[Dämon]

Originally posted by Optimus

But that would not necessarily affect his work with Gaga. You know damn well that Gaga brings out the best out of every producer she works with.

She worked with DJWS, and yet you trash his productions every damn day?

[Pierrot]

It's not about her working with Max Martin. It's about her choosing to work with Max Martin instead of better, novel producers.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Dämon

She worked with DJWS, and yet you trash his productions every damn day?

I should have ended with 'unless you're DJWS'

[Dämon]

I'm just saying, her running to generic producers will make her look desperate. I'd rather she experiment Then again, she can experiment with generic producers. Wait and see

The only think I know is that RedOne is a BAD idea.

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Max Martin produced ...Baby One More Time. That song alone was revolutionary for pop music at the time, so who's to say that should he work with Gaga, they couldn't do that again?

[Kayhan]

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Max Martin produced ...Baby One More Time. That song alone was revolutionary for pop music at the time, so who's to say that should he work with Gaga, they couldn't do that again?

[toanythingtaboo]

I'd be disappointed if she compromised her integrity and (very obviously) sold out for hits.

But if she simply wanted to work with Max Martin (because of his pop classics), I'd have no issue. If the song is basic, then we'll talk.

I second ELECTRAHEARTPOP, too. The producers are there to enhance and execute her vision. It's up to her to write a good song. The producers aren't going to drastically alter the song quality either way.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Dämon

I'm just saying, her running to generic producers will make her look desperate. I'd rather she experiment

Who cares if she will look desperate? See, she returned to RedOne and the twinks here call her desperate because they are afraid. Imagine if she really worked with Max Martin. They would go insane

Originally posted by ELECTRAHEARTPOP

Max Martin produced ...Baby One More Time. That song alone was revolutionary for pop music at the time, so who's to say that should he work with Gaga, they couldn't do that again?

Exctly my point!

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Optimus

Who cares if she will look desperate? See, she returned to RedOne and the twinks here call her desperate because they are afraid. Imagine if she really worked with Ma Martin. They would go insane



Exctly my point!

Because you only care about her being relevant and getting hits, lol. It's been known since months, now. You want her to have massive sales, massive singles, etc. I mean, you have trouble calling Applause a hit, lol.

I wouldn't have any problem with that if she didn't spend 2014 saying all the stuff she said, lol. I'll stand by her, I'll just be disappointed. If you don't see any problem with her completely ignoring what she said before, good for you.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Dämon

Because you only care about her being relevant and getting hits, lol. It's been known since months, now. You want her to have massive sales, massive singles, etc. I mean, you have trouble calling Applause a hit, lol.

I wouldn't have any problem with that if she didn't spend 2014 saying all the stuff she said, lol. I'll stand by her, I'll just be disappointed. If you don't see any problem with her completely ignoring what she said before, good for you.

really? Do you really think that if I stanned for sales and hits I would be here after artpop when a lot of stans jumped ship?

[- JED -]

Originally posted by Optimus

I dont get it too. Why would anyone unstan if Gaga worked with people who know how to do their job well, proven by time. Working someone who is experienced could only benenfit Gaga. Someone like Max Martin or Stargate will only help Gaga to bring her ideas to life in a much much better way than some random DJ would. How would that make Gaga basic? For gods sake, you havent even heard ANYTHING

When you're right, you're right

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Optimus

really? Do you really think that if I stanned for sales and hits I would be here after artpop when a lot of stans jumped ship?

Because you still have hope she'll get massive hits with LG5, hence why you want her to work with generic producers and want Gaga to completely IGNORE what she preached throughout 2014.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Dämon

Because you still have hope she'll get massive hits with LG5, hence why you want her to work with generic producers and want Gaga to completely IGNORE what she preached throughout 2014.

Originally posted by - JED -

When you're right, you're right

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Optimus

Where did I lie?

Did you not say you expected her to have a massive global hit in the Base?
Did you not say you wanted her to work with generic producers (RedOne, Max Martin & co)?

[jackieshann]

max martin is a shell of his former self anyway. the trash he served ellie goulding with on my mind

his production is basic and forgettable, doesn't suit gaga at all.

[Kayhan]

Originally posted by Dämon

Because you still have hope she'll get massive hits with LG5, hence why you want her to work with generic producers and want Gaga to completely IGNORE what she preached throughout 2014.

too much

[ELECTRAHEARTPOP]

Oh yeah of course I wouldn't want her to sell out for hits. I wouldn't want her to make 1989. If she was to work with him or any other popular producer for a cheap and quick #1 I'd be pissed and so disappointed. But if she wanted to see what they could make together then why not? It (in my opinion) worked out with will.i.am. A lot of people - myself included - expected Scream and Shout when he was announced as the producer of Fashion!, but we actually got a funky nu-disco song with Let's Dance era Bowie verses and a crazy early Daft Punk breakdown at the end.

[Vertigo Stick]

Originally posted by Pierrot

It's not about her working with Max Martin. It's about her choosing to work with Max Martin instead of better, novel producers.

.

I need something organic from her...something that feels like natural progression. I am interested in knowing what direction she goes in because she's in an interesting place. A lot of people want her to return to her pop roots with catchy hooks and simple productions, yet many expect more from her. I'd love for her to do something unexpected, but as long as it is good then can't really complain!!

[LadyGagaStan93]

I don't find anything fantastic about Max Martin or Dr.Luke but I wouldn't stop stanning for her if she worked wit them. She was never above working with them. But some of y'all stay pretending that she's too good for that so idk. I guess it makes sense you'd leave if she did.

I just think she should do what she wants. If I don't like what she makes from here on out there are other artists. Life goes on.

[Optimus]

Originally posted by Dämon

Where did I lie?

Did you not say you expected her to have a massive global hit in the Base?
Did you not say you wanted her to work work with generic producers (RedOne, Max Martin & co)?

I did not say 'I expect'. Do not put words in my mouth. I said ' I feel like she is gonna have a big hit' judging by her attitude, the pics with RedOne etc. Thats of course what I think.
And yeah I said that I would like Gaga to work with producers who know how to their job, will help her to execute her ideas better, and make qualty music. I do not see a problem with that