[Sanctuary]

If the update so far is any indication, I bet it's I Want You.

[Vilppu]

Perhaps Your Honesty?

[That Bad Eartha]

47. Your Honesty


Average - 7.441
Album: Extras
Rank within album: 3rd of 13

Hearts (10): tylerlscwv, Quicksand, Lifeline, mrmikefern, XStaticProcess
Rebels (2): Reinvention

Host commentary - I don’t think this should have replaced Don’t Stop (because I love DS), but I do think this might be her strongest uptempo recorded in the 90s (not that she recorded many tbh). It definitely deserved a spot on the tracklist. It is just so infectious and lovely. Happy it made it this far.

Guest commentary
Lifeline -It does have that special quality. I simple love it when M sings in French. Don't ask me how this ended up on Remixed & Forgotten only in 2003. It wouldn't have sounded out of place one bit if it had replaced 'Don't Stop' on Bedtime Story.

Quicksand– The best non-single from the Bedtime Stories era overall.

mrmikefern - Could have been on the album (probably in the place of Don't Stop tbh) but didn't really need to be. I'm glad it was officially released.

[Vilppu]

I like it but honestly I wouldn't like it to be on Bedtime Stories.

[Achilles.]

Iconic is awful and should have been killed 20 spots ago before Candy Shop and whatnot.

[Sanctuary]

Forreal though, why do so many BS outtakes sound like Tuberculosis b-sides? Were they going to go back to that sound initially? Thank God someone intervened.

[Achilles.]

It's time for Gang Bang, Iassic, and the rest of Music + AL to go.

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

Aw buh-bye Your Honest Tea! Love ya

[That Bad Eartha]

46. She's Not Me


Average - 7.486
Album: Hard Candy
Rank within album: 2nd of 14

Hearts (10): THEBEASTWITHIN, Shaliydah88, Reinvention, Dark Miracles, Alongoria13, dabunique
Rebels (2): Vilppu, Humoresque

Host commentary - One of the only Hard Candy songs I really do like. It still is missing something to make it a signature Madonna song, but it is cute. Would be higher if Pharrell didn’t show up towards the end and ruin it.

Guest commentary
Subomie- The song is decent, a bit too long, but the tour performance is everything!

[Lifeline]

Not Your Honesty

[Vilppu]

Oop.

She's Not Me would probably be my favourite track on HC but it gets tiring after, like, 3 minutes. 6 is an exaggeration.

[Alongoria13]

My corazon is numb

[Sanctuary]

The only reason I didn't give this a ten was because the studio version is seventeen years long!

If we were rating the live version I'd be pissed, but this can go now.

[Nemo]

One of the worst, unusable tracks on Hard Grammy (but the bridge slaYs)

[Petty Bourgeoisie]

She's Ain'T Moi ha remixing halfway through the track >>>>>



I use it endlessly

[Pandora]

I agree, it's far too long.

[Dark Miracles]

Pharrell does ruin She's Not Me, but the first 3 minutes are still good enough for a 10.

[Achilles.]

Nooo SNM is the second best of the 3.5 good songs on Hillary Clinton.

[Lifeline]

She's So Meh out YAS



Two Steps Behind Ha >>>>>>>

[Reinvention]

Originally posted by tylerlscwv

46. She's Not Me


Average - 7.486
Album: Hard Candy
Rank within album: 2nd of 14

Hearts (10): THEBEASTWITHIN, Shaliydah88, Reinvention, Dark Miracles, Alongoria13, dabunique
Rebels (2): Vilppu, Humoresque

Host commentary - One of the only Hard Candy songs I really do like. It still is missing something to make it a signature Madonna song, but it is cute. Would be higher if Pharrell didn’t show up towards the end and ruin it.

Guest commentary
Subomie- The song is decent, a bit too long, but the tour performance is everything!

Ya'll did "She's Not Me" wrong. Such an iconic bop, and highlight of the Sticky & Sweet Tour.