[SpinThatShhh]

Originally posted by Dani97

Every time i'm watching a video in youtube the next video they play is Hello. I had to deactivate the automatic reproduction.

She has already beat Loose's record. You can watch in peace now.

[slw84]

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

Madonna and Janet are better producers&writers than Mariah.And please don't bring that ''but she wrote 17 #1s!1!!!1!!'' receipt

I wont' luv because many of mariah's album tracks and songs that didn't hit #1 are superior to those that did.

Madonna and Janet are better CO writers.

I've seen albums where Mariah has sole credit as a writer...to great songs.

I haven't seen that with the other two.

[Evolution]

Mariah is a better songwriter and producer than Madonna.

*inb4 Rolling Stones biased songwriters list *

[slw84]

I NEEEEEEED Adele to break Nsync's record.

I hear they are putting it almost everywhere.

Seriously 2.5M+ with streaming I won't settle for anything less.

[gettsleazy]

Revival > True Blue

[Lein]

Originally posted by slw84

Eminem stans still mad that Mariah never claimed their fave.

Mariah carey is vocally better than both she produces and writes better songs.

She's better looking than both.

They just dance better and are more entertaining and have more artistic visual direction.

She has the vocals but what about the rest? Her albums & songs don't get close to Janitor & Madonna highs. "She writes better songs" but they never made any "best" list. Her videos are horrible & as a performer

I like Mariah, Marshmallow stan or not

[XStaticProcess]

Originally posted by slw84

I wont' luv because many of mariah's album tracks and songs that didn't hit #1 are superior to those that did.

Madonna and Janet are better CO writers.

I've seen albums where Mariah has sole credit as a writer...to great songs.

I haven't seen that with the other two.

Mariah has like 2 solo written songs according to official credits...

[slw84]

Originally posted by Evolution

Mariah is a better songwriter and producer than Madonna.

*inb4 Rolling Stones biased songwriters list *

Educate them....
I think people get tricked by the subject matter.
Madonna has more interesting topics and more versatility in what she covers.
She still depends on an established writer to "co-write" with her.

Mariah just has the innate skill of writing a great song even if her subjects are limited the way it's written is stronger than a madonna song.


But Madonna and janet are more artistic than Mariah though

[Ecstasy]

Originally posted by Evolution

Mariah is a better songwriter and producer than Madonna.

*inb4 Rolling Stones biased songwriters list *

Cuz yours is not biased right?

[XStaticProcess]

Rolling Stone's list was not biased.Madonna is a better songwriter&producer than Mariah

[bluth]

not long until ari her b0p. this is our time of need, the world needs to be reminded that pop musec doesn't have to be morose ballads for the next year.

[slw84]

Originally posted by Lein

She has the vocals but what about the rest? Her albums & songs don't get close to Janitor & Madonna highs. "She writes better songs" but they never made any "best" list. Her videos are horrible & as a performer

I like Mariah, Marshmallow stan or not

Mariah's videos are subpart.
EVEN SHE admitted that her videos are not great and focused on the songs to connect the audience.
I would agree that artistically
Madonna has been the most versatile
Janet has executed her reinventions the best
Mariah is the most technically gifted.
I think madonna and janet have better albums but Mariah has better songs overall her best songs >>> Janet and Madonna's

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

Mariah has like 2 solo written songs according to official credits...

Are we not counting songs in which samples get credits. She did a lot of samples back in the 90s.

[alex_katycat]

Originally posted by jinzo

Same Old Love is better than any Madonna single.

I'm logging in and this the first post I see

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Like A Prayer is the best song of all time though.

Originally posted by conatus

Explain.

Self explanatory. ARTPOP is far out her best album.

ARTPOP > Born This Way = The Fame Monster >>> The Fame.

[jinzo]

Originally posted by gettsleazy

Revival > True Blue

!!!!!

Me and the Rhythm is literally better than any Celine Dion song.

[bluth]

there is something utterly transcendent about the hook in this. b0pdonna at her finest.

[XStaticProcess]

Originally posted by Lein

She has the vocals but what about the rest? Her albums & songs don't get close to Janitor & Madonna highs. "She writes better songs" but they never made any "best" list. Her videos are horrible & as a performer

I like Mariah, Marshmallow stan or not

All of this.

[SpinThatShhh]

Godga can do better than CHARTDROP, but it's still better than most main pop girls albums in the last 5 years.

[slw84]

Originally posted by XStaticProcess

Rolling Stone's list was not biased.Madonna is a better songwriter&producer than Mariah

I love madonna but I honestly ok I won't...
We'll just have to agree to disagree.

[conatus]

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Self explanatory. ARTPOP is far out her best album.

ARTPOP > Born This Way = The Fame Monster >>> The Fame.