[MillionLights]

Gaga. More sales =/= more impact.

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by Crescendolls.

First of all collaborating with a hot rapper for some extra sales is not what I call impact. Kendrick and Taylor both used each other's audiences, it was a very clear and basic scheme. Singers collaborate with rappers every time, so miss me with that flop argument.

I do not care that she has sold a billion albums or whatever. Selling a lot doesn't mean that you actually have impact on "pop culture". Of course she would have impact on her fans, otherwise they wouldn't be fans. But I have yet to see her impact on pop culture, a term that involves a lot of things. Did she have massive impact on other singers ? No. Did she start any trend/craze ? No. Does she actually have any iconic moment ? No. Did she even inspire any fashion trend ? No. Did she take country or pop to another level ? No. She's by far the safest act in pop history. As for that part about "attention-seeking" gestures, let me not

/thread

[Whiskey Mouth]

Lady Gaga. Taylor really hasn't done anything memorable and that people will remember.

Gaga has iconic performances, iconic looks...Everything just points to her. I love both artists though, so I hope Taylor has an iconic performance some time down the road.

[halcyonday]

Originally posted by Crescendolls.

First of all collaborating with a hot rapper for some extra sales is not what I call impact. Kendrick and Taylor both used each other's audiences, it was a very clear and basic scheme. Singers collaborate with rappers every time, so miss me with that flop argument.

I do not care that she has sold a billion albums or whatever. Selling a lot doesn't mean that you actually have impact on "pop culture". Of course she would have impact on her fans, otherwise they wouldn't be fans. But I have yet to see her impact on pop culture, a term that involves a lot of things. Did she have massive impact on other singers ? No. Did she start any trend/craze ? No. Does she actually have any iconic moment ? No. Did she even inspire any fashion trend ? No. Did she take country or pop to another level ? No. She's by far the safest act in pop history. As for that part about "attention-seeking" gestures, let me not

[Azealia Banks]

Gaga, she is a worldwide phenomenon

[Brinny Baby]

Gaga

[jacklovesyou1]

Taylor I hear in the streets everyone referencing bad blood, shake it and blank space no one talks about gaga really

[ivi]

Originally posted by Crescendolls.

First of all collaborating with a hot rapper for some extra sales is not what I call impact. Kendrick and Taylor both used each other's audiences, it was a very clear and basic scheme. Singers collaborate with rappers every time, so miss me with that flop argument.

I do not care that she has sold a billion albums or whatever. Selling a lot doesn't mean that you actually have impact on "pop culture". Of course she would have impact on her fans, otherwise they wouldn't be fans. But I have yet to see her impact on pop culture, a term that involves a lot of things. Did she have massive impact on other singers ? No. Did she start any trend/craze ? No. Does she actually have any iconic moment ? No. Did she even inspire any fashion trend ? No. Did she take country or pop to another level ? No. She's by far the safest act in pop history. As for that part about "attention-seeking" gestures, let me not

/thread

[Sippy Cup]

The only thing Taylor has memorable is that time she got interrupted by Kanye. That's it. Gaga has perfomances, songs, outfits, and way more.

[M A R C]

Gaga by miles.

[AMENHOOKER]

Originally posted by jacklovesyou1

Taylor I hear in the streets everyone referencing bad blood, shake it and blank space no one talks about gaga really

Yeah, because these three songs smashed and went #1 recently.
Next year, and the year after that, and the year after that, there will be more singles that will smash, and people 'in the streets' will be referencing them.

[NX127]

Gaga by FAR

[enxe]

Gaga

[CandyBling]

Lady Gaga is the only answer. I mean whats the impact of tswift?

[yogosans14]

Is this even a question?

Taylor ofc

[HereInMyHead]

I personally think Gaga. I don't have a problem with Taylor but she hasn't really had any iconic moments that would make her have more impact than Gaga.

Gaga may no longer be as popular as she once was, but that doesn't mean that she doesn't have memorable moments. Within her time at her peak she managed to make the rest of the pop world step up its game and make things more interesting, weird fashion has always existed but Gaga definitely brought it back and popularised it in the late 2000's/early 2010's.

Taylor may have some impact in the future, but as of right now, not so much.

[Yanko]

considering that taylor has absolutely no impact, Lady gaga

[Truffle.]

What impact does Taylor have besides the record for most songs about a boy in ones discography

Gaga gets my vote

[Yanko]

Originally posted by Luxas

Her music is more catchy and versatile.... Music legends are praising her....and there's definately more in store from her... she's win here...

you just described gaga not taylor lmoa

[Aqua]

Gaga by lightyears