[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by dwuw

Actually, Rihanna only has 5 albums on metacritic, and Gaga has 5 too.

Sorry Kaeli.

So now we're taking whole credit for C2C? How much lower, Monster?
Poor Tony when GaGa has nothing but love for the sexy old man.

[H-I-M]

Originally posted by ImsoLOUD

OK?! Like homegirl couldn't make it past her third era she'll be lucky to get through her fourth era. She is a fad, the sooner they accept it and move on the sooner we can all be at peace. With any luck she can get a reoccurring role on AHS.

So Gaga's "flop" existence had you so shook to the point of making fun of suicide ?

[Eóghan Scherzy]

After 5 pages of reply, i think we can all agree that this thread backfired



Disappointing, i expected more balance

[M A R C]

Originally posted by romonster

HumanitySector and some others are missing from this thread, indeed. Thanks for pointing out though.

Humanity and what others?
I need a list.

And don't bash us for dragging what you and your fellow monsters started.

[Clarksonator]

Useless discussion... Navy and Monsters need to stop

[Stark]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

So now we're taking whole credit for C2C? How much lower, Monster?
Poor Tony when GaGa has nothing but love for the sexy old man.

Without C2C, Gaga's average would be higher, but ok.

[RatedG²]

No amount of dragging equals self harm jokes.

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by dwuw

Actually, Rihanna only has 5 albums on metacritic, and Gaga has 5 too.

Sorry Kaeli.

Ok, you got me there.

But it's still only 2 points so who cares

Mess @ C2C finally being acknowledged tho

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by The Truth Is Sexy

By your logic, your fav couldn't outpeak Gaga's singles - who was "destroyed" by Katy - so I don't even know what's worse.

How is Rihanna "destoryed" by Katy when just yesterday it was confirmed that Rihanna is the first artist ever to cross 100M digital sales? Seems like Rihanna continues to be on the top and occasionally shares the limelight with her bff Kitty Kat.

[istan4badgalriri]

FFS outsold Applause, has more Vevo views, more Spotify streams (despite being released only less than 6 months ago), bigger impact. Yet it only had 1 live performance and Rihanna stopped promoting it just 2 weeks after its release.

BBHMM went platinum in the US (before the video came out) just 14 weeks after its release, it took 2 years for DWUW to achieve that despite being a pop-friendly song, performed at the AMAs. BBHMM also had a bigger impact than DWUW.

AO and G.U.Y. basically both flopped in the US (even though AO peaked at #15 on US iTunes while G.U.Y. barely cracked the Top 100). I could talk about the Tidal mess but let's not.....we all know what happened.

[suburbannature]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

So now we're taking whole credit for C2C? How much lower, Monster?
Poor Tony when GaGa has nothing but love for the sexy old man.

Not much to take credit for. A Tony Bennett album with a former pop star that could barely scan gold.

And at least that one is actually an LP unlike TFM, which they've been trying to pass as one of her four albums instead of C2C.

[Samuel.]

Originally posted by suburbannature

Doesn't matter if they go #1 if they don't sell anything after that.

A navy saying that a #1 doesn't matter???? OMFG I never thought I'd live to see it.

The low standars I guess.

[ImsoLOUD]

Originally posted by The Truth Is Sexy

Yeah Katy destroyed our fave, we know it. Since 2013, everyone keeps saying that. We got it. What does it have to do with the OP's question, tho?

By your logic, your fav couldn't outpeak Gaga's singles - who was "destroyed" by Katy - so I don't even know what's worse.

Well I can tell you. GaGa releasing basic generic popcorn dance music almost the equivalent of SIO yet still underperforming >>>>>> Rihanna releasing music completely different from her discography. I don't even get why R8 positions are so important. My fave is on her EIGHTH era while yours has already become a distant memory before even getting halfway there. You aren't even allowed to have this conversation with me.

[M A R C]

Originally posted by Samuel.

A navy saying that a #1 doesn't matter???? OMFG I never thought I'd live to see it.

The low standars I guess.

If you were more open minded you'd notice not all of us stan for success.

[Stark]

Originally posted by istan4badgalriri

AO and G.U.Y. basically both flopped in the US (even though AO peaked at #15 on US iTunes while G.U.Y. barely cracked the Top 100). I could talk about the Tidal mess but let's not.....we all know what happened.

AO was a new release while G.U.Y. wasn't, but ok!

[Wink]

Originally posted by NX127

Except, the R8 era won't end on the 3rd single. As a whole, it'll end up with a much better single sales total than ARTPOP.

Let's see how Gaga will do on her 8th era, though.

What happened to R8 changing music and dominating in 2015?

[suburbannature]

Originally posted by Samuel.

A navy saying that a #1 doesn't matter???? OMFG I never thought I'd live to see it.

The low standars I guess.

I'm not even a Rihanna fan.

A Monster not being able to read??? Shocked.

[GhostHaus]

Originally posted by ImsoLOUD

Well I can tell you. GaGa releasing basic generic popcorn dance music almost the equivalent of SIO yet still underperforming >>>>>> Rihanna releasing music completely different from her discography. I don't even get why R8 positions are so important. My fave is on her EIGHTH era while yours has already become a distant memory before even getting halfway there. You aren't even allowed to have this conversation with me.

I can't with this post
Gaga released a jazz album and sold millions of copies, probably more than R8 will sell.

[Bey_Rihstan]

Originally posted by Wink

What happened to R8 changing music and dominating in 2015?

What happened to album of the millennium, Artpop doing it in 2013?

[Wink]

Originally posted by Bey_Rihstan

What happened to album of the millennium, Artpop doing it in 2013?

I am not a Monster