[Instant]

Originally posted by Hotshot

only 8 reviews and 66 already? gosh, expect this to be at 50s when all reviews are factored in.



I feel like Ryan can't top coven's pilot episode ever

Lol, what? Asylum's pilot was so much better than Coven's yet it got 65 on metacritic. Clearly critics' opinions on AHS don't hold much weight

[MetalHausOfJosh]

Originally posted by Hotshot

only 8 reviews and 66 already? gosh, expect this to be at 50s when all reviews are factored in.



I feel like Ryan can't top coven's pilot episode ever

Stop with the trolling This is actually a pretty good score

[Hotshot]

Originally posted by Instant

Lol, what? Asylum's pilot was so much better than Coven's yet it got 65 on metacritic. Clearly critics' opinions on AHS don't hold much weight

debatable!!! asylum's pilot is quite boring. coven is just perfect, the critics agree with me

[Hotshot]

Originally posted by MetalHausOfJosh

Stop with the trolling This is actually a pretty good score

what trolling? usually we get high scores in the beginning then as more reviews come, the score eventually drops.

not that reviews matter for a TV show since metacritic mostly count pilot reviews only.

anyway, we should focus on their gaga's acting critique

[IBeMe]

does rotten tomato get meshed into the metacritic final figures?

[Hotshot]

Originally posted by IBeMe

does rotten tomato get meshed into the metacritic final figures?

no. they are entirely different.

what about imdb ratings? they are indicative of GP's perception. we should include it here also

[wesleywalrus]

Originally posted by IBeMe

does rotten tomato get meshed into the metacritic final figures?

nope two separate things

[Skywalker]

Originally posted by Hotshot

no. they are entirely different.

what about imdb ratings? they are indicative of GP's perception. we should include it here also

Maybe but they won't be up until tomorrow.

[Instant]

Originally posted by Hotshot

what trolling? usually we get high scores in the beginning then as more reviews come, the score eventually drops.

not that reviews matter for a TV show since metacritic mostly count pilot reviews only.

anyway, we should focus on their gaga's acting critique

Usually like 2-3 episodes of new seasons are showed to critics. This time Ryan send only pilot to critics. So yeah, whole season's score will be represented by one episode

[Hotshot]

considering this is not an HBO show, 70 would be a great metacritic score.

ratings is more important tbh. I believe Ryan already bought the emmy noms for next year so we need not worry hihi

[Flawfree]

Originally posted by Hotshot

only 8 reviews and 66 already? gosh, expect this to be at 50s when all reviews are factored in.



I feel like Ryan can't top coven's pilot episode ever

?

If you're talking about ratings, then Freak Show's premiere had the highest ratings for any show in FX history.

If you're talking about quality, then LOL.
Coven turned to **** as soon as the credits stopped rolling and Taissa came on.

[Hotshot]

Originally posted by Flawfree

?

If you're talking about ratings, then Freak Show's premiere had the highest ratings for any show in FX history.

If you're talking about quality, then LOL.
Coven turned to **** as soon as the credits stopped rolling and Taissa came on.

who is Taissa? she is the least remarkable/ important character I suppose. coven's quality is superior - writing (first few episodes), visuals, etc.

[Nein]

Originally posted by Hotshot

who is Taissa? she is the least remarkable/ important character I suppose. coven's quality is superior - writing (first few episodes), visuals, etc.

Taissa was Zoe and Violet on AHS.

[Flawfree]

Originally posted by Hotshot

who is Taissa? she is the least remarkable/ important character I suppose. coven's quality is superior - writing (first few episodes), visuals, etc.

lol you didn't understand my point. I was saying that the only good part about Coven's premiere was Kathy Bates' opening scene in the 1800s.

[jim19911126]

Is this the first time that MC reviews for AHS?
I can't see any old AHS reviews on the website.

[zoldyck]

Gaga is not getting trashed for her acting and overall MC score is 60s like other seasons so i am good with these reviews.

[effie593]

I don't really have much use for reviews apart from seeing how good Gaga's acting is. As long as I like the season I don't really care about its Metacritic score, considering Asylum's score is no way indicative of its quality.

[Remixed]

Originally posted by Hotshot

only 8 reviews and 66 already? gosh, expect this to be at 50s when all reviews are factored in.



I feel like Ryan can't top coven's pilot episode ever

[Jenher]

The daily beast review

Lady Gaga’s Bloody Insane ‘Hotel’ Orgy: The Craziest ‘American Horror Story’ Premiere Yet

http://www.thedailybeast.com/article...miere-yet.html

[BlondUnicorn]

St. Louis Post-Dispatch: 50

TV review: 'American Horror Story: Hotel' takes gore too far