (PH Grammy winner)
1, Purpose (PH Grammy nominated)
1, Love Her*
2, Ship in a Bottle
2, Odyssey
2, Lost Birds* (PH Grammy Nominated)
3, Make Me a God, (2x PH Grammy nominated)
4, Gales of Time
4, Dance With the Ghosts
4, Astral Lullaby
4, Brand New Eyes
5, The Story (feat. Era)*
6, Silver
8, Dark Side (PH Grammy nominated)
9, Irreplaceable
9, Freak.
13, Just a Dream
17, Village by the Mountain

3 No.1s, 12 Top 5s, 16 Top 10s and 18 Top 20s

[UFO]

Idgaf as long as I'm slaying

[keshaspearsxo]

Originally posted by Sam 

Funny, I never heard you complaining about the way the scoring was done in GotSkill's or Truth Teller's seasons (which is the same as this season, by giving a numerical score and averaging them).

But let me not take you so seriously and ignore your request to change the scoring system.

I haven't asked you to change anything. Just commenting. Like y'all do.

[minho]

adljf poor Village By The Mountain

I don't know why I was the only one stanning for that

[Temporal]

Originally posted by lovesong

adljf poor Village By The Mountain

I don't know why I was the only one stanning for that

If you didn't lord knows how bad it would've been

[swiftie13]

Does anyone have a link to the previous season? I wanna check my (very little number of) positions hehe

[minho]

Originally posted by ClarksonSlays

If you didn't lord knows how bad it would've been

It might be the highest score I've given you so far

[minho]

Originally posted by swiftie13

Does anyone have a link to the previous season? I wanna check my (very little number of) positions hehe

Good luck, that thread has way too many pages

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=792003

[Moonchild]

If next round involves sign-ups.

[Temporal]

Originally posted by lovesong

It might be the highest score I've given you so far

Poor Brand New Gods

[Temporal]

Originally posted by Moonchild

If next round involves sign-ups.

Get used to it sis.

[minho]

Originally posted by Moonchild

If next round involves sign-ups.

dd signups were the WORST. I'd always get stuck with limited options.

The good thing about this past one was that Sam gave so many potential choices for you all to sign up.