[Artemisia]

Aren't reviewers given the first couple of episodes? I know that happens with GoT.

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Aren't reviewers given the first couple of episodes? I know that happens with GoT.

Just 1 unfortunately.

[Teen Idle]

Originally posted by Luma

It is decent, and Freakshow's 69 is the second highest rating for AHS. You do the math!

-

ok so... excellent for AHS standards. got it

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Artemisia

Aren't reviewers given the first couple of episodes? I know that happens with GoT.

Not for this season. Reviewers said they only got one episode. Did you not read the reviews during your stay in this, well, thread about reviews?

[joacerbaser]

Originally posted by Pure Adrenaline

I cant at the Madonna and Katy avis flooding the last pages

And Lana avis as well....poor dem their faves bore them

[Pop]

Glad Gaga is getting rave reviews

Seems like she is the saving grace of this season. Who else?

[Butters]

yall can stay hitting the refresh button on the Rotten Tomatoes page, going into pathetic, celebratory, little convulsions "the FAD is over!!!!!" each time you see that the AHS score falls 2 points, bye

[Artemisia]

Originally posted by Tanguy

Did you not read the reviews during your stay in this, well, thread about reviews?

And spoil the woman of the year's cable debut? Ha!

[Baby Boy]

Originally posted by borntodiethisway

Funny how y'all can dish it, but can't take it.

mte.

OT: still have hope the season is good.

[Dämon]

Originally posted by Artemisia

And spoil the woman of the year's cable debut? Ha!

I'm confused. What are you even doing in this thread if you're not interested in what the reviews have to say about the show? I'm legit confused.

Originally posted by Baby Boy

mte.

OT: still have hope the season is good.

Nice to see you (again)! Was wondering when you'd show up (again)!

[GypsyLife]

Originally posted by Artemisia

And spoil the woman of the year's cable debut? Ha!

You mean to say you only entered when the ratings went down just to get some kiis and snark. It's fine sis, just call a spade a spade

[Luma]

Originally posted by Haus

Yes, which is why Metacritic and RT are entirely pointless for television and this thread shouldn't even exist. Fans and haters are getting worked up over scores that mean absolutely nothing.

Agreed, but I find these reviews pointless for pretty much everything. Which is odd because ATRL usually agrees with this statement when it comes to their favs but suddenly they've all changed their minds!

-
Excited for the season!

[Austin]

omg what happened Swear I went out and this was on like 80 something % on RT

[MonsterConnor]

I'm so done with RT.
Did some digging and once again, they are counting "6/10" reviews as negative........

No wonder Metacritic is using the same reviews but its score is a 61%. Because unlike Rt, metacritic doesn't just count a review positive or negative, it has a "mixed/average" bar as well.

[Starburst]

[Giancor]

Cant wait to be scared/slayed by gagz!
idont like horror stuff tho

[Hotshot]

Omg, I was right! It will have 50s score

[MonsterConnor]

Who knows tho, maybe the mixed reviews are warranted.

I did have a slight feeling that a hotel setting might be bland.

[Haus]

Originally posted by Luma

Agreed, but I find these reviews pointless for pretty much everything. Which is odd because ATRL usually agrees with this statement when it comes to their favs but suddenly they've all changed their minds!

-
Excited for the season!

They're relevant for music and film since those reviews cover the piece as a whole. It makes no sense to designate a score to a TV show when the reviews only cover the first episode, and never does a show have consistent quality from episode to episode when they all have different writers, directors, etc.

What Metacritic and RT should do is wait until a season has finished airing and then add and average the reviews for each episode... but that'd be too much work, huh?

[Bounce]

Originally posted by Baby Boy

mte.

OT: still have hope the season is good.

You seem to be in every Gaga thread in ATRL despite saying that you don't care about her? Wyd sis?