[Havoc]

Originally posted by Bríseis

Nah. The only moment when Bey seemed to become global was during DiL era, mainly thanks to the success of CiL.

Delusional. She's been global since Survivor.

[Nicole]

She's global (her last tour did $200m+) and she released the most acclaimed album by a major popstar possibly ever. She has nothing to worry about.

[.aR]

Nice to see some beyhive members posting here now that most have shifted to Popfn. The trolls do get annoying.

[Wafflecakes]

Originally posted by .aR

Nice to see some beyhive members posting here now that most have shifted to Popfn. The trolls do get annoying.

"Anyone who disagrees with me is a troll*

[Kingpin]

It's scary how much they care

[*-ChriZ-*]

Of course shes global, shes a music legend.

[Aleks]

Another one of these threads

No, she's not global. Her unimpressive WW sales is all we need to know, I'm afraid some random receipts of South Korean sales and her ringtone certifications in Canada won't change that.

[Kool_Aid_King]

She isn't local at all. Her tour's bigger than everyone in this thread's faves (Besides Medonsters).

We didn't need this thread cause people who think she's global will still have the tea and the people who think she's local remain either joking or just don't like Beyoncé.

[Ryanicorn]

That's fantastic. I can't wait for her see this so she can help put you and your kids through college.

[T0M]

Only the haters think she's local You don't have to prove anything to someone that his fave is Britney Spears just look at the Mr Carter World Tour's box office and you will get the answer.
Britney spears was a teen pop phenomenon in the early 2000's and that's it. It is tragic to see her fans comparing her to legends like MJ or Madonna she will never be in the same league as a performer/artist like them. Any realistic person knows that.

Beyonce is more powerful and respected than Ms. Spears will ever be.

/endthread

[americanshameless]

The drags write themselves

[Travis Bickle]

Those global receipts

[americanshameless]

OT: I think she's aite, she's known but she never really had that strong UNIVERSAL appeal.

Originally posted by Planet Mars

and YAAAAASSS @ the Hive showing up and showing out in here I love y'all

hanajaan I just
showin out youknow dd
yall a bunch of damn fools

[Lein]

South Africa:
I am...Sasha fierce certified MULTIPLATINUM(equivalent of diamond)

Singapore:
Dangerously in love certified MULTIPLATINUM(equivalent of diamond)
This is just some,only 10x platinum and above achievements have been recognised

In SA it's certified 2x platinum = multiplatinum, same goes for Singapore

She has also succeeded in albums with Dangerously in love being certified 8x platinum

Absolutely wrong, it has sold 76k+ aka less than 3x platinum .

Using ringtones, particularly in for South Korea, as receipts

[T.C]

Originally posted by Cupid

Nice try jan.

And Europe has huge music markets, people trying to downplay it is very transparent.

Nah, more like Europeans here downplay the rest of the world

[Bríseis]

Originally posted by Planet Mars

Lol Hive, haters know she isn't local its just what they use to drag Bey like a running gag of sorts.

Anyway its just your gay white European twinks on ATRL who use that shade towards her. They Stan for your basic, minimally talented plane Jane's who make basic pop music so...

Beyonce out earns, is more respected, is more talented and is on a whole other level compared to their faves (who normally fade after 5-6 years regardless) so the Hive shouldn't be bothered and we rarely ever are lmao

Originally posted by Deuces

He was talking about what ATRL sees as global and it is very euro-centric. No lies there.
You should be taking advice from Hive members because we know how to stan for talent. While others just stan for...you know...lack of live vocals and incoherent "dance" moves.

No thanks hunties. I am rather stanning for amazing artists who are using their "minimal" (lol) talents to actually create brilliant music than your basic and bland fave, dear Hive.

[T0M]

Originally posted by Bríseis

No thanks hunties. I am rather stanning for amazing artists who are using their "minimal" (lol) talents to actually create brilliant music than your bland, basic, on pro songwritters relying fave, dear Hive.

[Revel]

The point is that Beyonce's name/brand is bigger than her music worldwide, that's why she sell tours so well cause she's an established act. Bey has had no memorable hits in years worldwide, no shade.

[Kim Kardashian]

Beyonce (the celebrity, the brand) is definitely not local.

And from these receipts it looks like her music isn't local either (yes, her US success is higher but not so much higher that she is local).

[Chemist]

She is not local but she is not global either

i.e: BEYONCE (the album) has sold less copies than Rebel Heart and Shakira. in countries like Germany, France and Italy